A taxpayer selling medical products online and in-store and also providing paramedical foot care services asked whether income from medical foot health and care services is commercial profit or self-employment income, and what VAT rate applies to the service.
The Administration's view:
- Since the activity is carried on through a combined capital-labour source within a continuing organisation and the products used in foot care are also traded, the income is taxed as commercial profit.
- Awareness activities and medical foot care and training provided by podiatrists to healthy individuals are not within item 21 of List (II).
- Services such as nail prosthesis, bandage, dressing and foot support applications, and assessing, preventing and treating foot problems, nail pathologies and corns, are subject to 10% VAT if provided by authorised persons based on a specialist physician's diagnosis and referral; otherwise the general rate (20%) applies.
The ruling is relevant to podiatrists and foot care centres.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of medical foot care services and the applicable VAT rate
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated …...
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that you are a taxpayer of the ….. Tax Office Directorate with tax identification number ….., and that in addition to your ongoing activities under NACE code 47.91.14 "Retail Trade via Radio, TV, Mail or the Internet" and NACE code 47.74.01 "Retail Trade of Medical and Orthopaedic Products in Specialised Stores (Including Other Medical Products Excluding Spectacles)", you started on 18/4/2023 the activity under NACE code 86.90.90 "Other paramedical human health services n.e.c. (occupational therapy, aromatherapy, speech therapy, homeopathy, nutritional therapy, foot care, dental hygiene and similar services provided by authorised persons other than physicians) (outside hospitals)", our Directorate's opinion is asked on the value added tax (VAT) rate to be applied to medical foot health and care services and on whether the income to be earned from performing that service counts as commercial profit or self-employment income.
I- INCOME TAX LAW
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 37, headed "Determination of commercial profit": "Profits arising from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are commercial profit. ...",
- in Article 65, headed "Definition of self-employment income": "Profits arising from all kinds of self-employed professional activities are self-employment income. Self-employed professional activity is the carrying out, in one's own name and for one's own account under personal responsibility without being subject to an employer, of work based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital and not commercial in nature.",
- in Article 66, headed "Self-employed persons": "Those who carry on self-employed professional activity as their usual profession are self-employed persons. Being continuously engaged in another work or duty besides the self-employed professional activity does not change this status. ..."
Section (1.1) of Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 221, headed "Self-Employed Professional Activity", states: "...whether an activity is a self-employed professional activity depends on whether it has the elements of being based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital, being carried out in one's own name and for one's own account under personal responsibility without depending on an employer, and being continuous."
Commercial profit essentially arises from a combined capital-labour source. All kinds of activities carried out based on this source and within a continuing organisation are commercial activities. Carrying out a self-employed professional activity within a commercial organisation does not change the nature of the income earned; it only requires it to be treated as commercial profit for those earning it and makes it subject to the principles and provisions on commercial profit. In commercial activity there is a continuing organisation consisting of capital and labour, and the share of capital and labour within this organisation may vary depending on the type, nature and size of the activity. In self-employed professional activity, unlike commercial profit, it is not capital but personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise that comes to the fore.
Whether an activity is a self-employed professional activity depends on whether it has the elements of being based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital, being carried out in one's own name and for one's own account under personal responsibility without depending on an employer, and being continuous.
Under these provisions and explanations, since the medical foot health and care activity is essentially carried out based on a combined capital-labour source and within a continuing organisation, and the products and materials used in foot health and care activity are also traded, the income earned within these activities must be taxed under the provisions on determining commercial profit.
II- VALUE ADDED TAX
VAT rates applied to goods and services are determined, on the authority given by Article 28 of VAT Law No. 3065 and within the limits set out in that article, by the Council of Ministers before the amendment by Decree Law No. 700 and by the President after it.
In this context, VAT rates were applied at 1% for supplies and services in List (I) annexed to Council of Ministers Decision (BKK) No. 2007/13033, 8% for supplies and services in List (II), and 18% for taxable transactions not in these lists; by Presidential Decision No. 7346, published in Official Gazette No. 32241 dated 7/7/2023 and entering into force on 10/7/2023, this rate was set at 10% for supplies and services in List (II) and 20% for taxable transactions not in the relevant lists, while no change was made to the VAT rate for supplies and services in List (I).
Item 21 of List (II) annexed to that BKK provides for "Preventive medicine, diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation services for human or animal health (including services for the improvement of animal breeds) performed by natural or legal persons authorised by the relevant Ministries or by laws, services provided by physicians or through physicians to those performing these services, and ambulance services", and these services are subject to VAT at 10% (8% before 10/7/2023).
In this context, to determine whether services provided by podiatrists can be treated as within item 21 of List (II) annexed to the BKK, the letter received from the ….. General Directorate on the nature of these services states:
- all health professionals in Additional Article 13 of Law No. 1219 on the Practice of Medicine and Its Branches are accepted as professionals assisting diagnosis and treatment, and podiatrists should also be treated within this scope,
- the podiatrist profession is defined in paragraph (1)(e) of that article as a health technician who has graduated from an associate degree podiatry programme, provides services for protecting and caring for individuals' foot health, and treats patients' feet based on the relevant specialist physician's diagnosis and referral for treatment,
- under paragraph (2) of the same article, health professionals other than physicians and dentists cannot plan treatment by directly diagnosing diseases and cannot write prescriptions, and the details of the work and duties of health professionals and the working conditions and job and duty descriptions of other professionals working in health services are regulated by a regulation to be issued by the Ministry of Health,
- in Annex 1 to the Regulation on the Job and Duty Descriptions of Health Professionals and Other Professionals Working in Health Services, issued under this provision, the job and duty descriptions of podiatrists are set as:
"a) Takes part in work to raise awareness of foot health and protection.
b) In healthy individuals, performs medical foot care and provides training on this subject.
c) Based on the relevant specialist physician's diagnosis and referral for treatment, performs nail prosthesis applications and bandage, dressing, toe pad and foot support applications, and takes part in assessing, preventing and treating foot health problems, nail pathologies and corns."
From the above provisions, it is understood that podiatrists are professionals assisting diagnosis and treatment and cannot plan treatment by directly diagnosing diseases or write prescriptions, and services relating to "work to raise awareness of foot health and protection" and "medical foot care and training provided to healthy individuals" stated in their job and duty descriptions cannot be treated as within item 21 of List (II) annexed to BKK No. 2007/13033.
However, services listed among podiatrists' job and duty descriptions under that legislation, such as:
- performing nail prosthesis applications,
- performing bandage, dressing, toe pad and foot support applications,
- taking part in assessing, preventing and treating foot health problems, nail pathologies and corns,
may be treated as within item 21 of List (II) annexed to that BKK and subjected to VAT at 10% (8% before 10/7/2023), provided they are performed by natural or legal persons authorised by the relevant ministries or by laws and based on the relevant specialist physician's diagnosis and referral for treatment; where these services do not meet this condition, they must be subjected to VAT at the general rate (20% from 10/7/2023, 18% before that date).
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.