A university's revolving-fund Experimental Medicine Application and Research Centre asked whether its activities of supplying and selling laboratory animals, breeding, raising and care, technical support and training support for laboratory animal use certificate courses are subject to VAT. The Administration also addressed corporate tax.
The Administration's view:
- If the activities are carried out only within education and training, no corporate tax liability arises in the Centre's name under Corporate Tax Law Article 4/1-a; where they are carried out outside education and training, or workers are employed from outside, production is to order or work is obtained by tender, liability is established for an economic public enterprise within the University.
- A separate registration is required for each economic public enterprise with independent and different activities.
- Laboratory animal sales, certificate courses, technical support for a fee and care services cannot be considered within VAT Law Articles 17/1-a and 17/2-a; they are subject to VAT under Article 1/3-g.
The ruling is relevant to universities' revolving-fund units.
Full text
Subject: Scientific research activities of a university Experimental Medicine Application and Research Centre
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Your ruling request form dated ….
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that, as … University Revolving Fund Experimental Medicine Application and Research Centre, you carry out activities of supplying and selling laboratory animals for scientific research, technical support services, production, raising and care of laboratory animals, and training support for laboratory animal use certificate courses, our opinion is requested on whether these activities are subject to value added tax (VAT).
WITH RESPECT TO THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists economic public enterprises among corporate taxpayers; the third paragraph of that article provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or attached to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and institutions, with continuous activities and other than capital companies and cooperatives, are economic public enterprises; and the sixth paragraph provides that economic public enterprises not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties given by law, their not having legal personality, and their not having independent accounts and capital or workplaces allocated to them do not affect their liability, and that the price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made or profit being allocated to their founding purposes do not change their economic nature.
The first paragraph of Article 4 of the same Law lists entities exempt from corporate tax; sub-paragraph (a) of the paragraph provides that schools, school workshops, conservatories, libraries, theatres, museums, exhibitions, sample nurseries, seed and animal development and production stations, racecourses, book, newspaper and magazine publishers and similar organisations operated by public administrations and institutions for the purpose of teaching, spreading, developing and promoting agriculture and animal husbandry, science, technical and fine arts, and sub-paragraph (b) provides that hospitals, clinics, dispensaries, sanatoriums, nursing homes, childcare homes, animal hospitals and dispensaries, animal care homes, veterinary bacteriology, serology and distophagy organisations and similar organisations operated by public administrations and institutions for the purpose of protecting general human and animal health and treatment, are exempt from corporate tax; and it is stated that sales of goods and services by those providing health services to each other for diagnosis and treatment, and leasing of property and rights specified in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law by institutions such as hospitals, clinics, dispensaries and sanatoriums attached to the Ministry of Health, do not remove this exemption.
The second paragraph of Article 14 of that Law provides that each taxpayer files one return for all its taxable income; however, for each of the economic public enterprises without legal personality and the economic enterprises belonging to associations and foundations, separate returns are filed by the public legal persons and associations and foundations to which they are attached.
Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, containing explanations on the application of that Law, states:
- in section (2.3.1.), that economic public enterprises cover all economic enterprises belonging or attached to public administrations and institutions, so the concept of economic public enterprises covers both state economic enterprises and economic organisations belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, public institutions and organisations, and revolving-fund organisations; and that the explanations in section (2.4.) of the Communiqué must be taken into account on whether economic public enterprises constitute a commercial, industrial or agricultural enterprise,
- in section (2.4.), that the distinctive features of economic enterprises are attachment, continuity and the activity being of a commercial, industrial or agricultural nature; in other words, that the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as buying and selling goods, manufacturing or providing services for consideration within the market economy under an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity; that instead of listing such cases one by one, the Law covers all economic activities carried out by an association or foundation within the market economy; that even without a profit motive, an economic enterprise belonging to associations or foundations is deemed formed where the subject and activity of the enterprise are all kinds of sales of goods and services or similar and are carried out continuously; that where associations or foundations perform certain services without consideration, these activities are not characterised as an economic enterprise attached to the association or foundation; but that where the expenses incurred for these services are collected from those served, or a price is received from these persons or their families under the name of donation, these activities will be accepted as an economic enterprise belonging to the association or foundation and be subject to corporate tax,
- in sections (4.1.) and (4.2.), that organisations operated by public administrations and institutions for the purpose of teaching, spreading, developing and promoting agriculture and animal husbandry, science, technical and fine arts, and organisations operated by public administrations and institutions for the purpose of protecting general human and animal health and treatment, are exempt from corporate tax,
- in section (14.1.), that for each of the economic public enterprises without legal personality and the economic enterprises without legal personality belonging to associations or foundations, separate returns must be filed by the public legal persons or associations or foundations to which they are attached; that therefore separate corporate tax registration will be established for each economic enterprise of those organisations; that separate registrations must be established where the activities of economic enterprises are independent and different, even if they have common management or capital, whereas a single registration is possible where activity is carried out in the same field at different workplaces; but that enterprises with different management, capital or organisation will be accepted as separate economic enterprises.
Commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or attached to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and institutions, with continuous activities and other than capital companies and cooperatives, are listed among corporate taxpayers as economic public enterprises under the principle of equality in taxation. Economic public enterprises are organisations, including commercial enterprises, that continuously make sales or provide services for consideration. The basic rationale for taxing economic public enterprises is to ensure tax equality of competition within the market economy.
Economic public enterprises not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties given by law, their not having legal personality, and their not having independent accounts and capital or workplaces allocated to them will not affect their liability. The price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made, or profit being allocated to founding purposes will also not change their economic nature.
In this respect, where the activities carried out by universities, which have no corporate tax liability as legal persons, consist of commercial, industrial and agricultural activities carried out continuously and for consideration within the market economy under an organisation, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic public enterprise that will be formed within the universities because of these activities. Furthermore, where the activities of the economic public enterprises to be formed are independent and different, even if they have common management or capital, separate corporate tax registration will have to be established for each of them. However, it goes without saying that if the economic public enterprises formed within universities because of their activities are among organisations operating within Article 4 of the Corporate Tax Law, they will be exempt from corporate tax.
Under the above provisions and explanations, where the activities carried out within your Centre, which has no corporate tax liability as a legal person, consist of commercial, industrial or agricultural activities carried out continuously and for consideration within the market economy under an organisation, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic public enterprises that will be formed within the University because of these activities.
Accordingly, if, as … University Experimental Medicine Application and Research Centre, you only sell laboratory animals produced and raised within education and training activities, organise laboratory animal use certificate courses and provide technical support and care services for laboratory animals for consideration at the request of persons, institutions and organisations, there will be no corporate tax liability in your Centre's name under sub-paragraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Corporate Tax Law. However, it goes without saying that where those activities are carried out outside education and training activities, workers are employed from outside, production is carried out to order or work is obtained by tender, corporate tax liability will be established for the economic public enterprise that will be formed within the University.
On the other hand, it goes without saying that, where the activities of the economic public enterprises to be formed within your University because of its activities are independent and different, even if they have common management or capital, separate corporate tax registration will have to be established for each of them.
WITH RESPECT TO THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of establishments belonging or subject to, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and unions formed by them, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations, and of revolving-fund organisations or other establishments belonging or subject to them, are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/1-a, that deliveries and services made by general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities, villages, unions formed by them, universities, revolving-fund organisations, public institutions and organisations established by law and Presidential Decree, professional organisations in the nature of public institutions, political parties and trade unions, pension and aid funds established by law or having legal personality, associations working for the public benefit, agricultural cooperatives and foundations granted tax exemption by the President, for the purpose of spreading, improving and promoting science, technology and fine arts and agriculture, are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 17/2-a, that deliveries and services consistent with their founding purposes performed by the above institutions and organisations by operating or managing organisations such as hospitals, convalescent homes, clinics, dispensaries, preventoriums, sanatoriums, blood banks and banks for organ transplantation, monuments, botanical and zoological gardens, parks and veterinary, bacteriology, serology and distophagy laboratories, student or training dormitories, elderly and disabled care and nursing homes, free soup kitchens for the poor, almshouses and orphanages, and deliveries and services by those providing health services to each other for diagnosis and treatment, are exempt from VAT.
Article 1 of the same Law provides that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activity are determined under the Income Tax Law and, where the Income Tax Law is not clear, under the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation, and that these activities being carried out on the requirement shown by laws or official authorities, the legal status and personality of those carrying them out, whether they are Turkish nationals, and whether their domicile or workplaces or legal seat or business centre are in Türkiye do not change the nature of the transactions or prevent taxation.
Accordingly, the sale of laboratory animals produced and raised by your Revolving Fund Experimental Medicine Application and Research Centre, the organisation of laboratory animal use certificate courses, the provision of technical support services for consideration at the request of persons, institutions and organisations, and the provision of care services for laboratory animals cannot be considered within Articles 17/1-a and 17/2-a of Law No. 3065 and must be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-g of Law No. 3065.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.