A municipality asked whether its economic enterprise, set up within its budget and liable to corporate tax, can deduct payments for cooks, waiters and cleaners employed through a service purchase from the municipality's own company.
The Administration stated that payments under a service purchase contract with the municipal company for such staff employed at the social facilities are deductible in determining corporate profit, provided they are met from the economic enterprise's own resources. The ruling also refers to the arm's length principle for related party transactions (Article 13 of the Corporate Tax Law).
The ruling is relevant to municipal economic enterprises and municipal companies.
Full text
Subject: Deductibility of payments for staff employed at a business established within a municipality
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: …
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether payments for cooks, waiters or cleaners employed through a direct service purchase from the municipality's own company by the enterprise, which has no legal personality, was established within the budget to carry out commercial activities on behalf of your Municipality and is liable to corporate tax, can be deducted as expenses.
Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that the profits of capital companies, cooperatives, public economic entities, economic enterprises belonging to associations or foundations, and joint ventures are subject to corporate tax; Article 2 lists public economic entities among corporate taxpayers; and paragraph 3 of that article provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or affiliated to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and bodies, whose activities are continuous and which are not capital companies or cooperatives, are public economic entities.
Article 6(1) of that Law, headed "Net corporate profit", provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate profit earned by taxpayers within an accounting period, and Article 6(2) that the commercial profit provisions of the Income Tax Law apply in determining net corporate profit.
Article 38 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that commercial profit on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of equity in the enterprise at the end and beginning of the accounting period; that values added to the business by the owner(s) during the period are deducted from this difference and values withdrawn are added; and that in determining commercial profit in this way the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and Articles 40 and 41 of this Law are observed.
Article 40 of Law No. 193 lists the expenses deductible in determining net profit, and paragraph (1)(1) states that general expenses incurred to earn and maintain commercial profit may be deducted.
For general expenses incurred to earn and maintain commercial profit to be deductible, there must be a clear and strong causal link between the expense and the earning and maintenance of profit, the expense must be proportionate to the importance of the business, it must not be arbitrary (that is, it must be necessarily incurred to earn profit), no intangible asset must be acquired in return, and it must not be an expense to be included in cost. In addition, these expenses must be supported by documents such as invoices and documents in lieu of invoices and tracked in the statutory records.
Furthermore, Article 13 of Law No. 5520 provides:
- in paragraph 1, that where corporations purchase or sell goods or services with related persons at a price or amount determined contrary to the arm's length principle, the profit is deemed to have been wholly or partly distributed in a disguised manner through transfer pricing, and that purchase, sale, manufacturing and construction transactions, leasing and renting transactions, borrowing and lending of money, and transactions requiring bonuses, wages and similar payments are in all cases treated as purchases or sales of goods or services,
- in paragraph 2, that related person means the corporation's own shareholders, the natural persons or entities with which the corporation or its shareholders are associated, and natural persons or entities to which it is directly or indirectly linked in terms of management, control or capital or which it holds under its influence; that for relationships arising directly or indirectly through shareholding to be within disguised profit distribution, at least 10% shareholding, voting or dividend rights are required; that parties are also deemed related where there are at least 10% voting or dividend rights directly or indirectly without a shareholding relationship; and that these ratios are considered collectively for related persons,
- in paragraph 3, that the arm's length principle means that the price or amount applied in the purchase or sale of goods or services with related persons is consistent with the price or amount that would arise if no such relationship existed,
...
Detailed explanations on the subject are given in General Communiqué No. 1 on Disguised Profit Distribution through Transfer Pricing.
Section "3.1.2- Natural Person or Entity with Which the Corporation or Its Shareholders Are Associated" of that Communiqué states:
"The expression natural person with whom the corporation is associated means persons other than natural persons who are its own shareholders, such as the other natural person partners of partnerships in which the corporation is a partner and the corporation's employees.
On the other hand, where the relationship of employees with the corporation is solely an employer-employee relationship, the corporation and the employee are not treated as related persons with respect to wage payments made. However, transactions between the corporation and its employees other than the employment relationship described above are treated as transactions with related persons.
..."
Under the above provisions and explanations, payments made to the Municipality's company under a service purchase contract for staff such as cooks, waiters or cleaners employed at the social facilities operated by your economic enterprise, which is affiliated to your Municipality and liable to corporate tax due to its commercial activity, may be deducted in determining corporate profit, provided they are met from the resources of your economic enterprise.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.