A parent whose children left a private school after enrolment asked whether the 10% of the annual fee not refunded under Article 56 of the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Education Institutions can be deducted on the return as an education expense.
The Administration stated that the unrefunded 10% is a contract withdrawal fee and not directly consideration for education services. It is therefore not an education expense and cannot be deducted from declared income under Income Tax Law Article 89.
The ruling is relevant to income taxpayers deducting education expenses on their return.
Full text
Subject: Whether the amount not refunded on withdrawal from school under the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Education Institutions is an education expense
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Ruling request form No. 5704893 dated 05.09.2023
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that after enrolling your children at school, because they left the school, the amount excluding 10% of the annual fee was refunded to you under Article 56 of the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Education Institutions, an opinion is requested on whether the unrefunded amount can be treated as an education expense and deducted from income to be reported on the income tax return.
The first paragraph of Article 70 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides that income from the leasing of the property and rights listed in its sub-paragraphs by their owners, possessors, holders, holders of easement and usufruct rights or tenants is income from immovable property.
Article 89 of the same Law, headed "Other deductions", lists the deductions that may be made from income reported on the income tax return in determining the income tax base, and sub-paragraph (2) of the first paragraph of that article provides: "Education and health expenses relating to the taxpayer, spouse and minor children, provided they do not exceed 10% of declared income, are incurred in Türkiye and are supported by documents obtained from natural or legal persons with income or corporate tax liability (wage earners benefiting from the tax reduction for education and health expenses under repeated Article 121 cannot deduct the same expenses from their base under this provision)."
On the subject, Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 255 states:
- in the section headed "Education expenses": "Payments to educational and training institutions, kindergartens, nurseries and private tutoring centres for educational purposes, educational course fees, school bus fees, expenses for books and stationery, and amounts paid where students stay in private dormitories and boarding houses will be taken as the basis for the tax reduction.",
- in the section headed "Incurring the expense in Türkiye and documentation": "For the above expenses to be eligible for the tax reduction, they must be incurred in Türkiye and with taxpayers subject to income or corporate tax. In other words, where expenses eligible for the tax reduction are incurred with persons or entities not subject to income or corporate tax, these expenses will not be eligible for the tax reduction.
..."
On the other hand, Article 56 of the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Education Institutions, headed "Refund of fees", provides:
"(1) ...
(3) Of students and trainees enrolling in institutions;
a) in pre-school education institutions, primary schools, lower secondary schools, special education schools and secondary schools that set tuition fees annually, those leaving the school before the start of the academic year, except those documenting enrolment in 9th grade of public schools admitting students by examination, are refunded the part of the annual fee other than ten per cent. Those leaving after the start of the academic year are refunded the part of the annual fee other than ten per cent and the amount calculated according to the days of attendance.
..."
In this case, it is understood that the amount of 10% of the annual fee paid and not refundable under the provision of that Regulation on refund of fees is a contract withdrawal fee and is not directly consideration for education and training services.
Under the above provisions and explanations, the 10% of the annual fee collected by the school but not refunded under Article 56 of the Ministry of National Education Regulation on Private Education Institutions, because your children left the school after enrolment, cannot be treated as an education expense and deducted from income to be reported on the annual return under Article 89 of the Income Tax Law.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.