A land registry directorate asked whether fees are due when implementing a court decision cancelling a construction-for-flats agreement and ordering the cancellation of the title of the share registered to the defendant company and its registration in the names of the former owners and their heirs. Part of the property is registered as a cultural asset requiring protection.
The Administration's opinion:
- No fee is charged on the portion attributable to the building registered as a cultural asset, under Article 21 of Law No. 2863.
- For the remaining portion, a fixed fee is charged under paragraph I/13-c of Tariff (4) for registration in the name of the living claimant.
- For registrations in the names of heirs, a proportional fee is charged under paragraph I/3-a of the same tariff.
The ruling is relevant to owners who obtain title cancellation and registration decisions in construction-for-flats disputes and to owners of properties including historic buildings.
Full text
Subject: Rate of title deed fee on registration made pursuant to a court decision
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the examination of your letter referred to above, the ruling request form and their annexes, it is understood that you asked for our opinion on whether a fee will be charged on the registration to be carried out by your Directorate pursuant to decision No. … (Docket No. …) of the … Civil Court of First Instance, which became final on 6/5/2025, concerning the property in … District, … Neighbourhood, block …, parcel …, and, if so, how it will be charged.
Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastral transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to the Law are subject to land registry and cadastral fees; paragraph (a) of item 3 of section "I- Land registry transactions" of Tariff (4) provides that a proportional fee is charged on the registered value on the partition, in kind or by subdivision, of immovables in the estate among statutory and appointed heirs, and paragraph (c) of item 13 provides that a fixed fee is charged (for each transaction) on all kinds of corrections of type and records other than those in paragraph (a).
The first paragraph of Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is charged from persons exempted from fees by special laws or on transactions exempted by them.
In addition, Article 21 of Law No. 2863 on the Protection of Cultural and Natural Property provides: "Immovable cultural property annotated in the land register as 'immovable cultural property requiring protection', and parcels that are immovable cultural and natural property on which an absolute building ban has been imposed because they are archaeological or natural sites, are exempt from all taxes, duties and fees..."
In this connection, the letter dated … No. … received from the Directorate of Istanbul Regional Board No. 6 for the Protection of Cultural Property states that:
- parcel …, block …, … Neighbourhood, … District is not within the "Bosphorus Foreground Area" and is outside the site area, and that the property was formed by merging parcel …, sheet …, block …, which is not registered as cultural property requiring protection, with parcel …, privately owned in the land register as a "wooden house with garden", which was registered as a group II cultural property requiring protection by decision No. … dated … of Istanbul Board No. III for the Protection of Cultural and Natural Property and for which a restitution project was approved,
- by decision No. … dated … of Istanbul Regional Board No. 6 for the Protection of Cultural Property it was decided that only the registered cultural property on parcel … could be exempt from tax, and that subsequently, following objection and judicial proceedings against that decision, Board decision No. … dated … stated that "decision No. … dated … of Istanbul Regional Board No. 6 for the Protection of Cultural Property is valid",
- accordingly, in line with decisions No. … dated … and No. … dated … of Istanbul Regional Board No. 6 for the Protection of Cultural Property, only the portion of parcel … relating to the building registered as cultural property requiring protection may benefit from the tax exemption, and the building(s) not registered as cultural property requiring protection may not benefit from the tax exemption.
In addition, from the examination of the court decisions annexed to your letter, it is understood that, in the action brought for the termination of the contract and for the cancellation of the title of the 50% share in parcel … (parcel … after merger) transferred to the defendant and its registration in the names of the claimants, on the grounds that, although the claimants fulfilled their obligations under the construction-for-flats contract dated … with journal No. … concluded at Beyoğlu 21st Notary concerning the property in … District, … Neighbourhood, sheet …, block …, parcel … and transferred half of their land shares to the defendant … İç ve Dış Ticaret A.Ş., the defendant company did not fulfil its obligations, decision No. … (Docket No. …) dated … of the 15th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal ruled:
- to terminate retroactively the "Construction-for-Flats Agreement and Promise to Sell Agreement in Official Form" dated … with journal No. … of Beyoğlu 21st Notary concluded between the parties,
- to cancel the title of the 386285/1369992 share registered in the name of the defendant … İç ve Dış Tic. A.Ş. in the 5,137.47 m² property consisting of a wooden house with garden and a masonry house with garage on parcel …, block …, sheet …, … Neighbourhood, … District, and to register in the land register the 117565/1369992 share in the name of claimant …, the 134360/1369992 share in the name of …, heir of …, and, of the 134360/1369992 share to be registered in the name of the deceased claimant …, the 67180/1369992 share in the name of heir … and the 67180/1369992 share in the name of …, heir of ….
Accordingly, pursuant to the court decision, for the property registered in … District, … Neighbourhood, sheet …, block …, parcel …:
- on the registration of the 117565/1369992 share in the name of …, no fee is to be charged on the portion attributable to the building registered as cultural property requiring protection, and a fee is to be charged on the remaining portion under paragraph I/13-c of Tariff (4) annexed to Law No. 492;
- on the registration of the 134360/1369992 share in the name of …, heir of …, no fee is to be charged on the portion attributable to the building registered as cultural property requiring protection, and a fee is to be charged on the remaining portion under paragraph I/3-a of Tariff (4) annexed to Law No. 492;
- on the registration, of the 134360/1369992 share to be registered in the name of the deceased claimant …, of the 67180/1369992 share in the name of heir … and the 67180/1369992 share in the name of …, heir of …, no fee is to be charged on the portion attributable to the building registered as cultural property requiring protection, and a fee is to be charged on the remaining portion under paragraph I/3-a of Tariff (4) annexed to Law No. 492.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.