A university revolving fund enterprise asked about declaring the export of services (VAT Law Art. 11/1-a) and printed book (Art. 13/n) exemptions, notifications based on the IPA II VAT exemption certificate, notification of tax-free payments to academic staff under Article 58/k of Law No. 2547, and notifications for the stamp duty exemption under Law No. 5746.
The Administration's views were:
- Article 58/k payments must be shown in the payroll, with the 85% portion excluded from the income tax base; no separate notification is required.
- A notification is filed for the stamp duty exemption under Law No. 5746 in accordance with Communiqué Serial No. 5; no stamp duty notification is required for Article 58/k transactions.
- Under IPA II, the notification obligation lies with the Union Contractor; the supplier has no obligation to file the IPA Purchase Notification.
- For exports of services, documents are submitted with a petition within the filing period of the declaration period; printed book supplies are declared on line code 335 of the return.
The ruling is relevant to university revolving funds and suppliers to EU-funded projects.
Full text
Subject: Notification obligations of a university revolving fund enterprise
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form with document registration date ….
In the ruling request form referred to above, our Directorate's opinion is requested on:
- how notifications are to be made for supplies and services carried out with exemption under Articles 11/1-a and 13/n of Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065,
- how notifications are to be made on the basis of the VAT exemption certificate under Article 28/2 of the IPA II Framework Agreement approved by Law No. 6647,
- since 85 per cent of income paid to academic staff working under Article 58/k of Law No. 2547 is to be paid to them without any tax deduction, whether payments to academic staff on which no income tax or stamp duty is withheld are to be reported,
- how notifications are to be made for those benefiting from the stamp duty exemption under Law No. 5746 for stamp duty on contracts.
INCOME TAX
Article 61 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides: "Wages are money and goods given in return for services to persons working subject to an employer and attached to a particular workplace, and benefits provided and representable in money. The fact that wages are paid under names such as allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial liability compensation), appropriation, increment, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense allowance or other names, or determined as a certain percentage of profit provided it is not in the nature of a partnership relationship, does not change their nature."
Article 94(1) of the same Law provides: "Public administrations and institutions, public economic institutions, other corporations, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed professionals required to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural profits on the balance sheet or agricultural operating account basis are obliged to withhold tax, to be offset against the income tax of the recipients, when making the payments listed in the following subparagraphs (including advances) in cash or on account. 1. From wages paid to employees and payments deemed wages listed in Article 61 (other than those benefiting from exemptions), under Articles 103 and 104, ..."
Furthermore, Article 238(1) of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides that employers are obliged to keep a (payroll) for wages they pay each month.
Article 58(k) of Higher Education Law No. 2547 provides: "Income earned from research and development, design and innovation projects and activities within university-industry cooperation is collected in a separate account of the revolving fund enterprise. No deductions, including those under paragraph (b), are made from this income. 85 per cent of the income to be paid to academic staff working in this context is paid to the relevant academic staff without any tax deduction. The remaining amount is used for the purposes specified in paragraph (b). Projects and activities to be considered within this scope are decided, upon the application of the academic staff member, with the permission of the university executive board."
Article 2, headed "Definitions", of Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities provides:
"a) Research and development activity (R&D): creative work carried out on a systematic basis to increase the stock of knowledge, including knowledge of culture, humanity and society, and to use it to devise new processes, systems and applications, environment-friendly product design or software activities, and activities that provide scientific and technological advancement in their field, focus on a scientific and technological uncertainty, and whose outputs are original, experimental, and of scientific and technical content,
b) Innovation: processes created with the idea of a new product, service, application, method or business model that can respond to social and economic needs, can be successfully introduced to existing markets or can create new markets, and the results of those processes,
...
ç) R&D project: a project carried out by a researcher on scientific principles, whose purpose, scope, general and technical description, duration, budget, special conditions, in-kind and/or cash support to be provided by other institutions, organisations, natural and legal persons, and principles for sharing resulting intellectual property rights have been determined, and which defines every stage of R&D activities,
...
j) Design activity: all innovative activities aimed at increasing, developing, improving and differentiating the functionality of a product or products, with the potential to create added value and competitive advantage in industry and other fields deemed appropriate by the President,
..."
