A person who edits their own books and old public domain books, designs covers and sells them on Amazon as e-books and printed books asked how this income is taxed, whether it falls within the Article 20/B exemption and what the position would be if the same sales were made through app stores.
The Administration stated that editing and selling public domain books is a commercial activity, not a self-employed profession, and is taxed as commercial profit. Selling books through e-commerce sites or app stores is not covered by the Article 20/B exemption. Income from selling one's own books is exempt under Article 18 of the Income Tax Law; however, if annual income exceeds the fourth income bracket, the exemption does not apply and a return must be filed.
The ruling is relevant to people selling their own or public domain works on digital platforms.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of income from editing public domain books and one's own books and selling them through websites and mobile apps
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated 15.03.2024 with document registration number 27295.
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you design covers for books you have written or old public domain books and offer them for sale as e-books in Word file form on the e-commerce site amazon.com, that books can also be sold in physical form through that site, and that where a physical book is sold, the printing and dispatch of the e-book you prepared to the buyer are carried out by the e-commerce site, you request an opinion on how the income from these sales will be taxed, whether this income can be treated as within Repeated Article 20/B of Income Tax Law No. 193, and how taxation will apply if you carry out the same activity on app stores such as Google Play Store and Apple Store.
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 18, which sets out exemptions for self-employment profits:
"Revenue earned by authors, translators, sculptors, calligraphers, painters, composers, computer programmers and inventors and their legal heirs from publishing their works such as poems, stories, novels, articles, scientific research and studies, computer software, interviews, caricatures, photographs, films, videotapes, radio and television scripts and plays in newspapers, magazines, on computers and the internet, radio, television and video, or from selling their works in the form of books, CDs, diskettes, paintings, sculptures and sheet music and their patents, or from assigning, transferring or leasing their existing rights in them, is exempt from Income Tax.
...
Those whose total profits within this article exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 cannot benefit from this exemption. There is no withholding obligation under Article 94(1) for those in this position."
- in Article 37 headed "Definition of commercial profit": "Profits arising from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are commercial profit...",
- in Repeated Article 20/B headed "Profit exemption for social content creation, services provided through the internet and similar electronic media and application development for mobile devices": "Profits earned by social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media from these activities, profits from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through these media, and profits earned by those developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt from income tax..."
- in Article 65 headed "Definition of self-employment profit": "Profits arising from all kinds of self-employed professional activities are self-employment profit. Self-employed professional activity is the performance of work that relies on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital and is not of a commercial nature, in one's own name and on one's own account under personal responsibility without being subject to an employer..."
Section (1.1) headed "Self-Employed Professional Activity" of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 221 states:
"...whether an activity is a self-employed professional activity depends on whether it has the elements of:
- relying on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital,
- being carried out in one's own name and on one's own account under personal responsibility without being attached to an employer,
- being continuous.
These elements set the boundaries between self-employment profit and commercial profit on the one hand, and between self-employment profit and employment on the other. In addition, continuity distinguishes self-employed professional activity from occasional self-employed activity.
..."
Furthermore, Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 318, which sets out the procedures and principles for the profit exemption for social content creation, services provided through the internet and similar electronic media and application development for mobile devices, states:
- in Article 3 headed "Definitions":
"a) Electronic application sharing and sales platform: A platform, also defined as an application store, allowing users to browse and download online mobile applications developed and published using software development kits,
b) Mobile application: Software developed with special codes and designs for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets,
c) Mobile application developer: A natural person who develops applications in order to operate on electronic application sharing and sales platforms and makes the applications developed available to users on these platforms,
..."
- in Article 4 headed "Those who may benefit from the exemption, conditions for benefiting and special situations in applying the exemption":
"(1) The exemption may be used by natural persons who are social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media, natural persons earning income from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through these media, and natural persons developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets.
...
(17) Within the activity of application development for mobile devices, only profits earned through electronic application sharing and sales platforms are exempt under that article. Income earned through these platforms such as paid application sales income, advertising income, in-app sales income, sponsorship income and paid subscription income will be taken into account within the exemption. On the other hand, profits earned outside electronic application sharing and sales platforms cannot be treated as within the exemption."
Commercial profit essentially arises from a source that combines capital and labour. All activities carried out on the basis of this source and within a continuous organisation are commercial activities. Carrying out a self-employed professional activity within a commercial organisation does not change the nature of the income earned; it only requires it to be treated as commercial profit for those earning it, subject to the principles and provisions applicable to commercial profit.
In self-employed professional activity, the main element is that the activity relies on personal work, scientific or professional knowledge and expertise rather than capital. This element is the most important feature distinguishing self-employed professional activity from commercial activity and shows that profits from such activities are mainly the product of labour. In self-employed professional activity, an organisation based solely on labour is not sufficient; the labour generating the income must also rely on scientific or professional knowledge and expertise.
According to the above provisions and explanations, since your activity of re-editing public domain books, designing book covers and selling them through an e-commerce site is a commercial activity rather than a self-employed professional activity relying on scientific or professional knowledge and expertise, the income you earn from this activity must be taxed under the commercial profit provisions.
Furthermore, the exemption in Repeated Article 20/B of that Law may be used by natural persons who are social content creators sharing content such as text, images, audio and video through the internet and similar electronic media, natural persons earning income from services such as individual courses, training, data processing and development and product promotion provided through these media, and natural persons developing applications for mobile devices such as smartphones or tablets. Accordingly, since selling books through e-commerce sites or app stores is not among the activities exempted under Repeated Article 20/B of that Law, you cannot benefit from that exemption for this activity.
On the other hand, you can benefit from the exemption in Article 18 of the Income Tax Law for profit from selling books you have written through an e-commerce site; where the profit you earn from selling these works in the relevant calendar year exceeds the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 of the Income Tax Law, the exemption cannot be used and the profit must be declared in the annual income tax return.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.