In a dispute on ending co-ownership, the parties reached agreement through mandatory pre-suit mediation, and a civil court of peace gave the agreement an enforceability annotation. One co-owner applied to the land registry to take over the other co-owners' shares for consideration, and the question was at what rate the fee would be charged on this transaction.
The Administration's view:
- Mediation is a precondition to suit in ending co-ownership; an agreement with an enforceability annotation has the nature of a court judgment and no suit can be filed on the agreed matters. The share transfer is therefore treated as a sale through dissolution of co-ownership (şüyuun izalesi).
- Where the proportional fee calculated under Tariff (4) I/20-a for each transfer and acquisition is below the minimum fixed fee, one minimum fixed fee is charged per property from the transferor and from the transferee, regardless of the number of transfers.
- Where the calculated proportional fee exceeds the minimum, the proportional fee is collected.
The ruling is relevant to property co-owners ending co-ownership through mediation.
Full text
Subject: Title deed fee on a land registry transfer under a mediation agreement bearing an enforceability annotation
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form and its attachments referred to above, it is understood that:
- ….., ….., ….., ….., ….., ….. and ….. reached agreement by signing, on ….. at ….. Mediation Office, a "Mediation Agreement Document as a Precondition to Suit in Disputes on the Division of Movables and Immovables and Ending of Co-Ownership" regarding their requests to end co-ownership over various immovables,
- an enforceability annotation was given to that agreement document by decision of ….. Civil Court of Peace dated ….. with Docket No. ….. and Decision No. …..,
- after this judgment became final on ….., by an application made to your Directorate by ….., a request was made for the transfer to him/her, for a total consideration of ……….. TL, of the shares of the other co-owners in the immovables registered in ….. province, …. district, …. village, ….. locality, block ….. parcel ….; …… village, ….. locality, block …., parcels …., …., …., within the scope of the mediation agreement,
- an opinion is requested on at what rate the fee will be collected under Fees Law No. 492 on the land registry transaction to be carried out on this request.
As is known, Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to this Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; and sub-paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) annexed to the Law provides that, on transfer and acquisition of immovables for consideration, under a contract of care until death, or under barter provisions, a proportional fee is required separately for the transferor and the transferee on the property tax value of the immovable, not less than the declared transfer and acquisition price (in cases of compulsory enforcement and dissolution of co-ownership, on the sale price; in expropriations, on the assessed price).
On the other hand, by Article 14 of Law No. 7440 on the Restructuring of Certain Receivables and Amending Certain Laws, published in Official Gazette No. 32130 dated 12/3/2023, the sentence "However, in transfers and acquisitions relating to each immovable sold through dissolution of co-ownership under paragraph I/20-a, the minimum fixed fee to be charged under this paragraph is charged once from each of the transferor and the transferee, without regard to the number of transfers and acquisitions." was added to the paragraph of Tariff (4) annexed to Fees Law No. 492 before its repealed last paragraph, reading "The minimum amount of proportional fees in land registry and cadastre transactions is 101.20 liras." (346.10 TL for 2025), and this provision entered into force as of 12/3/2023.
Under this amendment, in sales of immovables through dissolution of co-ownership, where a minimum fixed fee must be charged because the proportional fee calculated for each transfer and acquisition under sub-paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) annexed to Law No. 492 is below the minimum fixed fee, one minimum fixed fee must be charged per immovable from the transferors and the transferees, regardless of the number of transfers and acquisitions; and where the proportional fee calculated for each transfer and acquisition exceeds the minimum fixed amount, the existing practice of collecting the calculated proportional fee will continue.
On the other hand, Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes provides in Article 1 headed "Purpose and Scope",
"(1) The purpose of this Law is to regulate the procedures and principles to be applied in resolving civil disputes through mediation.
(2) This Law applies, including those with a foreign element, only to the resolution of private law disputes arising from acts or transactions over which the parties can freely dispose. However, disputes involving allegations of domestic violence are not suitable for mediation."
in Article 18 headed "Agreement of the Parties",
"(1) The scope of the agreement reached at the end of the mediation activity is determined by the parties; if an agreement document is drawn up, it is signed by the parties and the mediator.
