Land of a company under TMSF trusteeship, mortgaged to a bank, was sold by the TMSF to a third party by tender, and part of the price will be paid against the bank debt. The company asked whether the profit attributable to the part paid to the bank is exempt under Corporate Tax Law Article 5/1-f and whether the VAT Law Article 17/4-m exemption applies to the sale.
The Administration's view:
- The 5/1-f exemption covers profit from transferring property to a bank or the TMSF; since the land was sold by the TMSF to a third party, there is no transfer to the TMSF and the exemption does not apply. The provision in Article 20 of Law No. 6758 concerns the TMSF's powers and has no effect for the exemption. The 5/1-e exemption may be used if its conditions are met.
- The 17/4-m exemption applies in proportion to the amount of the price passing to the Fund; since the whole price passes to the company, it does not apply.
- If real estate trading is not among the company's main activities and the land has been in its assets for more than two full years, the sale is VAT-exempt under Article 17/4-r.
The ruling is relevant to companies under TMSF trusteeship and sales of mortgaged property.
Full text
Subject: Profit exemption on the TMSF's sale of company land mortgaged to a bank
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: a) …. b) ….
In the ruling request form referred to in (a) and your petition referred to in (b), it is stated that:
- the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (TMSF) was appointed as trustee for the management and supervision of your company by decision …. under Decree Law No. 674,
- by approval No. …. of the Fund Presidency, it was decided to include the company within commercial economic integrity, and …. was formed by the TMSF,
- a mortgage was established by …. on the land registered in the company's name,
- a sale tender for that land was held by the TMSF, it was sold on …., and TL …. of the land sale price will be paid against the …. debt,
and our opinion is asked on whether the part of the profit from the sale of the land to be paid to the bank is exempt from tax under Article 5/1-f of the Corporate Tax Law, and whether the exemption in Article 17/4-m of the Value Added Tax Law can be applied to this sale.
I. CORPORATE TAX
Sub-paragraphs (e) and (f) of Article 5(1) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, headed "Exemptions", before amendment by Article 19 of Law No. 7456, provide:
"(1) The following profits are exempt from corporate tax:
...
e) 75% of profits from the sale of participation shares held in entities' assets for at least two full years, and founder's shares, usufruct shares, pre-emptive rights held for the same period, and participation units of investment funds giving rise to exempt profits under sub-paragraph (a) of this paragraph, and 50% of profits from the sale of immovables held in their assets for the same period.
This exemption applies in the period in which the sale is made, and the exempt part of the sale profit is held in a special fund account on the liabilities side until the end of the fifth year following the year of sale. However, the sale price must be collected by the end of the second calendar year following the year of sale. Taxes not accrued in time due to the exemption corresponding to the sale price not collected within this period are deemed lost.
Taxes not accrued in time due to the exemption applied are deemed lost for the part of the exempt profit transferred within five years in any way to another account other than addition to capital, withdrawn from the business or transferred by limited liable entities to their head office. This provision also applies where the business is liquidated within the same period (excluding transfers and divisions under this Law).
...
Profits earned by entities engaged in securities or real estate trading and leasing from the sale of assets held for this purpose are outside the exemption.
f) the whole of the profits attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from transferring to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, against these debts, immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors; and 50% of the profits from the sale of immovables (including immovables subject to financial leasing whose every right of disposal the lessor has taken over by mutual agreement of the parties against financial leasing receivables under legal proceedings due to the lessee's default in financial leasing transactions under Law No. 6361), and 75% of the profits from the sale of the others, of such assets acquired in this way by banks, financial leasing or financing companies..."
Section "5.7.1. Exemption for entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the TMSF, and for their guarantors and mortgagors" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains detailed explanations on the subject, states:
"By Article 5(1)(f) of the Corporate Tax Law, the whole of the profits attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from transferring to banks or to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, against these debts, immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities subject to legal proceedings due to their debts to banks or indebted to the Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors, has been exempted from corporate tax.
Entities using this exemption must have been subject to legal proceedings under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 due to their debts to banks or be indebted to the TMSF.
The exemption may be used by entities subject to legal proceedings due to bank debts or indebted to the TMSF, and by their guarantors liable to corporate tax or corporate taxpayers giving mortgages on behalf of these entities.
The assets subject to the exemption are immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights.
On the other hand, the profit that may benefit from the exemption is limited to the amount attributable to the part, used to settle these debts, of the proceeds from the sale or other transfer of those assets to banks or the TMSF against the debts..."
Furthermore, Article 20 of Law No. 6758 on the Adoption with Amendments of the Decree Law on Certain Regulations within the Scope of the State of Emergency, headed "Powers of the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund relating to sale and liquidation", provides: "(1) The powers given to the Fund by Banking Law No. 5411 dated 19/10/2005 regarding banks/companies whose shareholder rights excluding dividends and management and supervision have been taken over by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, and their assets, apply by analogy to the trusteeship duty given to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund by this Law and to sale or liquidation transactions, regardless of whether these companies or their owners are indebted to the Fund and whether there is a Fund attachment on their assets..."
Accordingly, the provision in Article 20 of Law No. 6758 that the powers given to the Fund regarding companies whose management and supervision have been taken over by the TMSF and their assets apply by analogy in the transactions in that article, regardless of whether the Company is indebted to the Fund and whether there is a Fund attachment on its assets, concerns the use of the TMSF's powers under that Law and has no effect regarding the corporate tax exemption to be applied to profits from the sale of immovables belonging to companies transferred to the TMSF.
