TREN
Contact us

In Public Procurement, the 5% Difference Paid to the Contractor When Work Is Completed Below 80% of the Contract Price Is Subject to VAT and Catering Withholding

VAT · WithholdingIn Public Procurement, the 5% Difference Paid to the Contractor When Work Is Completed Below 80% of the Contract Price Is Subject to VAT and Catering WithholdingPrivate ruling · 9 July 2025
Rast note

An ordinary partnership that undertook a hospital's tender for food preparation, cooking, distribution and dishwashing services asked whether the 5% difference payable to it under Article 24 of Law No. 4735, because the work was completed below 80% of the contract price, is subject to VAT and withholding.

The Administration's view:

  • This payment is made in return for the contractor's actual costs and profit and is linked to the service provided; unlike penalty-type compensation, it is subject to VAT.
  • Since personnel costs and occupational safety responsibility rest with the contractor, the work as a whole is treated as a catering service; VAT withholding at 5/10 applies to the service fee and to this difference, which cannot be considered separately from the service fee.

The ruling is relevant to contractors receiving work-reduction differences in public tenders.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether an amount paid under contract terms without a corresponding supply of goods/services is subject to VAT
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: Ruling request forms dated … and … .

In your ruling request forms referred to above, stating that a contract was signed between your Ordinary Partnership and … Training and Research Hospital affiliated with … Provincial Health Directorate for the "Procurement of Food Preparation, Cooking, Distribution and Dishwashing Services", that the service was completed on …, and that payment will be made under sub-paragraph 1/a-b of Article 29 of the contract, which provides "...Where it is understood that the tendered work will be completed at a price lower than 80% of the contract price, 5% of the difference between 80% of the contract price and the amount of work done at contract prices is paid to the contractor in return for its actual costs and contractor's profit.", our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the amount to be paid is subject to value added tax (VAT) and, if so, whether it is subject to withholding.

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the scope of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employed professional activity are subject to VAT,

- in Article 9/1, that where the taxpayer has no domicile, workplace, legal seat or business centre in Türkiye, and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold those party to taxable transactions responsible for paying the tax in order to secure the tax receivable,

- in Article 20, that the tax base in supply and service transactions is the consideration for these transactions, and that the term consideration means the total of money, goods and other benefits, services and values that can be represented in money, received or owed in any manner whatsoever, in return for these transactions, from the person receiving the goods or to whom the service is rendered or those acting on their behalf,

- in Article 24/c, that various income such as late payment differences, price differences, exchange differences, interest and premiums, and all benefits, services and values provided under names such as service and similar, are included in the tax base.

Section (I/C-2.1.3.1.) of the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation, headed "Nature of Partial Withholding and Purchasers Applying Withholding", lists those responsible for withholding, and section (I/C-2.1.3.2), headed "Services Subject to Partial Withholding", lists the services subject to withholding.

In addition, the General Communiqué on VAT Implementation:

- lists the nature of partial withholding and purchasers applying withholding in section (I/C-2.1.3.1.), services subject to partial withholding in section (I/C-2.1.3.2.) and supplies subject to partial withholding in section (I/C-2.1.3.3.), and section (I/C-2.1.3.2.4.) of the Communiqué, headed "Catering and Organisation Services", states:

"2.1.3.2.4.1. Purchasers Applying Withholding and Withholding Rate
VAT withholding at (5/10) is applied by purchasers on all kinds of catering and organisation services performed for those listed in sub-section (I/C-2.1.3.1/b) of the Communiqué.
2.1.3.2.4.2. Scope
Catering services cover service purchases made by the administrations, institutions and organisations listed in sub-section (I/C-2.1.3.1/b) of the Communiqué to meet the food needs of persons who are their staff, students, patients, customers, guests or passengers.
Example: VAT withholding will be made on payments to contractors preparing and/or distributing lunches (packed meals) given to students under bussed education by the Ministry of National Education (provincial or district national education directorates).
Withholding will also be made on the purchase of meals (packed meals) where the price is met from a source other than the purchaser's own budget appropriations, for example by the Social Assistance Foundation.
The meal being prepared (cooked) at a place belonging to the administration, institution or organisation responsible for withholding, or being supplied ready for consumption, does not prevent withholding.",

- in section (III/A-5) headed "Elements Included in the Tax Base":

"Under Article 24 of Law No. 3065, the following elements are included in the VAT base:
...
c) Various income such as late payment differences, price differences, exchange differences, interest and premiums, and all benefits, services and values provided under names such as service and similar,"

Furthermore, section (1.2.) headed "Compensation" of VAT Circular No. 60 states that compensation and similar payments not arising in return for any supply or service are in principle outside the scope of VAT, and that in this context payments in the nature of penalty clauses made under names such as compensation or withdrawal fee for reasons such as the work not being performed in accordance with the contract, not being completed within the given period, or termination of the contract are outside the scope of VAT since they are not consideration for any supply or service.

Article 24 of Law No. 4735 provides:

"...
In work that is understood to be completed at a price lower than 80% of the contract price, the contractor is obliged to complete the work. In this case, 5% of the difference between 80% of the contract price and the amount of work done at contract prices is paid to the contractor, at prices on the provisional acceptance date, in return for its actual costs and contractor's profit."

Accordingly, VAT must be calculated under the general principles on the total of 5% of the difference between 80% of the contract price and the amount of work you did at contract prices, to be paid to you in return for your actual costs and contractor's profit under sub-paragraph 1/a-b of Article 29 of the contract signed with your Ordinary Partnership for the "Procurement of Food Preparation, Cooking, Distribution and Dishwashing Services" of … Training and Research Hospital affiliated with … Provincial Health Directorate.

Furthermore, from examination of the contract and technical specification, considering together that all costs of the staff to be employed will be borne by the contractor and that the contractor will be responsible in matters such as occupational health and safety inspections of the staff, the work is understood to be catering work as a whole.

In this context, the service performed by your Ordinary Partnership must be treated as within "Catering and Organisation Services" and VAT withholding at (5/10) applied on the service fee to be paid, and since the differences to be paid to you under Article 24 of Law No. 4735 for the catering service provided cannot be considered separately from the service fee, VAT withholding at (5/10) must also be applied to these differences under section (I/C-2.1.3.2.4.) of the Communiqué.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.