Article 5(1), headed "Activities not deemed R&D and innovation", of the Implementation and Audit Regulation on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities states that certain activities such as marketing activities, market scanning, market research or sales promotion, quality control and research in the social sciences are not treated as R&D and innovation for the purposes of the Regulation.
Furthermore, university-industry cooperation aims to bring our industry to a sustainable, high-technology structure able to produce innovative, highly competitive and high value-added products, and university-industry cooperation projects aim to contribute to commercialising the knowledge and technology in universities and public research centres and institutes by transferring them to industry as products or processes in line with the needs of organisations established in Türkiye that undertake to apply the project results in Türkiye.
Within the framework of these provisions and explanations, where a project or activity is a research, development, design or innovation project or activity as defined above carried out within university-industry cooperation under Article 58(k) of Law No. 2547, and the projects and activities to be considered in this scope are decided with the permission of the university executive board, 85 per cent of the income to be paid to academic staff working on these projects may be paid without deducting income tax and stamp duty.
Accordingly, a payroll must also be drawn up for payments to academic staff under Article 58(k) of Law No. 2547, or these payments must be shown in the payrolls drawn up for other wage payments, and 85 per cent of these payments shown in the payroll must not be included in the income tax base.
In addition, no notification is required on this matter.
STAMP DUTY
Article 3(4) of Law No. 5746 on Supporting Research, Development and Design Activities provides that no stamp duty is levied on documents drawn up in relation to all kinds of R&D and innovation activities and design activities within the scope of the Law.
Explanations on the stamp duty exemption in that Law are given in General Communiqué Serial No. 5 on Law No. 5746, published in Official Gazette No. 29843 of 30/09/2016.
The section of that Communiqué headed "Responsibility of institutions and organisations carrying out transactions" states:
"(1) Institutions and organisations such as notaries, public offices and other public bodies carrying out transactions with the stamp duty exemption must, within one month following the transaction date, complete the "Notification on Those Benefiting from the Stamp Duty Exemption for R&D, Innovation and Design Activities and Order-Based Projects" in Annex-1 of this Communiqué for stamp duties relating to documents drawn up for R&D, innovation or design activities that were not collected from the parties or not withheld on payment due to the exemption, and submit it to the tax office to which the parties are attached for income or corporate tax. Documents to which the exemption was applied may be reported collectively in the same notification, provided the one-month period is not exceeded.
(2) Where a notification on the income tax withholding incentive is submitted for wage payments to R&D and support personnel within the income tax withholding incentive under Law No. 5746, there is no obligation to submit a separate notification for documents drawn up for these wage payments to which the stamp duty exemption also applies. However, where the stamp duty exemption is applied to documents relating to wages paid to personnel not included in the income tax withholding incentive notification, a separate notification is submitted for these documents to the tax office where the withholding return is filed."
Accordingly, your Institution has a notification obligation for transactions carried out under Law No. 5746 in accordance with the explanations in the Communiqué.
Furthermore, Article 58/k of Higher Education Law No. 2547 provides: "Income earned from research and development, design and innovation projects and activities within university-industry cooperation is collected in a separate account of the revolving fund enterprise. No deductions, including those under paragraph (b), are made from this income. 85 per cent of the income to be paid to academic staff working in this context is paid to the relevant academic staff without any tax deduction. The remaining amount is used for the purposes specified in paragraph (b)."
Accordingly, since neither Higher Education Law No. 2547 nor Stamp Duty Law No. 488 contains any provision on notification of transactions carried out under Article 58/k of Law No. 2547, you have no notification obligation for transactions carried out under that paragraph.
IPA II FRAMEWORK AGREEMENT
The Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance (IPA II) Framework Agreement was signed between our country and the European Union, approved by Law No. 6647, published in Official Gazette No. 29393 of 21/6/2015 and entered into force on 22/6/2015. The procedures and principles for the tax exemptions under that Agreement were set by IPA II General Communiqué No. 1, published in Official Gazette No. 29623 of 13/2/2016.
