A contractor building a stadium and car park for a metropolitan municipality stated that, for a progress payment already invoiced and declared, the administration found an overpayment and reduced the amount to a negative figure through a supplementary progress statement; since the administration is not a VAT taxpayer it cannot issue a return invoice and asked that the amount be recorded with an adjustment slip. The contractor asked how to record this, whether the adjustment slip replaces an invoice, and about VAT deduction.
The Administration's view:
- Tax Procedure Law: For the reduced progress payment following the correction, the contractor should, as a rule, issue an expense voucher (gider pusulası); however, the payment may also be recorded with an official document issued by the municipality, and that document may be used as supporting evidence.
- VAT: Under VAT Law Article 35, by the contractor issuing an expense voucher and attaching the administration's document to it, the VAT relating to that document can be deducted in the tax period in which the change occurred.
The ruling is relevant to contractors working for public administrations who face progress payment corrections.
Full text
Subject: Whether VAT can be deducted in the correction period due to invoice corrections
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated … with document registration number … .
From your ruling request form referred to above, stating that the "… Neighbourhood Stadium and Underground Car Park Construction Work" contract was signed between your Company and … Metropolitan Municipality Department of Technical Works, Directorate of Building Works, that completion of the work was achieved through an extension of time with progress report No. …, that invoice No. … dated … was issued on the basis of that progress report, recorded and declared on time, that during the process, since an overpayment was calculated in the progress payment in the administration's reviews, a supplementary progress statement was issued for correction, that the amount considered overcalculated was shown as negative in the progress statement and your Company requested a return invoice for the negative amount, and that the administration stated that it cannot issue a return invoice since it has no value added tax (VAT) liability and that the amount debited with an adjustment slip must be recorded, it is understood that our Directorate's opinion is requested on how the situation should be recorded in the accounts, whether the "adjustment slip" can be treated as a document replacing an invoice under the Tax Procedure Law, and whether VAT can be deducted.
WITH REGARD TO THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Article 227 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides that, unless otherwise provided in this Law, records kept under this Law relating to relations and transactions with third parties must be documented, and these records must be documented with the appropriate document among those set out in Article 229 and the following articles of the same Law or made mandatory on the basis of the authority given to our Ministry.
In this context, Article 234 of the said Law, as amended by Law No. 7338, provides:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method, and self-employed professionals and farmers required to keep books issue an expense voucher, to be signed by the person doing the work or selling the goods, for work they have done by, or goods they buy from, persons not required to issue documents under this Law (except goods bought from farmers not taxed under the actual method). An expense voucher issued for tax-exempt tradesmen has the effect of an invoice given by these persons.
The expense voucher contains the nature of the work, the type and kind, quantity and price of the goods, the wage for the work, the names and surnames (titles for legal entities) and addresses of the person commissioning and the person doing the work, or of the buyer and seller of the goods, and the date, and is drawn up in two copies, one of which is given to the person doing the work or selling the goods.
Expense vouchers are numbered consecutively by series and serial number. An expense voucher is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. An expense voucher not issued within this period is deemed never to have been issued.
Provided they contain the information specified in the second paragraph;
a) Where the price of the goods or service is paid to the seller within the period specified in the fourth paragraph through a bank defined in Banking Law No. 5411 dated 19/10/2005, payment institutions authorised under Law No. 6493 dated 20/6/2013 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions, or Posta ve Telgraf Teşkilatı Anonim Şirketi established under Postal Services Law No. 6475 dated 9/5/2013, documents issued by these institutions,
b) On return of goods bought under Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 dated 7/11/2013 to those required to issue expense vouchers, where amounts to be refunded under Law No. 6502 are refunded through the institutions in sub-paragraph (a), documents issued by these institutions,
c) Documents issued by public institutions and organisations not required to issue documents under this Law, within their applicable legislation, for work they do or goods they sell,
replace the expense voucher.
The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this article."
Accordingly, after your Company issued an invoice for the construction work tendered within the public services carried out by … Metropolitan Municipality, for the correction of the progress payment amount and the resulting reduced progress payment, it is as a rule for your Company to issue an expense voucher; however, it is also possible for this payment to be recorded with an official document to be issued by … Metropolitan Municipality and for that document to be used as a supporting document in the application of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
WITH REGARD TO THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activity are subject to VAT,
- in Article 20, that the tax base in supply and service transactions is the consideration for these transactions; and that the term consideration means the total of money, goods and other benefits, services and values that can be represented in money, received or owed in any manner whatsoever, in return for these transactions, from the person receiving the goods or to whom the service is rendered or those acting on their behalf,
- in Article 29, that taxpayers may, unless otherwise provided in this Law, deduct from the VAT calculated on their taxable transactions the VAT shown on invoices and similar documents issued for supplies and services made to them in connection with their activities, and that the right of deduction may be used in the tax period in which the relevant documents are recorded in the legal books, provided the calendar year following the calendar year in which the taxable event occurred is not exceeded,
- in Article 35, that where the tax base changes due to return of goods, non-performance of the transaction, abandonment of the transaction or other reasons, taxpayers who carried out the taxable transactions may correct the tax they owed for them, and taxpayers who are counterparties to these transactions may correct the tax they had the right to deduct, in a manner appropriate to the nature of the change and within the period in which the change occurred.
Sub-section (III/C-6.1.) headed "General Explanation" of section (III/C-6.) headed "Changes in Tax Base and Deduction Amounts" of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation states:
"Provided the returned goods have actually entered the business and this entry is shown in the book records and the return, where the tax base changes due to return of goods, non-performance of the transaction, abandonment of the transaction or other reasons, the taxpayer who carried out the taxable transactions corrects the tax owed for them, and the taxpayer who is the counterparty corrects the tax it had the right to deduct, in a manner appropriate to the nature of the change and within the tax period in which the change occurred, under Article 35 of Law No. 3065.
Furthermore, under that provision, if the VAT rate applicable to the transaction has changed by the date the change in tax base occurs, the correction must be made on the basis of the VAT rate applicable to these transactions on the date of the original supply or service."
Accordingly, considering that an invoice dated … was issued on the basis of progress report No. .. relating to the contract signed between your Company and … Metropolitan Municipality Department of Technical Works, Directorate of Building Works, that a supplementary progress statement was later issued for correction since an overpayment was calculated in the administration's reviews, that the amount considered overcalculated was shown as negative in the progress statement, and that it was stated that the amount debited with an adjustment slip must be recorded, it is possible, by your Company issuing an expense voucher for the reduced progress payment and attaching the document issued by the administration to the expense voucher, for the VAT relating to that document to be deducted in the tax period in which the change occurred.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.