Under the provisions and explanations above, the exemption in Article 5(1)(f) of the Corporate Tax Law covers profit from transferring to banks or the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund immovables, participation shares, founder's shares, usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights due to the debts of corporate taxpayers and their guarantors and mortgagors; where the land in your company's assets is sold by the TMSF to third parties by tender, since no transfer of immovables to the TMSF within Article 5(1)(f) of the Corporate Tax Law will take place, the profit from the sale cannot be exempted from corporate tax under that sub-paragraph.
However, provided the conditions in Article 5(1)(e) of the same Law are met, you may benefit from the corporate tax exemption under that sub-paragraph regarding the sale profit.
II. VALUE ADDED TAX
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye in the course of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/4-r, that transfers and supplies by sale of participation shares and immovables (the word immovable was removed as of 15/7/2023 by Article 7 of Law No. 7456) held in entities' assets for at least two full years, transfers and supplies of immovables and participation shares (including sales at auction premises) to banks, financial leasing and financing companies against the debts of those indebted to them and their guarantors, and transfers and supplies of these immovables and participation shares by financial leasing and financing companies, are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 17/4-m, that under the Banking Law, supplies of goods and rights to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund and their supply by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (including sale at auction premises), supplies of goods and rights forming the collateral of receivables taken over by this Fund for the purpose of collecting them (including sale at auction premises), and supplies of the assets of companies whose shareholder rights excluding dividends and management and supervision have been taken over, for the purpose of collecting the Fund's receivables (including sales at auction premises), are exempt from VAT,
- in Provisional Article 43, that for immovables in entities' assets before 15/7/2023, the provisions before the amendment made to Article 17(4)(r) of this Law by the Law creating this article apply.
The General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
- in section (II/F-4.12.): "Under the Banking Law, supplies of goods and rights to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund and their supply by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (including sale at auction premises), supplies of goods and rights forming the collateral of receivables taken over by this Fund for the purpose of collecting them (including sale at auction premises), and supplies of the assets of companies whose shareholder rights excluding dividends and management and supervision have been taken over, for the purpose of collecting the Fund's receivables (including sales at auction premises), are exempt from VAT. This exemption is applied in proportion to the amount of the transaction price passing to the Fund."
- in section (II/F-4.16.):
"By the amendment made to Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065 by Article 7 of Law No. 7456, published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, the VAT exemption for transfers and supplies by sale of immovables held in entities' assets for at least two full years has been abolished.
On the other hand, under Provisional Article 43 added to Law No. 3065 by Law No. 7456, the VAT exemption as before the amendment made by Law No. 7456 to Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065 will continue to apply to transfers and supplies by sale, by entities from 15/7/2023, of immovables registered in entities' assets before 15/7/2023.
Under Article (17/4-r) and Provisional Article 43 of Law No. 3065, transfers and supplies by sale of participation shares held in entities' assets for at least two full years and of immovables registered in entities' assets before 15/7/2023 are exempt from VAT, but supplies by entities trading in the exempt assets of such immovables and participation shares held in their assets for this purpose are outside the exemption.
In calculating the period of holding in assets for at least two full years for the sale to third parties by the originator and lessee of participation shares and immovables registered in entities' assets before 15/7/2023 transferred to asset leasing companies under Article (17/4-u) of Law No. 3065 and to financial leasing companies, participation banks and development and investment banks under Article (17/4-y), the periods during which the participation shares and these immovables were in the assets of asset leasing companies, financial leasing companies, participation banks and development and investment banks are also taken into account.
..."
- in section (II/F-4.16.1.1):
"Provisional Article 43, added to Law No. 3065 by Law No. 7456 published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, provides: "For immovables in entities' assets before the entry into force of this article, the provisions before the amendment made to Article 17(4)(r) of this Law by the Law creating this article apply."
In this context, the VAT exemption will continue to apply to transfers and supplies by sale, by entities from 15/7/2023, of immovables in entities' assets before 15/7/2023.
For the exemption to be applied to the sale of immovables (land, plots, buildings) and participation shares, they must have been registered in the entities' assets for at least 2 full years (730 days).
In calculating the period of holding in assets for at least two full years, the periods during which these immovables were in the assets of asset leasing companies, financial leasing companies, participation banks and development and investment banks within the exemptions in Articles (17/4-u) and (17/4-y) of Law No. 3065 are also taken into account.
The exemption does not apply to supplies of immovables held in their assets for this purpose by entities trading in the exempt assets (habitually buying and selling or leasing immovables).
The exemption applies to transfers and supplies made by sale. Transfers and supplies made as donations or gifts are outside the exemption.
..."
- in section (II/F-4.16.1.2): "By the amendment made to Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065 by Article 7 of Law No. 7456, published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, the VAT exemption for transfers and supplies by sale of immovables registered in entities' assets was abolished as of 15/7/2023, and from this date transfers and supplies by sale of immovables recorded in entities' assets will be subject to VAT under the general provisions."
Furthermore, from the examination of your ruling request form and its annexes, it has been determined that the sale of that land took place on ….
Accordingly, under Article 17/4-m of the VAT Law, the exemption for supplies of goods and rights to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund and their supply by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (including sale at auction premises), supplies of goods and rights forming the collateral of receivables taken over by this Fund for the purpose of collecting them (including sale at auction premises), and supplies of the assets of companies whose shareholder rights excluding dividends and management and supervision have been taken over, for the purpose of collecting the Fund's receivables (including sales at auction premises), is applied in proportion to the amount of the transaction price passing to the Fund.
In this framework, since it is understood that in the sale by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund to third parties of the land belonging to …., no amount of the transaction price passes to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund and the whole of the sale price passes to ….., that sale cannot be treated as within Article 17/4-m of Law No. 3065.
On the other hand, where real estate trading is not among your company's main activities and the immovable has been in your company's assets for more than two full years, the sale of that land will be exempt from VAT under Article 17/4-r of Law No. 3065.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.