(2) If the parties reach an agreement at the end of the mediation activity, they may request an annotation on the enforceability of this agreement document. If mediation was applied for before a suit was filed, the annotation on enforceability may be requested from the civil court of peace where the mediator serves. If mediation was applied for while a suit is pending, the annotation may be requested from the court hearing the suit. An agreement containing this annotation is deemed a document in the nature of a court judgment.
(3) Granting the enforceability annotation is non-contentious jurisdiction and the examination is made on the file. However, in family law disputes suitable for mediation, the examination is made with a hearing. The scope of this examination is limited to whether the content of the agreement is suitable for mediation and compulsory enforcement. A fixed fee is charged on the application to court for an enforceability annotation on the agreement document and, if the party concerned appeals the resulting decisions. If the parties wish to use the agreement document in another official transaction without obtaining an enforceability annotation, stamp duty is also charged at a fixed amount.
(4) Except where the laws make an enforceability annotation mandatory, an agreement document signed together by the parties and their lawyers and the mediator, or, in commercial disputes, by the lawyers and the mediator, is deemed a document in the nature of a court judgment without an enforceability annotation.
(5) If agreement is reached at the end of the mediation activity, the parties cannot file a suit on the matters agreed."
and in Article 18/B headed "Mediation as a precondition to suit in certain disputes",
"(1) In the following disputes, having applied to a mediator before filing a suit is a precondition to suit:
a) Disputes arising from a lease relationship, except provisions on eviction of leased immovables through enforcement without judgment under Law No. 2004.
b) Disputes on the division of movables and immovables and ending of co-ownership.
c) Disputes arising from Condominium Law No. 634 dated 23/6/1965.
ç) Disputes arising from neighbour rights.
(2) If the parties agree at the end of the mediation process, the agreement document is drawn up observing the limitations, procedures and principles in the laws relating to the immovable.
(3) Obtaining an enforceability annotation on an agreement document drawn up under this article is mandatory, and the annotation is obtained from the civil court of peace where the immovable is located for agreement documents relating to immovables, and where the mediator serves for other agreement documents. In its examination of agreement documents relating to immovables, the court reviews the content of the agreement as to whether it is suitable for mediation and compulsory enforcement and whether the limitations, procedures and principles in the laws relating to the immovable have been observed; in this context it may request information or documents from institutions or organisations and may hold a hearing where necessary.
(4) Article 18 applies to other matters relating to granting the enforceability annotation on the agreement document.
(5) One of the parties to an agreement document on the transfer of an immovable or the creation of a limited real right on an immovable may request registration from the land registry directorate after the enforceability annotation is given. The registration request is fulfilled by the land registry directorate without drawing up an official deed, after the necessary examination and assessment under the legislation on the immovable."
Under the provisions and explanations above, considering that in disputes on the division of movables and immovables and ending of co-ownership, having applied to a mediator before filing a suit is a precondition to suit, that where the relevant court gives an annotation on the enforceability of the agreement reached at the end of mediation, the agreement containing this annotation is deemed a document in the nature of a court judgment, and that if agreement is reached at the end of mediation the parties cannot file a suit on the matters agreed; the transaction for the transfer to ….. of the other co-owners' shares, for a total consideration of ………. TL, in the immovables registered in ….. province, ….. district, ….. village, ….. locality, block ….. parcel …; ….. village, ….. locality, block ….., parcels ….., ….., ….., under the "Mediation Agreement Document as a Precondition to Suit in Disputes on the Division of Movables and Immovables and Ending of Co-Ownership" signed on ….. at ….. Mediation Office regarding the requests of ….., ….., ….., ….., ….., ….. and ….. to end co-ownership over various immovables, attached to your ruling request form, must be treated as a sale through dissolution of co-ownership; accordingly, in these sales of immovables, where a minimum fixed fee must be charged because the proportional fee calculated for each transfer and acquisition under sub-paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) annexed to Law No. 492 is below the minimum fixed fee, one minimum fixed fee must be charged per immovable from the transferors and the transferees, regardless of the number of transfers and acquisitions; and where the proportional fee calculated for each transfer and acquisition exceeds the minimum amount, the calculated proportional fee must be collected.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.