A fuel station stated that a customer's vehicle was damaged after a rainwater grate at the station entrance was dislodged, and that the damage was invoiced to and paid by the company. Since the amount to be received from the insurer would be recorded as income, the company asked whether the damage invoice could be recorded as an expense.
The Administration stated that this damage payment, borne by the company without being based on a contract, a court judgment or a legal requirement, cannot be deducted in determining corporate income under Article 11(1)(g) of the Corporate Income Tax Law.
The ruling is relevant to businesses paying compensation to customers without a contract, court decision or legal obligation. For a deduction under Article 40(3) of the Income Tax Law, the payment must be based on one of these grounds.
Full text
Subject: Whether an amount paid for damage to a customer's vehicle may be deducted
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that you stated that the rainwater grate at the entrance of your fuel station, belonging to your business, was dislodged by a passing vehicle; that another vehicle coming behind it to refuel struck the dislodged, upright grate and was damaged; that the customer requested your company to cover the damage to the vehicle; that an application was made to the insurance company for the damage to be covered under the third-party liability insurance you had taken out; that the resulting damage amount was invoiced to your company; and that this amount was paid by your company, and that, since the damage amount to be received from the insurance will be recorded as income, you asked for our opinion on whether the damage invoice may also be recorded as an expense.
The first paragraph of Article 6 of Corporate Income Tax Law No. 5520, headed "Net Corporate Income", provides that corporate income tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers within an accounting period, and the second paragraph provides that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on business income apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 40 of Income Tax Law No. 193, headed "Deductible Expenses", provides:
"The deduction of the following expenses is accepted in determining net income:
1. General expenses incurred to obtain and maintain business income.
...
3. Damages, losses and compensation paid under a contract, a court judgment or a legal requirement, provided that they are related to the business;
..."
In addition, Article 11 of Corporate Income Tax Law No. 5520, headed "Non-Deductible Items", provides:
"(1) The following deductions are not accepted in determining corporate income:
...
g) Expenses for material and moral damages arising from offences of the entity itself, its shareholders, managers and employees, excluding compensation stipulated as a penalty clause in contracts.
..."
Furthermore, two fundamental principles apply in determining business income: the "accrual principle" and the "periodicity principle". Under the accrual principle, the income or expense must be finalised in terms of amount and nature; that is, in addition to the completion of the transaction giving rise to the income or expense, its amount and the payment terms of the receivable or payable arising from the transaction must also be determined. Under the periodicity principle, income and expenses must be allocated to the period to which they relate, and under this principle businesses must recognise their income and expenses on an accrual basis and match their revenue, income and profits with the costs, expenses and losses of the same period.
Within the framework of these provisions and explanations, the damage amount borne by your company due to the damage to the customer's vehicle, which is not based on a contract, a court judgment or a legal requirement, cannot be taken into account as an expense in determining corporate income under subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 11 of Corporate Income Tax Law No. 5520.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.