That Communiqué states:
- in section "4.2.2.6. Use of the VAT Exemption Certificate":
"Where the invoice amount to be issued by the Supplier for goods, services and works to be obtained under the Union Contract using the VAT Exemption Certificate, or the total amount of purchases from the same Supplier under the same Union Contract (excluding VAT), exceeds TL 15,000, the Union Contractor will first conclude a "Supply Contract" with the Supplier, a sample of which is annexed to the Communiqué (ANNEX-7). Where the Grant Beneficiary approves that the goods, services and works subject to that Supply Contract are within the Union Contract by annotating "The purchases in this Supply Contract were made under Union Contract dated ...... numbered ......", no VAT will be calculated for these supplies of goods, services and works.
Where the Union Contractor is also the Grant Beneficiary, the Supply Contract must be approved by the Union Contractor itself if a natural person, or by the manager of the legal entity authorised to sign in the matter if a legal person.
The Union Contractor and the Supplier may freely determine the form of the Supply Contract, provided it contains the information in ANNEX-7.
Where the Supply Contract concluded with the Union Contractor and approved by the Grant Beneficiary and the Union Contractor's VAT Exemption Certificate are presented to it, the Supplier will obtain copies of the Supply Contract and the certificate certified "True Copy" by the Union Contractor and will not calculate VAT, annotating the invoice or similar document issued to the Union Contractor with "No VAT has been calculated on the basis of VAT Exemption Certificate dated ............ numbered .............. under Article 28/2 of the IPA II Framework Agreement approved by Law No. 6647".
Where the invoice amount issued by the Supplier for goods, services and works to be obtained by the Union Contractor under the Union Contract using the VAT Exemption Certificate and the total amount of purchases from the same Supplier under the same Union Contract (excluding VAT) are below TL 15,000, no VAT will be calculated in the invoice or similar document issued with the above annotation on presentation of the VAT Exemption Certificate and provision of a copy, without the requirement to conclude a Supply Contract and have it approved by the Grant Beneficiary.
The Union Contractor will transfer its VAT-free purchases made under the Union Contract using the VAT Exemption Certificate, its purchases with VAT made without using the certificate and its other expenditure outside the scope of VAT to the "IPA Purchase Notification" annexed to the Communiqué (ANNEX-8), have it approved by the Grant Beneficiary with the annotation "The purchases and expenditure in this notification were made under Union Contract dated ........ numbered ......", and send it with wet signature attached to a petition, starting from the beginning of the calendar year following the date the VAT Exemption Certificate was obtained, by the last day of February each year, for contracts ending within the year by the end of the second month following the month in which the contract term ends, and in any case where VAT refund is claimed by the date of the refund claim:
- to the tax office directorate/revenue office written on the VAT Exemption Certificate,
- where no VAT Exemption Certificate has been obtained, to the tax office directorate/revenue office authorised for VAT refunds specified in section "4.2.3.1.1." of this Communiqué.
For contracts whose term exceeds a calendar year, notifications in subsequent years will be made cumulatively including prior periods, and the final notification will also be made electronically (CD, DVD, flash disk, etc.). Where there are no purchases, this will be notified to the relevant authority by letter within the same periods. Where no VAT Exemption Certificate has been obtained, the IPA Purchase Notification will be submitted only if a VAT refund is claimed.
Where the Union Contractor is also the Grant Beneficiary, the notification must be approved, where public administrations within general government are the Union Contractor, by the senior administrative superior of these administrations authorised to sign in the matter; for other Union Contractors, by the natural person Union Contractor itself, or for legal person Union Contractors by the senior manager of the legal entity authorised to sign in the matter.
The obligation to submit the IPA Purchase Notification (ANNEX-8) starts after the VAT Exemption Certificate is obtained. With the first notification, all purchases made from the contract signing date will be reported."
