A company importing human tissue and cell products asked which VAT rate applies to supplies of "live cornea" (HS 3001.90.20.00.00) and "artificial eye cornea" (HS 9021.39.90.00.19).
The Administration's view:
- According to letters from the relevant General Directorate of the Ministry of Health, human-origin conventional tissue and cell products, being used for treatment, can be treated in the same class as human medicinal products. Live human cornea is therefore subject to 10% VAT under item 18 of List (II) annexed to the Council of Ministers Decision.
- An artificial eye cornea with no Product Tracking System (ÜTS) record cannot be treated as within item 22 of List (II) (medical devices) and is subject to VAT at the general 20% rate.
The ruling is relevant to importers of tissue and cell products and eye implants.
Full text
Subject: VAT rate on imports and supplies of live cornea and artificial eye cornea under HS 3001.90.20.00.00 and 9021.39.90.00.19
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request forms referred to in (a), (c), (ç) and (f), stating that:
- your company, which imports human-origin tissue and cell products (allografts), could not be registered in the Product Tracking System (ÜTS) because it is not within the cosmetics or medical device classification,
- the products commercially described as "live cornea", stated to be classified under Customs Tariff Statistical Position (HS) No. 3001.90.20.00.00 of the Turkish Customs Tariff Schedule (TGTC), and "artificial eye cornea", stated to be classified under HS No. 9021.39.90.00.19 of the same schedule, which you imported, are within human medicinal products used for patient treatment,
our Directorate's opinion is requested on the value added tax (VAT) rate to be applied on supplies of these products.
VAT rates applied to supplies of goods and services are determined, on the authority granted by Article 28 of VAT Law No. 3065 and within the limits set in that article, by the Council of Ministers before the amendment by Decree-Law No. 700 and by the President after the amendment.
In this context, VAT rates are applied at 1% for supplies and services in List (I) annexed to Council of Ministers Decision (BKK) No. 2007/13033, 10% for supplies and services in List (II), and 20% for taxable transactions not in these lists.
List (II) annexed to that BKK contains:
- in item 18, foods for special medical purposes and human medicinal products licensed or authorised for import by the Ministry of Health, active substances contained in human medicinal products and raw materials used in producing active substances (where goods in this item are also in List (I), the rate set in List (II) applies),
- and in item 22, supplies of devices subject to the provisions of the "Medical Device Regulation" and the "In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Device Regulation" published by the Ministry of Health, and their rental services (excluding goods subject to special consumption tax and goods in heading 85.17 of the Turkish Customs Tariff Schedule Divided Into Statistical Positions annexed to Presidential Decision No. 8040 of 30/12/2023).
Tariff heading 30.01 of the TGTC defines "Glands and other organs for organotherapeutic uses, dried, whether or not powdered; extracts of glands or other organs or of their secretions for organotherapeutic uses; heparin and its salts; other human or animal substances prepared for therapeutic or prophylactic uses, not elsewhere specified or included", and HS No. 3001.90.20.00.00 of that heading "Of human origin",
and tariff heading 90.21 of the same schedule defines "Orthopaedic appliances, including crutches, surgical belts and trusses; splints and other fracture appliances; artificial parts of the body; hearing aids and other appliances which are worn or carried, or implanted in the body, to compensate for a defect or disability:", and HS No. 9021.39.90.00.19 of that heading "Other".
Furthermore, it was stated:
- in the letter dated … No. … addressed to your company by …. General Directorate, following your application to the Ministry of Health on whether this product is within ÜTS, stating that the Customs Administration questioned the need for ÜTS registration of the cornea tissue you wish to import: "under Ministerial Approval dated …. No. …, work and transactions relating to conventional tissues and cells are carried out by the relevant General Directorate, and cornea tissues, which are conventional tissue and cell products, are not registered through ÜTS",
- in the letter dated … No. … addressed to your company again by that General Directorate, following an application to obtain an official letter from the Ministry of Health for submission to the Customs Administration on whether the human-origin cornea tissue you import, which has the features of a conventional tissue and cell but no ÜTS record, is within human medicinal products: "under Ministerial Approval dated … No. .., work and transactions relating to conventional tissues and cells are carried out by the relevant General Directorate in line with the Regulation on the Quality and Safety of Human-Origin Tissue and Cell Products, Human Tissues and Cells and Related Centres and the Communiqué on the Licensing of Human Tissue and Cell Products and Centres Carrying Out Their Production, Import, Export, Storage and Distribution Activities; human-origin conventional tissue and cell products are registered through the Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices National Information Bank; in this framework, although human-origin tissue and cell products imported by your firm are not expressly included in List (II) annexed to BKK No. 2007/13033, since they will be used for treatment in patients there is no objection to treating them in the same class as human medicinal products, active substances contained in these products and raw materials used in producing active substances".
Under the provisions and explanations above, regarding the TGTC:
- since the human-origin "live cornea" stated to be classified under HS No. 3001.90.20.00.00 is treated as within item 18 of List (II) annexed to BKK No. 2007/13033, VAT at 10%,
- since the "artificial eye cornea" stated to be classified under HS No. 9021.39.90.00.19 and having no ÜTS record cannot be treated as within item 22 of List (II) annexed to the same BKK, VAT at the general rate (20%),
must be applied on supplies of these products.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.