Of the deceased spouse's 29.70% shareholding in a joint stock company, 12.02% was acquired before 2002 and 17.68% after 2002. The surviving spouse asked whether the portion acquired after 2002 could be treated as her own right under the participation in acquired property regime, separated by a settlement record under Article 35/A of the Attorneys' Law, and declared without including it in the estate.
The Administration stated that liquidation of the matrimonial property regime precedes liquidation of the estate and that there is no legal obstacle to carrying out the liquidation on the basis of an Article 35/A record. The 12.02% acquired before 2002, plus the portion of the post-2002 shares determined after liquidation to belong to the deceased, must be included in the estate, with the shares declared under Article 10/2-d of the Inheritance Tax Law (at nominal value if unlisted).
The ruling is relevant to heirs carrying out a liquidation under the participation in acquired property regime on a spouse's death.
Full text
Subject: Participation in acquired property regime
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: …
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that:
- your spouse … died on …,
- your spouse held 29.70% of the shares of … A.Ş., of which 12.02% was acquired before 2002 and 17.68% was acquired by purchase for consideration after 2002 (in 2014) during the marriage,
- no other matrimonial property regime was chosen between the spouses and the participation in acquired property regime has applied since 01.01.2002,
and it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether, accepting that the 17.68% shareholding acquired by your deceased spouse after 2002 is acquired property, this portion can be treated as a right belonging to the surviving spouse under the participation in acquired property regime and separated, without being included in the estate in the inheritance and gift tax return, by an attorney's record drawn up under Article 35/A of Attorneys' Law No. 1136.
Inheritance and Gift Tax Law No. 7338 provides:
- in Article 1, that the transfer, by inheritance or gratuitously in any manner, from one person to another of property belonging to Turkish citizens and property located in Türkiye is subject to inheritance and gift tax;
- in Article 2(1), that the term "property" used in this Law means movable and immovable things capable of ownership and all other rights and receivables that can form part of an estate,
- in Article 10(1), that the inheritance and gift tax base is the value of the transferred property determined under the Tax Procedure Law (where the debts and expenses listed in Article 12 must be deducted, the amount remaining after these deductions); in Article 10(2), that taxpayers declare the property subject to inheritance and gift tax, for the purposes of the initial assessment, by valuing it using the valuation measures set out in this article and, for property not covered by this article, in accordance with the principles in the third section of the Tax Procedure Law on the valuation of assets; in Article 10(2)(a), that for those keeping books on the balance sheet basis, commercial capital is the equity determined according to the balance sheet for the calendar year preceding the date of death, and taxpayers may, if they wish, base the calculation of equity on a balance sheet drawn up as at the date of death; and in Article 10(2)(d), that shares are valued at the last transaction value within the three years preceding the date of death if listed on an exchange, and at nominal value if not listed or if listed but not traded within three years,
- in Article 11, that the valuation date of property subject to this tax is, for transfers by inheritance, the date the estate devolves and, for transfers otherwise, the date the property is legally acquired;
and Article 575 of the Turkish Civil Code states that the estate devolves upon death.
In addition, Article 10 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Law states that the tax office makes the initial assessment on the values declared by taxpayers according to the principles set out in the article, and that the taxes assessed are later completed according to the values of the transferred property determined under the Tax Procedure Law.
As understood from the above provisions, there is a two-stage assessment system in inheritance and gift tax, and in the initial assessment taxpayers must declare the value of the property subject to tax according to the valuation measures in Article 10 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Law. However, where the Law does not specify a valuation measure, the measures in the asset valuation section of the Tax Procedure Law are taken into account.
Accordingly, where a joint stock company shareholding is transferred by inheritance or gift, the asset transferred is not commercial capital but shares. Therefore, in the initial assessment, the tax base for the shares must be determined according to the provisions on the transfer of shares, not those on the valuation of commercial capital.
Furthermore, Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, which entered into force on 1/1/2002, adopted the "participation in acquired property" regime as the statutory regime between spouses, and the separation of property and community of property regimes as contractual property regimes.
In this context, Article 202 of Law No. 4721 provides that the participation in acquired property regime applies between spouses as the rule and that spouses may adopt one of the other regimes set out in the Law by a property regime contract; the system to which spouses who have not chosen one of the optional written property regimes on the division of their assets by contract, before or after marriage, are subject by law is the "statutory property regime". In other words, the "participation in acquired property regime" has applied between spouses as the statutory property regime from 1/1/2002, and even if they married before that date, spouses who have not set another division ratio by contract have become subject to this regime by law.
On the death of a spouse, if there is acquired property in the estate or the surviving spouse has acquired property, there are two kinds of liquidation: first, liquidation of the property regime arising from family law, and second, liquidation of the estate arising from inheritance law. Liquidation of the property regime takes precedence over liquidation of the estate. Since the division of the estate depends on the result of the property regime liquidation, liquidation of the property regime and determination of the participation claim are a preliminary issue for liquidation of the estate.
Since liquidation of the property regime between the surviving spouse and the deceased spouse is a prior legal step, the assets remaining in the deceased spouse's name after the surviving spouse has received (if any) their rights arising from the property regime between them form the estate. These rights of the surviving spouse arising from the property regime are separate from their status as heir. In liquidation of the statutory property regime, as a rule only the deceased spouse's "acquired property" is included. Acquired property comprises all assets acquired by the spouses during the marriage from the time they married after 1/1/2002, regardless of whose ownership they are in.
In addition, Article 35/A of Attorneys' Law No. 1136 provides:
"In matters and cases referred to them before a case is filed, or after a case is filed but before the hearing has begun, attorneys may, together with their clients, invite the other party to settle, limited to matters that the parties can obtain of their own will as a result of a claim. If the other party accepts this invitation and a settlement is reached, a record containing the subject, place and date of the settlement and the obligations to be performed by each party is signed jointly by the attorneys and their clients. These records constitute a judgment within the meaning of Article 38 of Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 dated 9/6/1932."
In this context, where the property regime ends due to the death of one of the spouses and there is a settlement record drawn up between the parties under Article 35/A of Law No. 1136 in the property regime liquidation for determining the estate, there is no legal obstacle to carrying out the property regime liquidation on the basis of that record.
Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, considering that:
- the shares of … A.Ş. held by your spouse …, who died on …, must, for the purposes of the initial assessment, be valued and declared under Article 10(2)(d) of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Law, that is, at the last transaction value within the three years preceding the date of death if listed on an exchange, or at nominal value if not listed or if listed but not traded within three years,
- 12.02% of those shares was acquired before 2002 and 17.68% after 2002,
the 12.02% of the company shares acquired before 2002, together with the portion of the 17.68% acquired after 2002 that is determined to belong to the deceased after the property liquidation to be carried out under the participation in acquired property regime, must be included in the estate and declared at the last transaction value within the three years preceding the date of death if listed on an exchange, or at nominal value if not listed or if listed but not traded within three years.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.