A company operating within the exemption in a technopark asked whether the corporate tax and VAT exemptions apply to maturity and exchange differences arising from these activities.
The Administration's view:
- Exchange and maturity difference income on receivables arising from activities carried on in the technopark is within the Provisional Article 2 exemption of Law No. 4691.
- Exchange difference income on foreign currency balances in bank accounts is not within the exemption.
- For VAT, maturity and exchange differences arising later on supplies and services are included in the base and VAT is calculated at the rate on the transaction date; however, no VAT is calculated on maturity and exchange difference invoices relating to supplies and services exempt under VAT Law Provisional Article 20.
The ruling is relevant to software and R&D companies in technoparks selling in foreign currency.
Full text
Subject: Tax treatment of maturity and exchange differences arising from technopark activities
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated ….
In your ruling request form referred to above, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the exemption applies for corporate tax and value added tax (VAT) purposes to maturity and exchange differences arising from your exempt activities carried on in the technopark.
I- CORPORATE TAX LAW
Provisional Article 2 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691, published in Official Gazette No. 24454 dated 6/7/2001, provides: "Profits earned by management companies within the scope of this Law and profits earned by income and corporate taxpayers operating in the Zone exclusively from software, design and R&D activities in this Zone are exempt from income and corporate tax until 31.12.2028. ..."
Section "5.12.2.4. Determination of the exempt profit amount" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
"The exemption in Provisional Article 2 of Law No. 4691 is a profit exemption, and the whole of the profit found by deducting the expense and cost items incurred for the exempt activities from the revenue earned from those activities will be exempt from corporate tax.
For determining the exempt profit and, in this context, the corporate tax base, revenue, cost and expense items within and outside the scope of the Law must be tracked separately, revenue, cost and expense items of exempt activities must not be associated with other activities, and records must be kept so as to ensure this separation.
Where exempt activities within the scope of the Law result in a loss, these losses cannot be deducted from profits relating to other non-exempt activities.
Income that taxpayers operating in the Zone earn from commercial transactions outside the scope of Law No. 4691 and extraordinary income cannot be treated as within the exemption. In this context, interest income from investing cash, exchange differences arising from foreign currency assets and income from disposal of economic assets will not be treated as within the exemption.
Aid provided as capital support on condition of repayment from other institutions to income and corporate taxpayers operating in the Zone is in the nature of debt, so this aid will not be included in commercial profit.
On the other hand, support amounts provided as grants by TÜBİTAK and similar institutions under the relevant legislation for exempt R&D and design projects to taxpayers operating in technology development zones, and all kinds of donations and aid of this nature by other institutions, will be included in corporate profit and benefit from the exemption."
As also stated in the Communiqué, profits within the software, design and R&D activities in the Zone are treated as within the exemption, and exchange differences arising on foreign currency receivables relating to these activities until they are collected are also within the exemption. However, income from investing cash, even if earned from R&D activities, and exchange differences arising from the valuation of foreign currencies are not within that exemption. Likewise, income earned outside software, design and R&D activities and extraordinary income are outside the exemption.
Under these provisions and explanations:
- exchange difference and maturity difference income relating to receivables arising from activities carried on in technology development zones will be within that exemption, since it is treated as income from commercial transactions within Law No. 4691,
- exchange difference income arising on foreign currency balances in bank accounts cannot be treated as within the exemption in Provisional Article 2 of the Technology Development Zones Law.
II- VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 20, that in supplies and services the base is the consideration for these transactions, and that the term consideration means the total of money, goods and benefits, services and values provided in other ways and representable in money, received in any manner whatsoever from, or owed by, the person receiving the goods or the service or those acting on their behalf in return for these transactions,
- in Article 24/c, that various income such as maturity differences, price differences, exchange differences, interest and premiums, and all kinds of benefits, services and values provided under names such as service and similar, are included in the base,
- in Provisional Article 20, that supplies and services in the form of system management, data management, business applications, sectoral, internet, game, mobile and military command and control application software produced exclusively in these zones by entrepreneurs operating in technology development zones and specialised technology development zones under Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691, during the period in which their profits are exempt from income or corporate tax, are exempt from VAT.
The General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
- in section (III/A-5.3), headed "Exchange Differences":
"In transactions where the price is expressed in foreign currency or indexed to foreign currency, where the price is paid partly or wholly after the date of the chargeable event, exchange differences arising in favour of the seller are included in the VAT base. Accordingly, in calculating the exchange differences to be included in the base, exchange differences corresponding to the price of goods and services are taken into account, and exchange differences arising on the VAT calculated are not included in the base.
...
Accordingly, for a favourable exchange difference arising between the date of the supply or service and the date the price is collected, the seller issues an invoice and calculates VAT by applying to the exchange difference shown on the invoice the rate applicable to these transactions on the date of the supply or service.
Where an exchange difference arises in favour of the buyer on the date the price is collected, the buyer must issue an invoice to the seller for the exchange difference and calculate VAT at the rate on the date of the supply and service."
- in section (IV/D-5.), headed "Payments Arising After the Period in Which the Exempt Transaction Took Place":
"After the exempt transaction takes place, certain payments (maturity differences, exchange differences, claims, etc.) may arise in favour of or against the seller. Such payments arising in relation to exempt transactions are not subject to VAT. Since these amounts affect the VAT base, they must be taken into account in calculating the maximum amount of tax that may be refunded.
Payments arising in favour of the person carrying out the exempt transaction are declared in the return for the relevant period in which they arise, in line with the declaration method of the main transaction."
Section (II-G/2.) of that Communiqué, headed "Supplies and Services Provided in Technology Development Zones and Specialised Technology Development Zones", sets out the procedures and principles for applying the exemption under Provisional Article 20 of the VAT Law.
Accordingly, maturity and exchange differences arising later in relation to supplies and services must be included in the VAT base and VAT calculated on this amount at the VAT rate in force on the date of the supply and service. However, no VAT will be calculated on maturity and exchange difference invoices arising later in relation to your supplies and services exempt under Provisional Article 20 of the VAT Law.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.