Under a financial restructuring agreement (FRA), properties registered in the name of the debtor company and a joint guarantor were transferred to a creditor institution against the receivable, with the land registry fee exemption applied. The creditor institution will transfer these properties back to their former owners under an option agreement; the question was whether the land registry fee exemption applies to these transfers.
The Administration's view:
- The fee exemption in Provisional Article 32/7 of Law No. 5411 does not apply where creditor institutions dispose of assets they acquired, except for transfers between creditor institutions or to the debtor.
- The transfer of the properties under the option agreement to the company named as debtor in the FRA is exempt from fees.
- The transfer to the joint guarantor, who does not fall within the statutory definition of debtor and is not named as debtor in the FRA, cannot be exempted from fees.
The ruling is relevant to banks, debtors and guarantors transferring assets under financial restructuring.
Full text
Subject: Transfer of real estate under an option agreement drawn up pursuant to a financial restructuring agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, stating that under the "Financial Restructuring Agreement" drawn up on …/…/… between the creditor institutions (…bank A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş., …bank T.A.Ş., … Finansal Kiralama A.Ş., … Katılım Bankası A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş.) and the debtor … and joint guarantors …, various properties registered in the name of joint guarantor … and the property in parcel … block … … district … province registered in the name of … were transferred to … A.Ş. against the receivable with the land registry fee exemption applied, and that the properties received by creditor … A.Ş. against the receivable will now be transferred to their former owners, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether the land registry fee exemption will apply to the transfer transactions to be made at the land registry.
Provisional Article 32, added to Banking Law No. 5411 by Article 17 of Law No. 7186 on Amendments to the Income Tax Law and Certain Laws, effective from 19/7/2019, provides:
- in its first paragraph, that debtors in a credit relationship with banks, financial leasing companies, factoring companies and financing companies operating in Türkiye and other financial institutions defined in this article, and identified in Framework Agreements prepared under the regulation issued by the Agency, may be subjected to restructuring as a whole or partly with other debtors in the risk group they belong to, in order to enable them to fulfil their repayment obligations and continue contributing to employment through measures to be taken regarding loans extended by these institutions; that the procedures and principles of financial restructurings under this article will be determined by Framework Agreements prepared within the regulation provisions issued by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency; that the provisions of this article will apply for two years from its publication; and that the President is authorised to extend this period by two more years,
- in subparagraph (ç) of its second paragraph, that "Debtor" means companies established in Türkiye other than institutions subject to this Law, Insurance Law No. 5684, Financial Leasing, Factoring and Financing Companies Law No. 6361, Law No. 6493 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions, and Article 35 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362 excluding investment trusts;
- in its seventh paragraph, that transactions to be made under the principles set in the Framework Agreements made under this article and the Agreements drawn up within these Agreements are exempt from fees charged under Fees Law No. 492 (including judicial fees), and that the exemptions in this paragraph will not apply where creditor institutions dispose of assets and collateral they acquired directly or indirectly due to transactions within the Framework Agreements and the Agreements drawn up within them, except for transfers between creditor institutions or to the debtor,
and the application period of that article was extended by two years by Presidential Decision No. 4299 published in Official Gazette No. 31542 of 15/7/2021.
The "Financial Restructuring Agreement" dated …/…/… annexed to the ruling request form states:
- in part (1.1) of Section 1, titled "Parties", that the creditor institutions are … A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş., …bank A.Ş., … Finansal Kiralama A.Ş., … Katılım Bankası A.Ş., … Bankası A.Ş.; in part (1.2) that the debtor is …; and in part (1.3) that the joint guarantors are …, …, … Ltd. Şti., … A.Ş.,
- in part "A. Provisions on Transfer of Real Estate to Liquidate Part of the Debt" of the section titled "7.1. Restructuring Conditions for … A.Ş.":
- in item (i), that the debtors accept, declare and undertake to transfer to … A.Ş., by …/…/… at the latest, ownership of the properties specified in table-2, to be set off by … A.Ş. ex officio against part of the debts determined in Table-1 of Article 4 of the agreement,
- in item (v), that after the transfer to … A.Ş. of ownership of all the properties specified in Table-2 is completed under the conditions and periods set in the agreement, … A.Ş. will grant the debtor an option right and an "Option Right Agreement" will be signed in this regard as an annex and integral part of the agreement,
- in item (vi), that the precondition for granting the debtor an option right is the completion of the transfer to … A.Ş. of all the properties specified in Table-2 in accordance with the agreement provisions, and that if this agreement goes into default in any period the option right to be granted to the debtor by … A.Ş. will end.
On the other hand, part (1.1) of the section titled "1. Option Right to Request Repurchase" of the "Option Right Agreement" signed on …/…/… between ... and … A.Ş. states that the right holder (… A.Ş.) has the right to request transfer of ownership of the real estate whose ownership has passed to the bank and which is listed in ANNEX-A within the period defined as the option period, provided the conditions in the agreement have not been breached; and item (4.1) of the section titled "4. Option Period" states that the "Option Right to Request Repurchase" granted to the right holder by this agreement must be used by the right holder starting at the earliest from 09.00 on the day following the date ownership of the real estate was transferred to the bank, and at the latest by 17.00 on …/…/….
Also, on examination of the ruling request form and its annexes, it is stated that various properties registered in the name of joint guarantor … and the property in parcel … block … … district registered in the name of debtor … A.Ş. were transferred to … A.Ş. by sale, and that an "Option Right Agreement" was signed on …/…/…, under which the "Option Right to Request Repurchase" granted to the right holder must be used by the right holder starting at the earliest from 09.00 on the day following the date ownership of the real estate was transferred to the bank, and at the latest by 17.00 on …/…/….
Accordingly, considering that the seventh paragraph of Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411 provides that the exemptions in that paragraph will not apply where creditor institutions dispose of assets and collateral they acquired directly or indirectly due to transactions within the Framework Agreements and the Agreements drawn up within them, except for transfers between creditor institutions or to the debtor, it is possible to exempt from fees under Provisional Article 32 of Law No. 5411 the transactions for transfer of the properties acquired by … A.Ş. under the "Financial Restructuring Agreement" dated …/…/… to … A.Ş., named as debtor in the Financial Restructuring Agreement, pursuant to the "Option Right Agreement" signed on …/…/…, whereas it is not possible to exempt from fees the transactions for transfer of those properties to the joint guarantor …, who does not fall within the definition of debtor in the law and is not named as debtor in the "Financial Restructuring Agreement".
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.