- in section "4.2.4.5. Joint and Several Liability":
"Where Suppliers apply the VAT exemption contrary to the provisions of this Communiqué, those to whom the supply or service is made are jointly and severally liable together with the Suppliers making the supply or service for the tax, penalties, surcharges and interest lost due to the exemption. Suppliers to whom a VAT Exemption Certificate is presented carry out transactions within the exemption in accordance with the procedures and principles in the Communiqué. Where it is later determined that the transaction did not meet the conditions for exemption from the outset or that the conditions were later breached, the tax lost and the related penalties, interest and surcharges are sought from the Union Contractor to whom the supply or service was made within the exemption. The Supplier's deduction and refund claims are carried out under the procedures and principles in the relevant sections of the Communiqué."
Accordingly, although Suppliers to whom a VAT Exemption Certificate is presented must carry out transactions within the exemption in accordance with the IPA II Framework Agreement General Communiqué, where it is later determined that the transaction did not meet the conditions for exemption from the outset or that the conditions were later breached, the tax lost and the related penalties, interest and surcharges relating to the ineligible expenditure determined under the Union Contract must be sought from the Union Contractor.
Furthermore, within the framework of the above explanations, where Suppliers apply the VAT exemption in a manner not in accordance with the IPA II Framework Agreement General Communiqué, the Suppliers will also be jointly and severally liable together with the Union Contractors for the tax lost due to the exemption and the related penalties, surcharges and interest.
On the other hand, since under that Communiqué the notifications required for supplies of goods, services and works under the Union Contract must be made by the Union Contractor, you have no obligation to submit the IPA Purchase Notification (ANNEX-8) for the goods and services you provide as Supplier.
VALUE ADDED TAX
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 11/1-a, that export supplies and services relating to these supplies, and services performed for customers abroad, are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that for a service to be deemed performed for customers abroad, it must be performed for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad,
- in Article 13/n, that supplies of printed books and periodicals, other than those sold in sealed bags under the Law No. 1117 of 21/6/1927 on the Protection of Minors from Harmful Publications, are exempt from VAT.
The General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
- in section (II.A.2.2.), headed "Documentation and Declaration of the Exemption":
"The exemption for exports of services is documented by the service invoice issued to the customer abroad. Copies of service invoices certified by company officers or a list showing them are submitted. These documents must be submitted with a petition within the filing period in the period in which the exemption is declared. For declaring the exemption, it is not mandatory to have obtained the payment document for the service (a document evidencing that the price has been brought into Türkiye, a bank receipt, etc.).
The export exemption is declared in VAT Return No. 1 for the tax period in which the service is performed. The declaration is made using line code 302 in the "Transactions within Full Exemption" table on the "Exemptions-Other Transactions Giving Rise to Refund" tab of the return for the period in which the service for the customer abroad is completed/performed.
The price of the service is entered in the "Supply and Service Amount" column of this line. In the "VAT Borne" column, the VAT included in this service, calculated taking into account the explanations in section (IV/A3) of the Communiqué, is entered. Where no refund is claimed, "0" is entered in the "VAT Borne" field."
- in section (II.B.17.3.), headed "Declaration of the Exemption":
"Supplies within this exemption are declared through line code 335, "Supplies of Printed Books and Periodicals", in the "Transactions within Full Exemption" table on the "Exemptions-Other Transactions Giving Rise to Refund" tab of the VAT return for the tax period in which the supply is made. The VAT-exclusive amount of the exempt supply is entered in the "Supply and Service Amount" column of this line, and the total VAT shown in documents for purchases and expenses relating to these supplies in the "VAT Borne" column. Taxpayers not wishing to claim a refund should enter "0" in the "VAT Borne" column."
Accordingly, documents relating to your transactions under Article 11/1-a of VAT Law No. 3065 must be submitted with a petition within the filing period in the period in which the exempt transaction is declared.
On the other hand, for supplies under Article 13/n of VAT Law No. 3065, it is sufficient to declare them through line code 335, "Supplies of Printed Books and Periodicals", in the "Transactions within Full Exemption" table of the VAT return for the tax period in which the supply is made.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.