TREN
Contact us

Physical Gold Held by a Bank for Savings Purposes Is Valued at Cost in the 2024/2 Provisional Tax Period and at Exchange Price Thereafter

Tax Procedure · ValuationPhysical Gold Held by a Bank for Savings Purposes Is Valued at Cost in the 2024/2 Provisional Tax Period and at Exchange Price ThereafterPrivate ruling · 15 January 2025
Rast note

A bank holding physical gold stock for banking activities and valuing it at cost as merchandise asked how the gold should be valued in light of TPL 274/A, in force from 2/8/2024 under Law No. 7524, and whether the difference between cost and exchange price as at 30/6/2024 is taken into account in the 2024/2 provisional tax period.

The Administration's view:

  • From 2/8/2024, precious metals held for savings purposes and not as trading goods are valued at exchange price; precious metals recorded as trading goods by those engaged in production and trading of precious metals are valued at cost as merchandise.
  • Regardless of the date they entered the assets, physical gold held for savings purposes is valued at exchange price at period ends, and valuation differences are taken into account in determining corporate income.
  • Such gold acquired before 2/8/2024 is valued at cost at the end of the second provisional tax period of 2024, and at exchange price at subsequent provisional tax period and accounting period ends.

The ruling is relevant to banks and businesses holding physical gold or other precious metals in their assets.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Valuation of precious metals
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request forms referred to above, stating that:

- your Bank holds physical gold stock in order to carry out transactions listed in Article 4, titled activity subjects, of Banking Law No. 5411,

- that gold stock was treated as merchandise under Article 274 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213 and valued at cost, but Law No. 213 was amended by Law No. 7524 adding Article 274/A from 2/8/2024, providing that physical gold must be valued at exchange price after this date,

it is understood that our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the physical gold in your Bank's stock will be valued at cost until 2/8/2024, the effective date of Article 274/A, and at exchange price after this date, and whether the difference between the cost and the exchange price of the physical gold stock in assets as at 30/6/2024 will be taken into account in determining income in the corporate provisional tax return for the 2024/2 provisional tax period.

Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:

- in Article 258: "Valuation is the assessment and determination of economic assets relating to the calculation of tax bases.",

- in Article 259: "In valuation, the values that economic assets have on the days and times shown in tax laws are taken as the basis.",

- in Article 262: "Cost price means the total of payments made in connection with acquiring an economic asset or increasing its value and all expenses incidental thereto. ...",

- in Article 263:

"Exchange price means the average values of transactions on the exchange on the last transaction day before valuation of economic assets registered on securities and foreign exchange exchanges, or on commodity and precious metals exchanges.
Where clear instability in prices beyond normal fluctuations is seen, the Ministry of Finance is authorised to have the average price within the 30 days preceding valuation taken as the basis instead of the last transaction day.",

- in Article 274: "Merchandise is valued at cost. Where the sale prices of merchandise on the valuation day show a decline of 10% or more compared with cost, the taxpayer may apply the arm's-length price measure instead of cost, excluding the method in the second order of Article 267. This provision may also be applied to the products listed in Article 275.",

- in Article 274/A:

"Precious metals such as gold, silver, platinum and palladium are valued at exchange price. If there is no exchange price or the exchange price is found to have been formed collusively, cost is taken as the valuation basis instead of this price.
This provision also applies to receivables and payables in precious metals, with or without notes. Receivables and payables based on deposit or loan agreements in precious metals are taken into account together with interest to be calculated until the valuation day. The provisions in Articles 280, 281 and 285 on reducing receivables and payables to their valuation day value also apply to receivables and payables within this paragraph."

Under Article 274/A of the Tax Procedure Law, added to Law No. 213 by Article 8 of Law No. 7524 and in force from 2/8/2024, precious metals held by taxpayers in their assets for savings purposes, and their receivables and payables in precious metals, must be valued at exchange price.

Accordingly, from 2/8/2024:

- precious metals held by businesses for savings purposes and not disposed of as trading goods will be valued at exchange price (if there is no exchange price or the exchange price is found to have been formed collusively, cost will be taken as the valuation basis instead of this price),

- precious metals recorded as trading goods in the assets of taxpayers engaged in production and trading of precious metals will be valued at cost since they are merchandise under Article 274 of Law No. 213.

In this context, physical gold held for savings purposes and not treated as trading goods will be valued at exchange price at period ends regardless of the date it entered the business's assets, and the resulting valuation differences will be taken into account in determining corporate income.

In this vein, physical gold acquired before 2/8/2024 and held for savings purposes must be valued at cost at the end of the second provisional tax period of the 2024 accounting period, and at exchange price at the ends of subsequent provisional tax periods and the accounting period, with the resulting valuation differences taken into account in determining corporate income.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.