TREN
Contact us

No Law 4691 Withholding Incentive on Wages of Staff Sent Abroad to Commission Technology Developed in a Technopark and Turned Into a Commercial Product

Personal Income Tax · Employment incomeNo Law 4691 Withholding Incentive on Wages of Staff Sent Abroad to Commission Technology Developed in a Technopark and Turned Into a Commercial ProductPrivate ruling · 30 April 2025
Rast note

A technopark company asked whether the Law No. 4691 income tax withholding incentive applies to the wages of two engineers to be sent for more than 183 days to commission and operate a plant in Indonesia built with patented desalination and crystallisation technology it developed in the zone.

The Administration's view:

  • The withholding incentive covers systematic creative work during R&D before the product becomes a final (commercial) product. Staff sent abroad to commission and operate technology already turned into a commercial product in the technopark's production units cannot benefit from the incentive.
  • If these staff are found to have a domicile in Türkiye, they are deemed resident and their wages are subject to withholding as full taxpayers under ITL Articles 61, 94, 103 and 104.
  • The question about staff of the Indonesian-resident firm was not assessed because it was not based on a concrete event, and the social security premium support question should be put to the Social Security Institution.

The ruling is relevant to technopark firms posting staff on projects abroad.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether wages for time spent outside a technology development zone on a project developed in the zone benefit from the income tax withholding incentive
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request forms referred to above, stating that you are a taxpayer registered under tax identification number "…" at our Directorate's Urla Tax Office, that you carry on "Maintenance and Repair of Heating, Ventilation, Cooling and Air Conditioning Systems in Building or Other Construction Projects" and "Engineering and Consultancy for Energy Projects" activities within Teknopark-İzmir affiliated with the İzmir Institute of Technology, that you set up in Indonesia the desalination and salt production plant you developed in the zone, that in this plant clean water and salt (sodium chloride) will be obtained from seawater using "…" (your firm's patented technology) and crystallisation technology, that there is a permanent prototype unit of the project in that country, that during the commissioning and plant operation stages two of your company's employees, one an evaporation and crystallisation engineer in the position of department head and the other in the position of project engineer, must be in Indonesia for more than 183 days to see the product operate regularly, and that these persons' wages will be paid by your company, a full taxpayer resident in Türkiye, and further that you plan to apply for a work permit for staff working at the Indonesian-resident firm and that after these procedures such staff will work permanently in that country registered with you, our Directorate's opinion was requested on applying the income tax withholding incentive and the SSI exemption under Law No. 4691 to these staff.

Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

- in Article 1, headed "Subject":

"The income of natural persons is subject to income tax. Income is the net amount of earnings and revenues obtained by a natural person within a calendar year.",

- in Article 3, headed "Taxpayers":

"The following natural persons are taxed on the whole of the earnings and revenues they obtain in and outside Türkiye:
1. Those resident in Türkiye;
2. Turkish citizens attached to official departments and establishments or to organisations and enterprises headquartered in Türkiye and residing in foreign countries because of the business of those departments, establishments, organisations and enterprises (those among them who have been subjected to Income Tax or a similar tax in the countries where they are on the earnings and revenues obtained there are not separately taxed on those earnings and revenues.)"

Accordingly, residence in Türkiye is based on two criteria; for the domicile criterion, the places written in Article 19 and the following articles of the Turkish Civil Code are meant, and "domicile" is defined as the place where a person lives with the intention of staying permanently. The Law's definition of domicile in this way is based on the aim of distinguishing it from "dwelling". While in a domicile one lives with the intention and decision of staying permanently, in a dwelling there is no such decision or intention.

Therefore, under the domicile criterion, if a natural person's domicile in Türkiye is established, whatever his nationality, this person will be deemed resident in Türkiye without any other qualification or condition and will be taxed as a full taxpayer.

The same Law provides:

in Article 61, headed "Definition of wages":

"Wages are money and goods given, and benefits provided and representable in money, in return for service to those working dependent on an employer and attached to a specific workplace.
The fact that wages are paid under the names of allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial responsibility compensation), appropriation, raise, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense allowance or other names, or are determined as a certain percentage of profit provided it is not in the nature of a partnership relationship, does not change their nature....",

in Article 62, headed "Definition of employer":

"Employers are natural and legal persons who hire employees and have them work under their orders and instructions. Those making the payments written in sub-paragraphs 1 to 6 of Article 61 are deemed employers for fulfilling the duties written in this law.",

in Article 94, headed "Tax withholding":

"Public administrations and establishments, state economic establishments, other entities, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, business persons and self-employed persons obliged to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural income on a balance sheet or agricultural business account basis are obliged to withhold tax against the income tax of the beneficiaries when making the payments listed in the following sub-paragraphs (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account.
1. On wages paid to employees and payments written in Article 61 and deemed wages (excluding those benefiting from exemption), under Articles 103 and 104,
...
tax is withheld.
..."

Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 provides:

- in Article 3, headed "Definitions":

"(1) In applying this Law;
...
b) Technology Development Zone (Zone): the site, or a technopark having these features, in or near the area of a university, high technology institute or R&D centre or institute, where firms using high/advanced technology or oriented towards new technologies produce/develop technology or software using the facilities of a specific university or high technology institute or R&D centre or institute, operate to turn a technological invention into a commercial product, method or service, and thereby contribute to the development of the region, and where the academic, economic and social structure is integrated,
c) Research and Development (R&D): creative work carried out on a systematic basis to increase the stock of knowledge consisting of culture, human and social knowledge and to use it to design new processes, systems and applications including software,
...
m) R&D Personnel: researchers, software developers and technicians directly engaged in R&D activities,
n) Researcher: experts with at least a bachelor's degree involved in the design or creation of new knowledge, products, processes, methods and systems and in managing the related projects, in R&D activities and projects within the definition of innovation,
o) Technician: persons with technical knowledge and experience who graduated from the design, technical, science or health departments of vocational high schools or vocational colleges,
p) Support Personnel: managers, technical staff, laboratory staff, secretaries, workers and similar personnel participating in or directly related to R&D or design activities,
r) Software Developer Personnel: qualified personnel with sufficient experience or training in their field who work in the process defined as software and develop and produce programs,
...
y) R&D Project: a project whose purpose, scope, general and technical definition, duration, budget, special conditions, amounts of in-kind and/or cash support to be provided by other institutions, organisations, natural and legal persons, and principles for sharing the resulting intellectual property rights have been determined, carried out on scientific principles in a manner determining every stage of R&D activities, and conducted by researcher and/or software developer personnel,
...
means.",

- in the third paragraph of Provisional Article 2:

"Until 31/12/2028, the income tax calculated on the wages of R&D, design and support personnel working in the zone relating to these duties, after applying the minimum living allowance, is cancelled by deducting it from the tax assessed on the withholding tax return to be filed. Documents issued for wages within this scope are exempt from stamp tax..."

Furthermore, Article 3, headed "Definitions and abbreviations", of the Technology Development Zones Implementation Regulation published in Official Gazette No. 29797 of 10/8/2016 states:

"(1) In this Regulation;
...
c) R&D-based production activities means the activities of turning into a commercial product and producing, in production units located within the Zone, original processes, services, methods, production techniques, useful tools, materials, software, products and systems arising from the R&D activities carried out in this Zone by entrepreneurs operating in the Zone,
..."

Accordingly, the income tax calculated on wage payments of R&D, design and support personnel working under Law No. 4691 relating to these duties can be treated within the withholding incentive by deducting it from the tax assessed on the withholding tax return.

That income tax withholding incentive covers creative work carried out on a systematic basis during the product's R&D process before it becomes a final (commercial) product.

Under these provisions and explanations, your staff to be sent to provide services in that product technology during the commissioning and plant operation stages in that country of the "…" and crystallisation product technology, your firm's patented technology developed within the Technopark area affiliated with the İzmir Institute of Technology where you operate to turn a technological invention into a commercial product, method or service, and turned by you into a commercial product in production units in the technopark zone, for use in obtaining clean water from seawater at the desalination and salt production plant set up in Indonesia, cannot benefit from the income tax withholding incentive under Law No. 4691.

Furthermore, if the staff to be sent to provide services during the commissioning and plant operation stages of the product technology in that country are found to have a domicile in Türkiye, the staff must be deemed resident in Türkiye without any other qualification or condition and, as full taxpayers, subjected to income tax withholding under Articles 61, 94, 103 and 104 of the Income Tax Law.

Furthermore, no assessment has been made of the matter relating to staff working at the Indonesian-resident firm for whom you plan to apply for a work permit, since it is not based on a concrete event, and the matter relating to social security premium support should be put to the Social Security Institution.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.