A company selling to end consumers, in physical stores, codes and PINs obtained from a Türkiye-resident firm, whose value is a TL balance usable on certain platforms, asked whether it can issue an e-archive invoice or retail receipt without charging VAT on these sales.
The Administration's view:
- The supply and domestic sale of cards, PINs and codes that serve as a means of payment and do not represent a specific product or service are outside the scope of VAT.
- Since there is no supply of goods or services in these transactions, no document is issued under tax legislation; a document other than those listed in the Tax Procedure Law may be issued for information purposes.
- The commission the company earns for its intermediary service is subject to VAT, and an invoice/e-archive invoice must be issued for it.
The ruling is relevant to retailers selling game, app and digital platform balance codes.
Full text
Subject: Whether a VAT-free e-archive invoice can be issued for physical sales of codes and PINs
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form and its attachment referred to in reference (a) and the petition and its attachment referred to in reference (c), stating that codes and PINs obtained from a Türkiye-resident firm are sold to end consumers in a physical environment, that the value of these codes and PINs is a Turkish lira balance, that the balances are loaded onto the platforms of various brands and cannot be used on another platform, and that transactions such as apps, in-app purchases and buying series and films can be made with this balance, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether an e-archive invoice or retail receipt can be issued without calculating value added tax on the delivery of these codes and PINs to end consumers.
I- WITH REGARD TO THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activity are subject to VAT,
- in Article 8/1-a, that in the case of supplies of goods and services, those performing them are the taxpayers,
- in Article 10-a, that in the case of supplies of goods and services, the taxable event occurs with the delivery of the goods or the performance of the service.
Section (I/B-16) of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation, headed "VAT Application on the Sale of Cards, PINs, Codes and Similar", states:
"...
16.3. VAT Application on Cards, PINs and Codes Not Corresponding to a Specific Product or Service
Some cards, PINs and codes represent a virtual purchasing power for buying supplies or services to be made later by the providers of products or services. When these cards, PINs and codes are used, no specific product or service is obtained; a right to purchase arises in a virtual or physical environment.
16.3.1. VAT Application on the Sale of Cards, PINs and Codes Not Corresponding to a Specific Product or Service
The sale of cards, PINs and codes sold in a virtual or physical environment under names such as wallet code, which do not represent the equivalent of a specific product or service, create a purchasing right with the issuing firm when used, and are in the nature of a means of payment, is outside the scope of VAT. In this context, the procurement of these cards, PINs and codes from abroad or their sale within Türkiye will not be subject to VAT.
...
16.3.2. VAT Application on Obtaining Products or Services Using Cards, PINs and Codes Not Corresponding to a Specific Product or Service
Obtaining products or services in return for cards, PINs and codes sold in a virtual or physical environment but not representing a specific product or service, by using or activating them, is subject to VAT under the general provisions.
Where these products and services are:
- obtained by Türkiye residents from foreign-resident firms, the VAT on the transaction must be declared and paid by the Türkiye residents as a responsible party on VAT Return No. 2,
- provided by foreign-resident electronic service providers to Türkiye-resident individuals who are not VAT taxpayers, the VAT on the transaction must be declared and paid by the foreign-resident firm on VAT Return No. 3,
- obtained from firms in Türkiye, the VAT calculated must be declared by the selling firms on VAT Return No. 1.
...
16.4. VAT Application on Fees Received for Intermediary Services in Sales of Cards, PINs and Codes and Other Sales
In practice, cards, PINs and codes may be sold in virtual or physical stores. In addition, products developed within virtual games by individual players (such as game characters, powers, features, levels) may also be sold in virtual environments.
Whether or not they correspond to a specific product or service, intermediary services provided in Türkiye for the sale of cards, PINs and codes and other products in virtual or physical stores are subject to VAT, and the VAT calculated on fees received under names such as service fee or commission for these sales must be declared by those providing the intermediary service."
Accordingly, the sale of cards, PINs and codes that do not represent the equivalent of a specific product or service, create a purchasing right with the issuing firm when used, and are in the nature of a means of payment is outside the scope of VAT. In this context, the procurement of these cards, PINs and codes by your Company or their sale within Türkiye will not be subject to VAT. However, VAT must be calculated on the commission you earn for the intermediary service provided by your Company.
II- WITH REGARD TO THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in the first paragraph of Article 227, that unless otherwise provided in this Law, records kept under this Law relating to relations and transactions with third parties must be documented,
- in Article 229, that an invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work, showing the amount the customer owes for the goods sold or work done,
- in sub-paragraph (5) of the first paragraph of Article 231, that the invoice is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service, that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised, taking into account the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, field of activity, sector or type of liability separately or together, to reduce this period or to require the invoice to be issued at the moment of delivery or performance, and that invoices not issued within these periods are deemed never to have been issued,
- in Article 232, that first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method, and farmers required to keep books are required to give invoices for goods sold or work done to first and second class merchants, self-employed professionals, merchants whose income is determined under the simple method, farmers required to keep books and tax-exempt tradesmen, and these are required to request and receive invoices,
and that, for others, the seller or the person doing the work must give an invoice where the price of goods bought from or work commissioned from first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers required to keep books exceeds 50,000,000 liras (9,900 TL from 1.1.2025 under Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 577), or, even if below that amount, where they request one,
- in Article 233, that the prices of sales and work for which first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers required to keep books are not required to issue invoices are documented by retail receipts or any of the other documents listed in the article,
- in the second paragraph of repeated Article 242, that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for creating, recording, transmitting, keeping and presenting electronic books, documents and records, and for keeping, issuing and presenting books and documents electronically; that provisions on books, records and documents in this Law and other tax laws also apply to electronic books, records and documents; and that the Ministry is authorised to set procedures and principles for electronic books, documents and records different from those for other books, documents and records,
- in sub-paragraph (3) of the first paragraph of repeated Article 257, that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to permit or require mandatory books, records and documents to be kept and issued by microfilm, microfiche or electronic information and recording means, and stored or presented in these media.
Section "IV.2. e-Archive Invoice Application" of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 509, which contains the regulations on electronic document (e-Document) applications made on the basis of these authorities, states:
"...The e-Archive Invoice regulated in this Communiqué is not a new type of document and has the same legal characteristics as the paper "Invoice". Taxpayers registered in the e-Archive Invoice Application must, except in the exceptional cases specified in sections "V.7." and "VIII." of this Communiqué, issue the invoice as an e-Invoice for sales of goods and services to taxpayers registered in the e-Invoice Application, and as an e-Archive Invoice for sales of goods and services to taxpayers not registered in the e-Invoice Application and to non-taxpayers."
Accordingly, in the procurement or sale within Türkiye by the obligated company of cards, PINs and codes that do not represent the equivalent of a specific product or service, create a purchasing right with the issuing firm when used, and are in the nature of a means of payment, since there is no supply of goods or services by you, no document will be issued under tax legislation for these transactions, which are not subject to VAT. It is, however, possible to issue a document other than those listed in Law No. 213 for information purposes in return for these deliveries.
On the other hand, it goes without saying that an Invoice/e-Archive Invoice must be issued for the commission earned in return for the intermediary service provided by your Company.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.