A bank asked whether the fee exemption under Law No. 7269 applies to annotating in the land registry a sale promise agreement for 66 independent units that a company will build on its own land in an earthquake zone to meet the bank's staff housing needs, and to the sale of these properties to the bank.
The Administration's view:
- The exemption in Article 42 of Law No. 7269 is exclusive to persons documented as entitled beneficiaries for transactions relating to properties to be built or repaired under that Law.
- The units are not reconstruction or repair of the bank's earthquake-damaged buildings but structures the seller will build for the first time on its own land; the bank is not an entitled beneficiary under that Law.
- Therefore the annotation of the sale promise agreement and the sale of the properties to the bank cannot be exempted from fees under Article 42 of Law No. 7269.
The ruling is relevant to institutions acquiring property in disaster zones.
Full text
Subject: Whether the fee exemption under Law No. 7269 applies to annotating real estate sale promise agreements in the land registry and to the sale of the properties concerned
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether the annotation in the land registry of the "Real Estate Sale Promise Agreement in Notarised Form" drawn up for 66 properties to be built in the earthquake zone … to meet the housing needs of your Bank's employees, and the sale of the properties subject to the agreement to your Bank, can be exempted from fees under Law No. 7269.
Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) annexed to this Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; the second paragraph of Article 63 provides that in real estate transfers and acquisitions the land registry and cadastre fee is calculated on the declared transfer and acquisition price, not less than the property tax value; Article 12 of the section titled "I-Land registry transactions:" of Tariff (4) annexed to the Law provides that in annotating sale promise agreements and easement establishment promise agreements in the land registry, a proportional fee is charged on the price written in the agreement (this price cannot be less than the property tax value of the property subject to the agreement or more than twice the property tax value) and, for those without consideration, on the property tax value; and paragraph 20/a provides that in the transfer and acquisition of real estate for consideration, under a life-care contract or under barter provisions, a proportional fee is charged separately for the transferor and the transferee.
The first paragraph of Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is charged from persons exempted from fees by special laws or for transactions exempted.
On the other hand, Law No. 7269 on Measures to Be Taken and Assistance to Be Provided Due to Disasters Affecting Public Life provides:
- in Article 1, that the provisions of this Law apply to assistance to be provided with measures to be taken in places where buildings and public facilities are damaged or likely to be damaged to a degree affecting general life in disasters such as earthquakes (ground shaking), fire, flood, landslide, rockfall, avalanche, subsidence and similar,
- in Article 2, that regions that have suffered or may suffer floods are determined by the Ministry to which the State Hydraulic Works is attached upon the proposal of the Ministry of Reconstruction and Resettlement, and regions that have suffered or may suffer disasters such as ground shaking, landslide, rockfall and avalanche by the Ministry of Reconstruction and Resettlement, and the boundaries of those occurring or that may occur in cities and towns are marked on the zoning plan, and in towns and villages without a zoning plan on maps or sketches as they are determined, and decided as disaster-exposed regions by the Council of Ministers upon the proposal of the Ministry of Reconstruction and Resettlement, and the boundaries so determined are announced locally by the relevant governorships at the request of the Ministry of Reconstruction and Resettlement,
- in Article 3, that the technical conditions to which all official and private buildings to be newly built, altered, enlarged or substantially repaired in disaster regions announced under Article 2 will be subject are determined by a regulation to be prepared by the Ministry of Reconstruction and Resettlement after obtaining the opinion of the Ministry of Public Works,
- in Article 29, that housing will be built or credit given to families living in buildings that have collapsed, burned or been heavily damaged or are likely to be, and in buildings in places whose expropriation is necessary under zoning plans, provided they are entitled beneficiaries,
- in Article 42, that purchase, sale, mortgage and land registry cadastre transactions of immovables due to the application of this Law, tenders, contracts, licences and other transactions relating to those to be rebuilt or repaired, and declarations, undertakings and contracts to be given and made by those benefiting from this Law, are exempt from all taxes, duties and fees.
As can be seen on examination, the exemption provision in Article 42 of Law No. 7269 is regulated exclusively for persons documented as entitled beneficiaries, for transactions relating to properties to be built or repaired within the application of that Law.
On the other hand, from examination of the Real Estate Sale Promise Agreement in Notarised Form dated …/…/… with journal number … drawn up at … Notary and annexed to the ruling request form, it is understood that the subject of the agreement is the promise to sell to your Bank, for the sale price stated in the agreement, 66 independent units to be built by the seller on land registered in parcel no. … in … Neighbourhood, … district, … province, owned by the seller … Ltd. Şti., the annotation of the sale promise in the land register, and the transfer of ownership of the properties to your bank by the seller provided your Bank fully and completely makes the payments set in the agreement; that therefore the 66 independent units to be built do not relate to independent units in your Bank's name in … province for which reconstruction or repair was decided due to earthquake damage, but to independent units to be built for the first time by the named seller on land owned by the selling firm; and that your Bank is not an entitled beneficiary under Law No. 7269.
Accordingly, the annotation in the land register of the Real Estate Sale Promise Agreement in Notarised Form dated …/…/… with number … drawn up at … Notary for the 66 properties to be built in … Neighbourhood, … district, … province to meet the housing needs of your Bank's employees, and the sale of the properties subject to the agreement to your Bank, cannot be exempted from fees under Article 42 of Law No. 7269.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.