A company publishing AI and mobile game apps on Google Play and the App Store, earning in-app purchase and subscription income, asked whether it can issue bulk invoices to various domestic and foreign customers, apply the VAT service export exemption, and use the Article 10/1-ğ deduction and Article 32/7 reduced rate for the foreign portion.
The Administration stated that since the apps also target users in Türkiye, the condition of software services provided exclusively to customers abroad is not met and the Article 10/1-ğ deduction cannot be applied. If the apps are made exclusively for customers abroad, they are a service export, so the corporate tax rate is reduced by 5 points and no VAT is charged; if they are also used in Türkiye, these benefits do not apply. On bulk invoicing, the company must apply directly to the Revenue Administration.
The ruling is relevant to software and gaming companies selling through app stores.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of income from mobile apps downloaded from the App Store and Google Play Store
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: …
In the ruling request form referred to above, it is stated that your company publishes mobile apps developed in the fields of artificial intelligence and mobile games on Google Play and the App Store, that the software of these apps is developed entirely by you, that the apps offer in-app virtual product purchases and subscription services aimed particularly at customers abroad, and that the distinction between domestic and foreign customers can be documented; and an opinion is requested on whether, since users' billing information (name, identity number, address, etc.) is insufficient and the number of customers is very large for sales through the relevant platforms, invoices can be issued in the name of various domestic customers and various foreign customers; whether, if invoices can be issued in the name of various foreign customers, the export exemption in Article 11(1)(a) of the Value Added Tax Law can be used; and whether the deduction in Article 10(1)(ğ) and the reduction in Article 32(7) of the Corporate Tax Law can be used for profit from the part of these sales relating to foreign customers.
CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate profit earned by taxpayers in an accounting period.
Article 10, headed "Other deductions", of the same Law provides:
"(1) In determining the corporate tax base, the following deductions are made from corporate profit in order, provided they are shown separately on the corporate tax return:
...
ğ) 80% of the profit earned exclusively from these activities by service businesses operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance after obtaining the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Türkiye to persons not resident in Türkiye and to those whose place of business, legal seat and business centre are abroad and used exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Türkiye, provided that all of it is transferred to Türkiye (wording amended by Article 59 of Law No. 7491; effective 28.12.2023 for income and profits earned from 1/1/2023) by the due date of the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is earned.
To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the customer abroad.
The President is authorised to reduce the rate in this subparagraph to zero or increase it to 100% by service area and profit amount, and to reduce the amount of profit to be transferred to Türkiye to zero or increase it to its statutory level, and the Ministry of Finance is authorised, after obtaining the opinion of the relevant ministries, to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this subparagraph and its supervision.
..."
Article 32 of that Law provides:
"(1) Corporate tax is charged at 25% on corporate profit. However, corporate tax on the corporate profits of banks, companies within the scope of Law No. 6361, electronic payment and money institutions, authorised foreign exchange institutions, asset management companies, capital markets institutions, insurance and reinsurance companies, pension companies, and companies operating as parties to the contract in projects carried out under the build-operate-transfer model under Law No. 3996 dated 8/6/1994 on Having Certain Investments and Services Carried Out Under the Build-Operate-Transfer Model and in projects carried out under the public-private partnership model under Law No. 6428 dated 21/2/2013 on Construction, Renovation and Procurement of Services by the Ministry of Health under the Public-Private Partnership Model and Amending Certain Laws and Decree Laws is charged at 30%.
...
(7) The corporate tax rate is applied with a 5-point reduction to the profits of exporting entities earned exclusively from exports. This reduction also applies to the profits of manufacturing or supplier entities from export activities carried out through foreign trade capital companies or sectoral foreign trade companies under an intermediated export agreement.
...
(9) The reduced rates in the seventh and eighth paragraphs are applied to the corporate tax rate after the other reductions under this article have been applied."
Section "10.5. Services provided from Türkiye to non-resident persons and entities" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, issued on the matter, contains detailed explanations.
Section "32.1.2.5. Applying the corporate tax rate with a 5-point reduction to profits from export activities" of the same Communiqué states:
"Exporting entities may apply the corporate tax rate in force in the relevant period with a 5-point reduction, exclusively to profits from both goods and service exports. In applying this article, service export covers services provided for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad. In addition, profits from roaming services provided in Türkiye for customers abroad under international roaming agreements, provided they are reciprocal, will also be accepted among the profits to which the rate is applied with a 5-point reduction.
