A taxpayer designing sub-games and characters within a main game on a non-resident company's online gaming platform, earning income from players' purchases with in-game digital currency, asked how this income is taxed.
For income tax, the Administration stated that since the income comes from in-game use rather than app store sales, it is not covered by the Repeated Article 20/B exemption and must be declared under the general provisions. For game design and graphics services actually provided to the foreign company, 80% of the income can be deducted under Article 89/13 if the conditions are met. For VAT, the service export exemption applies if the services are provided exclusively for customers abroad and benefited from abroad; if domestic and foreign use cannot be separated, VAT must be charged. The Article 17/4-a exemption does not apply.
The ruling is relevant to developers designing content and characters for international gaming platforms.
Full text
Subject: Tax treatment of income from game design services on international gaming platforms
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated … and numbered ….
In your ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that you design or develop sub-games and/or game characters within a main game for non-resident companies through online gaming platforms, that you earn income in the spending units valid in the games when these sub-games are played by players on the relevant platforms or when games and game characters and other items are purchased in-game with the digital spending units used by players, and that you earn this income not from sales of the main game or sub-games through electronic application sharing and sales platforms or online, but from the use in games of the games and/or virtual items you design; and our Directorate's opinion is requested on the position under the tax laws of the income earned from these activities.
INCOME TAX LAW
Article 37, headed "Definition of commercial profit", of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that profits arising from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are commercial profit.
Repeated Article 20/B of that Law, headed "Profit exemption for social content creation, services provided through the internet and similar electronic media and application development for mobile devices", provides:
"Profits earned by social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media from these activities, profits from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through these media, and profits earned by those developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt from income tax.
To benefit from this exemption, an account must be opened at a bank established in Türkiye and all revenue from these activities must be collected exclusively through that account.
Banks must withhold income tax at 15% on the revenue transferred to accounts opened for this purpose as at the transfer date, and declare and pay it in accordance with Articles 98 and 119 of the Law. No further withholding is made on this amount under Article 94.
Having earnings or revenues from other activities outside the first paragraph does not prevent taxpayers from benefiting from the exemption.
Those whose total profits within the first paragraph exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103, and those who do not collect all their revenue from the activity under the conditions in the second paragraph, cannot benefit from this exemption. There is no withholding obligation under Article 94(1) for those in this position.
Where it is established that the conditions for the exemption are not met, the tax under-assessed is collected with late payment interest and a tax loss penalty is imposed.
The President is authorised to reduce the withholding rate in this article to zero separately for each type of activity or to re-determine it by increasing it up to double; the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for applying the article."
Furthermore, Article 3, headed "Definitions", of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 318 provides:
"a) Electronic application sharing and sales platform: A platform, also defined as an application store, allowing users to browse and download online mobile applications developed and published using software development kits,
b) Mobile application: Software developed with special codes and designs for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets,
c) Mobile application developer: A natural person who develops applications in order to operate on electronic application sharing and sales platforms and makes the applications developed available to users on these platforms,
..."
- and Article 4, headed "Those who may benefit from the exemption, conditions for benefiting and special situations in applying the exemption":
"(1) The exemption may be used by natural persons who are social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media, natural persons earning income from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through these media, and natural persons developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets.
...
(17) Within the activity of application development for mobile devices, only profits earned through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt under that article. Income earned through these platforms such as paid application sales income, advertising income, in-app sales income, sponsorship income and paid subscription income will be taken into account within the exemption. On the other hand, profits earned outside electronic application sharing and sales platforms cannot be treated as within the exemption."
Furthermore, Article 89(1)(13), headed "Other deductions", of that Law provides:
"80% of the income earned exclusively from these activities by service businesses operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance after obtaining the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Türkiye to persons not resident in Türkiye and to those whose place of business, legal seat and business centre are abroad and used exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Türkiye, provided that all of it is transferred to Türkiye by the due date of the annual income tax return for the calendar year in which it is earned. ..."
