In the agreement of a partnership established for a housing construction project, the partnership shares were set at 51%/49%, but profit distribution was set at 1%/99%. The question was whether profit can be distributed independently of the partnership shares.
The Administration found that although a joint venture agreement had been drawn up, the partnership is registered in GİB records as an ordinary partnership with no corporate tax liability. Since under Articles 621 and 623 of the Turkish Code of Obligations the contribution share and the share in profit and loss can be freely set in an ordinary partnership, the partners may include their income in their own returns according to the profit and loss sharing ratios set in the agreement.
The ruling is relevant to companies forming construction and project-based partnerships.
Full text
Subject: Whether the profit-share ratio can differ from the share ratio in a joint venture agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your joint venture was established by the joint venture agreement dated … and undertook the work of "… province, … district, … neighbourhood, stage …, construction of 697 dwellings and infrastructure and landscaping", that Article 7 of the joint venture agreement set the partnership shares as … Ltd. Şti. 51% and … Taah. İnş. A.Ş. 49%, but Article 9 of the same agreement set the profit distribution as … Ltd. Şti. 1% and … Taah. İnş. A.Ş. 99%, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether profit can be distributed independently of the partners' shares.
Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists joint ventures among corporate taxpayers, and the seventh paragraph of Article 2 of the same Law provides: "Joint ventures: Partnerships formed by the institutions listed in the paragraphs above among themselves or with partnerships of persons or individuals for the purpose of jointly undertaking a specific work and sharing its income, which request that tax liability be established in this way, are joint ventures. Their lack of legal personality does not affect their tax liability."
Detailed explanations on the subject are given in section "2.5. Joint ventures" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, and its sub-section "2.5.3 Status of losses arising at completion of the work" states:
"Corporations may, if they wish, operate by forming partnerships in the form of ordinary partnerships under the Code of Obligations or joint ventures under the Corporate Tax Law.
Although ordinary partnerships are not corporate taxpayers, they may keep separate books because they are VAT taxpayers. The partners share the profit or loss arising at period-end in proportion to their shares in the partnership and include it in their own accounts.
Joint ventures, on the other hand, are treated as separate entities under the Corporate Tax Law and counted as corporate taxpayers. Income from the activities of joint ventures is subject to corporate tax, and after-tax income is distributed to the partners according to their shares.
Losses of corporate taxpayers cannot be deducted by their partners, and the same applies to losses of joint ventures that are corporate taxpayers.
..."
On the other hand, ordinary partnerships are regulated in Articles 620-645 of Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, and Article 620 of that Code defines an ordinary partnership agreement as an agreement by which two or more persons undertake to combine their labour and property to achieve a common purpose.
Ordinary partnerships, which have no legal personality, are not income or corporate taxpayers on their income; the profit or loss from activities carried out within the ordinary partnership is taxed by being included in their own income by the partners forming the ordinary partnership in proportion to their shares.
Furthermore, Article 621 of that Code states that each partner is obliged to contribute to the partnership in money, receivables or other property or labour, and that, unless otherwise agreed in the agreement, contributions must be of the importance and nature required by the partnership's purpose and equal to each other; and Article 623 of the same Code states that, unless otherwise agreed in the agreement, each partner's share in profit and loss is equal regardless of the value and nature of its contribution, and that where the agreement sets the partners' share in either profit or loss, that setting also expresses the share in the other. Accordingly, in an ordinary partnership agreement, the contribution each partner will make to the partnership and its share in profit or loss can be set freely.
Article 7 of the partnership agreement dated … attached to the ruling request form sets the parties' partnership ratio as 51% … Yapı Ltd. Şti. (Lead partner) and 49% … Taah. İnş. A.Ş., but Article 9 of the same agreement, headed "Method of Distributing Profit", provides that on completion of the work, profit and loss will be distributed independently of the shares in Article 7 of the agreement, as 1% … Yapı Ltd. Şti. (Lead partner) and 99% … Taah. İnş. A.Ş.
Furthermore, from examination of GİB Intranet records, it is understood that although your Partnership drew up a joint venture agreement, your tax liability was established as an ordinary partnership and you have no corporate tax liability.
Under these provisions and explanations, although under the agreement drawn up for the "… province, … district, … neighbourhood, stage …, construction of 697 dwellings and infrastructure and landscaping" work undertaken by your partnership the partners' shares are set as 51% for … Yapı Ltd. Şti. and 49% for … Taah. İnş. A.Ş., it is possible for the partners forming the ordinary partnership to declare by including in their own income on the basis of the ratios set for participation in profit or loss as of the date the partnership agreement for that work was made.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.