..."
Accordingly, since the payments made to you for publishing mobile apps developed in the fields of artificial intelligence and mobile games and offering in particular in-app virtual product purchases and subscription services, delivered by your company to Google and Apple, relate to profits in the nature of in-app purchase income, and since these apps are aimed at Türkiye as well as abroad and therefore do not meet the condition of relating to software services provided exclusively for customers abroad, the profits earned from these activities cannot be deducted in determining corporate profit under Article 10(1)(ğ) of the Corporate Tax Law.
On the other hand, considering that the 5-point reduction in the corporate tax rate in Article 32(7) of that Law applies to profits of exporting entities earned exclusively from exports and that service export covers services provided for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad, if the artificial intelligence and mobile games developed by your company are made exclusively for use by customers abroad, they will be treated as a service export and the corporate tax rate will be applied to these profits with a 5-point reduction.
However, if these apps are used in Türkiye as well as abroad, the profits from the service not provided exclusively for customers abroad cannot be treated as a service export, and the reduced rate cannot be applied to profits from these services.
VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT,
in Article 4, that a service is any transaction other than a supply, deemed supply or import of goods, and that such transactions may take forms such as doing, processing, producing, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, storing, preparing, evaluating or leasing something, or undertaking not to do something,
in Article 6/b, that a transaction being carried out in Türkiye means the service being performed in Türkiye or being benefited from in Türkiye,
in Article 11/1-a, that export supplies and services relating to them, and services provided for customers abroad, are exempt from VAT,
in Article 12/2, that for a service to be treated as a service export, it must have been provided for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad.
The sub-section "II/A-2.1. Scope of the Exemption" of Section "II/A-2. Service Export" of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
"For a service to be exempt from VAT under Article (11/1-a) of Law No. 3065, under Article (12/2) of the same Law:
- the service must be provided for a customer abroad,
- the service must be benefited from abroad.
That the service was provided for a customer abroad is documented by an invoice or similar document issued in the name of the customer abroad.
Benefiting from the service abroad means that the service provided in Türkiye for the customer abroad relates to the customer's business, transactions and activities abroad and is not related to its activities in Türkiye."
Accordingly, if the artificial intelligence and mobile games developed by your company are made exclusively for use by customers abroad, the service will be treated as a service export under Article 11/1-a of the VAT Law (provided the other conditions for service export are also met) and no VAT will be calculated on the price of this service.
However, if these artificial intelligence and mobile games are used in Türkiye as well as abroad, the income from the service not provided exclusively for customers abroad cannot be treated as a service export, and VAT must be calculated on these services under the general provisions.
TAX PROCEDURE LAW
Article 227(1) of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides: "Unless otherwise provided in this Law, records kept under this Law and relating to relationships and transactions with third parties must be documented."
Article 229 of that Law defines an invoice as "a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work to show the amount owed by the customer in return for the goods sold or work done", and Article 231/5 provides that the invoice must be issued within at most seven days from the delivery of the goods or performance of the service, that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to shorten this period or to require the invoice to be issued at the moment the goods are delivered or the service performed, taking into account the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, field of activity, sector or type of tax liability separately or together, and that invoices not issued within these periods are deemed not to have been issued at all.
Article 232 provides:
"First and second class merchants, those whose profit is determined under the simplified method and farmers required to keep books must issue invoices for goods sold or work done to:
1. First and second class merchants;
2. Self-employed professionals;
3. Merchants whose profits are determined under the simplified method;
4. Farmers required to keep books;
5. Artisans exempt from tax;
and these must request and obtain invoices.
Where the price of goods purchased or work commissioned by others from first and second class merchants, those whose profit is determined under the simplified method and farmers required to keep books exceeds (TL 6,900 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 556), or even if it is less (TL 6,900 from 1.1.2024 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 556) where they so request, the seller of the goods or the person doing the work must issue an invoice."
Repeated Article 257(1)(1) of the same Law authorises the Ministry of Finance to set accounting procedures and principles by groups of taxpayers and professions, and to determine and change the nature, form and mandatory content of books and documents kept under this Law and of those it deems appropriate to be kept or issued in addition.
Accordingly, since whether bulk invoices can be issued in the name of domestic or foreign customers instead of each customer for these transactions must be assessed by the Ministry of Finance under Repeated Article 257 of the Tax Procedure Law, you must apply directly to the Revenue Administration.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.