A municipal public transport entity asked whether tea rooms set up with money collected from staff, meeting only staff tea and coffee needs, making no outside sales and having no profit motive, form an economic enterprise, and whether a potential tax number can be obtained for them.
The Administration's view:
- Corporate tax: if there is no commercial organisation in the tea room service, no economic public entity arises. If it operates within a commercial organisation and for consideration, corporate tax liability is established for the economic public entity.
- VAT: without a commercial organisation the services are not subject to VAT; with one they are subject to VAT under VAT Law Article 1/3-g.
- Tax procedure: since no economic public entity arises, a separate tax identification number (including a potential one) cannot be created for the tea rooms to open a bank account or track account movements.
The ruling is relevant to public bodies operating staff tea rooms.
Full text
Subject: Corporate tax and VAT liability of tea rooms operated within a general directorate
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that you are a public entity affiliated with … Municipality providing urban public transport services, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether your tea rooms, whose capital is formed by collecting money from staff working in your institution, which with this capital meet only your staff's tea and coffee needs, make no outside sales, have no profit motive, and were set up without leasing and without engaging outside workers, form an economic enterprise, and whether you can obtain a potential tax number for your tea rooms.
CORPORATE TAX LAW:
Sub-paragraph (c) of the first paragraph of Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 brings economic public entities within tax liability, and the third paragraph of Article 2 of the same Law provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging to or affiliated with the state, special provincial administrations, municipalities and other public administrations and entities, whose activities are continuous and which fall outside the first and second paragraphs, are economic public entities; and the sixth paragraph provides that the fact that economic public entities and economic enterprises of associations or foundations do not pursue profit, that their activities are among duties assigned by law, that they have no legal personality, independent accounts, or capital or premises allocated to them does not affect their liability, and that the price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made, or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their economic nature.
Section (2.3.1.) of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, containing explanations on the application of that Law, states that the explanations in section (2.4.) of the Communiqué should be considered on whether economic public entities form a commercial, industrial or agricultural enterprise.
Section (2.4.) of that Communiqué states that in determining an economic enterprise, the distinctive features of the enterprise are affiliation, continuity and the activity being commercial, industrial or agricultural in nature, in other words, the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as purchase and sale of goods, manufacturing or provision of services for consideration within the market economy, connected to an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity; that rather than listing such cases one by one, the Law covers all economic activities carried on by an association or foundation in the market economy; that the price of the goods or services sold being only enough to cover cost, no profit being made, or profit being allocated to founding purposes does not change their status as an economic enterprise; that, even without a profit motive, an economic enterprise of an association or foundation is deemed to arise where the subject and activity of the enterprise is sales of all kinds of goods and services or similar and is carried on continuously; and that an activity being periodic or seasonal (such as pool and beach operation) does not prevent continuity of the activity due to the nature of the work.
The continuity element means carrying out more than one transaction of a commercial nature in the same or different fields of activity within an accounting period. Although continuity of commercial activity cannot be accepted because of a single transaction in the same accounting period, the existence of continuity is accepted where the activity requires an organisation or its purpose is commercial.
A commercial organisation will be set up in a specific way by fulfilling all or some of elements and conditions such as allocation of capital, opening premises, employing staff and registering in the trade registry. In that case, even if only one transaction is made within this organisation in one calendar year or in two or three years, the existence of commercial activity is accepted.
Accordingly, where the activities carried on by … General Directorate, which has no corporate tax liability by virtue of its legal personality, consist of commercial, industrial and agricultural activities carried out continuously and for consideration in the market economy connected to an organisation, corporate tax liability must be established for the economic public entity that will arise within that Directorate because of these activities.
Therefore, where there is no commercial organisation in the tea room service to be operated by collecting a fixed amount from each staff member to meet only the tea and coffee needs of your General Directorate's staff with staff employed within the institution, without outside sales, no economic public entity affiliated with your General Directorate will arise.
Where the tea room operates within a commercial organisation and for consideration, corporate tax liability will have to be established for the economic public entity that will arise within your General Directorate.
VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
in Article 1/1, that supplies and services made in Türkiye within the framework of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional supplies and services of establishments belonging to or subject to, or founded or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and the unions they form, universities, associations and foundations, and all kinds of professional organisations, and of entities with revolving funds or other establishments belonging to or subject to them, are subject to VAT.
Accordingly, where there is no commercial organisation in the tea room services set up by collecting money from your staff to meet only the tea and coffee needs of your General Directorate's staff, without outside sales, since no economic public entity will arise within your General Directorate, the services provided in this tea room will not be subject to VAT.
However, where there is a commercial organisation in these tea room services, the services to be provided by the economic public entity arising within your General Directorate will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-g of Law No. 3065.
TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Article 2 of Law No. 4358 on Extending the Use of the Tax Identification Number provides:
"Public administrations and establishments and other natural and legal persons are obliged, when carrying out transactions to be determined by the Ministry of Finance, to determine the tax identification number of natural and legal persons addressed by or party to these transactions and to include tax identification numbers in their documents, accounts and records relating to these transactions. Persons addressed by or party to the transactions to be determined are obliged to obtain a tax identification number before completion of the transactions if they do not have one.
Provisions in the special legislation of institutions and organisations brought within the obligation to determine and show the tax identification number in their documents, accounts and records under this Law that prevent or restrict the use of the tax identification number do not apply.
The term 'tax identification number' in this Law means the tax number given to natural and legal persons under Article 8 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213."
The last paragraph of Article 8 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
"A tax number is given to every natural person of Turkish nationality and to legal persons. The Ministry of Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this provision and to introduce an obligation to use the tax number in records relating to transactions to be made by public institutions and organisations and natural and legal persons and in documents to be issued."
Furthermore, the section headed "I- Determination and Use of the Tax Identification Number" of Tax Identification Number General Communiqué Serial No. 2, published in Official Gazette No. 24437 of 19/06/2001 on extending the use of the Tax Identification Number, states:
"Natural and legal persons within the scope of this Communiqué, in addition to the identity, address and other information of all kinds of natural and legal person customers carrying out, addressed by or party to the transactions specified in this Communiqué;
1. Determine their tax identification numbers.
2. Use these numbers in the relevant documents, accounts and records."
Article A/2, headed "Matters Taxpayers Must Comply With in the Single Tax Number Application", of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué Serial No. 240 states:
"A single tax number will be given to every natural and legal person registered at tax offices, and taxpayers' head offices and branches will use the same tax number. Branches being within the jurisdiction of another tax office will not change this. Banks are excluded from this application."
Accordingly, since it is considered that no affiliated economic public entity will arise where no service is provided for consideration within a commercial organisation in the tea rooms set up within your Directorate by collecting money from staff to meet only your staff's tea and coffee needs without outside sales, a separate tax identification number (including a potential one) cannot be created for these tea rooms (to open a bank account or track bank account movements).
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.