Furthermore, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains explanations on the matter, states:
- in Section "10.5.2.2. The service being performed from Türkiye exclusively for a non-resident person and/or entity", that architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre and data storage services must be provided to persons not resident in Türkiye and to those whose place of business, legal seat and business centre are abroad, that these services must actually be provided, and that services such as assistance, consultancy and brokerage in these fields cannot be treated as within this scope,
- in Section "10.5.2.3. The invoice being issued in the name of the non-resident person and/or entity", that the invoice for the service must be issued in the name of the non-resident person and/or entity,
- in Section "10.5.2.4. Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing and data analysis services provided from Türkiye being used abroad", that the service provided must have been used abroad and that the service provided to the non-resident person and/or entity must not be related to their activities in Türkiye.
Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, the income you earn from developing games by designing sub-games and/or game characters within a main game through international online gaming platforms for the foreign company named …, providing 3D and 2D graphics, illustrations and new gaming experiences, when the sub-games you develop are played by players or the games and game characters you design are purchased in-game by players with digital spending units, must be declared in the annual income tax return under Article 85 of Law No. 193 and taxed under the general provisions, and you cannot benefit from the exemption in Repeated Article 20/B of that Law for income from this activity.
Furthermore, examination of your ruling request form and system records shows that, in addition to your other activities, you are also engaged in the activity with NACE code "741200 - Graphic Design and Visual Communication Activities, Publishing of Other Software, Publishing of Video Games".
On the other hand, 80% of the income you earn from actually providing services such as game development and game design, game character design, 3D and 2D graphics, illustrations and interface design to that foreign company through an international online gaming platform can be deducted in determining the income tax base, shown separately in the income tax return, under Article 89(1)(13) of the Income Tax Law, provided that all the conditions listed in that Law are met.
VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 4/1, that a service is any transaction other than a supply, deemed supply or import of goods, and that such transactions may take forms such as doing, processing, producing, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, storing, preparing, evaluating or leasing something, or undertaking not to do something,
- in Article 6/b, that a transaction being carried out in Türkiye means the service being performed in Türkiye or being benefited from in Türkiye,
- in Article 11/1-a, that services provided for customers abroad are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that for a service to be deemed provided for a customer abroad, it must be provided for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad,
- in Article 17/4-a, that supplies and services relating to profits taxed under Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law are exempt from VAT.
The General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
- in Section (II/A-2.1.) headed "Scope of the Exemption":
"For a service to be exempt from VAT under Article (11/1-a) of Law No. 3065, under Article (12/2) of the same Law:
- the service must be provided for a customer abroad,
- the service must be benefited from abroad.
That the service was provided for a customer abroad is documented by an invoice or similar document issued in the name of the customer abroad.
Benefiting from the service abroad means that the service provided in Türkiye for the customer abroad relates to the customer's business, transactions and activities abroad and is not related to its activities in Türkiye."
- in Section (II/F-4.26.) headed "Exemption for Social Content Creation, Services Provided Through the Internet and Similar Electronic Media and Application Development for Mobile Devices":
"Article (17/4-a) of Law No. 3065 exempts from VAT supplies and services relating to profits taxed under Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law.
This exemption applies from 1/1/2022 to supplies and services relating to profits earned from these activities by natural persons who are social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through social network providers and natural persons developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets.
In addition, from 1/1/2024, the exemption will also apply to supplies and services relating to profits earned from these activities by natural persons who are social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media, and natural persons earning income from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through the internet and similar electronic media.
Accordingly, no VAT is calculated on supplies and services relating to profits taxed under Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law.
Supplies and services relating to profits not within Repeated Article 20/B of the Income Tax Law are naturally not exempt and will be taxed under the general provisions..."
Accordingly, where the services of designing and developing sub-games and/or game characters within a main game provided by your company through online gaming platforms are provided exclusively for a customer (users) abroad and benefited from abroad, these services can be treated as a service export under Article 11/1-a of Law No. 3065.
However, where no distinction can be made between domestic and foreign use of these services, the income you earn from these services that are not provided exclusively for customers abroad cannot be treated as a service export, and VAT must be calculated on these services under the general provisions.
Furthermore, since the income you earn from this activity is not taxed under Repeated Article 20/B of Law No. 193, the services relating to this income cannot be exempted from VAT under Article 17/4-a of Law No. 3065.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.