A company in a technology development zone, which from 1/1/2023 began paying R&D staff gross rather than net wages, asked whether the income tax cancelled after the minimum wage exemption remains with the employer or the employee.
The Administration's view:
- Wages may be set gross or net in the employment contract; this is subject to private law.
- Under Provisional Article 2 of Law No. 4691, after 1/1/2022 the income tax remaining after deducting the tax attributable to the minimum wage exemption is cancelled from the tax accrued on the withholding and premium service return.
- Cancellation means the State waiving, in favour of the employer (the withholding agent), the collection of tax that has become payable; with gross wage payments, the company is the one that benefits from this incentive.
The ruling is relevant to companies employing R&D staff in technology development zones.
Full text
Subject: Who benefits from the incentive in Provisional Article 2 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company has operated in the Istanbul University Technology Development Zone under Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 since 2/5/2017, that salary payments to staff working under the Law were made on a net basis from the start of activity, and that from 1/1/2023 salary payments to those staff began to be made on a gross basis by decision of your Company's senior management, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether, under that Law, the portion to be cancelled from the income tax calculated on gross wage payments after deducting the minimum wage exemption, when filing the withholding and premium service return, will remain with the employer or the staff.
Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:
- in Article 61, titled "Definition of wages":
"Wages are money and in-kind values given in return for services to those working subject to an employer and attached to a specific workplace, and benefits provided that can be represented in money.
The fact that wages are paid under the names of allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial liability compensation), appropriation, raise, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense allowance or other names, or determined as a certain percentage of profit provided it is not in the nature of a partnership relationship, does not change their nature.
...",
- in Article 94, titled "Tax withholding":
"Public administrations and institutions, public economic institutions, other entities, commercial companies, business partnerships, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed persons obliged to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural income on the balance sheet or agricultural business account basis are obliged to withhold tax against the income tax of the beneficiaries when making the payments listed in the following items (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account.
1. From wages paid to employees and payments listed in Article 61 and deemed wages (excluding those benefiting from the exemption), according to Articles 103 and 104,
...
... tax is withheld...",
- in Article 96, titled "Principles to be followed in tax withholding": "Tax withholding applies to payments within Article 94 made in cash or on account. The term payment on account in this article means all kinds of records and transactions showing those paying income and revenue subject to withholding as indebted to the beneficiaries. Tax withholding is made on gross amounts for payments other than wages. Where the tax to be withheld is assumed by the payer, this tax is calculated on the total of the amount actually paid and the tax assumed by the payer."
Item (18) added by Article 2 of Law No. 7349 to the first paragraph of Article 23 of the same Law, which regulates wage exemptions, provides: "Wages of employees corresponding to the amount remaining after deducting the employee social security premium and unemployment insurance premium from the monthly gross amount of the minimum wage applicable in the month of payment (However, in taxing wage income exceeding the exemption, the income bracket amounts and rates on which tax is calculated are determined taking into account the amounts within the exemption. The tax payable is calculated by deducting from the tax so found the portion corresponding to the exempt amount. The tax not collected due to the exemption cannot exceed the tax to be calculated on the monthly minimum wage in the relevant month. For those receiving wages from more than one employer, this exemption applies only to the highest wage.)."
On this subject, the necessary explanations and application examples are given in Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 319 published in Official Gazette No. 31732 of 27/1/2022, and Article 8 of the Communiqué, titled "Wage payments within incentives and exemptions", states:
"...
b) on wages paid to R&D, design and support staff under Provisional Article 2 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 of 26/6/2001,
...
the portion of the income tax calculated remaining after applying the minimum living allowance was cancelled from the tax accrued on the withholding and premium service return to be filed.
Due to the exemption introduced by item (18) of the first paragraph of Article 23 of Law No. 193 and the abolition of the minimum living allowance, the exemption regulated in item (18) of the first paragraph of Article 23 of Law No. 193 will first be applied to these wage payments within incentives, and the tax after the exemption will be cancelled from accrual within the limits in the relevant regulations. Under regulations providing for cancellation from accrual of the tax corresponding to the minimum wage, since no tax is collected on the minimum wage due to the exemption, no tax calculation requiring cancellation from accrual will be made.
..."
Article 8 of Labour Law No. 4857 provides that an employment contract is a contract under which one party (the employee) undertakes to work dependently and the other party (the employer) undertakes to pay wages, that unless otherwise stated in the Law the employment contract is not subject to a special form, and that employment contracts with a term of one year or more must be made in writing. Under this provision, employment contracts between the employer and the employee contain information such as the employee's general and special working conditions, working hours, wage amount, wage payment period and contract term, the wage payment to the employee may be set gross or net, and the application of these contracts is subject to private law provisions.
On the other hand, the third paragraph of Provisional Article 2 of Technology Development Zones Law No. 4691 (as amended by Article 7 of Law No. 7263 published in Official Gazette No. 31384 of 03/02/2021) provides: "Until 31/12/2028, the income tax calculated after applying the minimum living allowance on wages of R&D, design and support staff working in the zone relating to these duties is cancelled by deducting it from the tax accrued on the withholding return to be filed. Documents drawn up relating to wages within this scope are exempt from stamp duty. The number of support staff who will benefit from incentives relating to income tax withholding and the employer's share of insurance premiums cannot exceed ten percent of the number of R&D and design staff. For Zone firms with a total of up to fifteen staff, this rate is applied as twenty percent..."
Subparagraph (c) of the first paragraph of Article 35, titled "Exemptions", of the Technology Development Zones Implementing Regulation states: "Until 31/12/2028, from the tax calculated on wages of R&D, design and support staff working in the Zone relating to these duties, the tax amount remaining after deducting the minimum living allowance regulated in Article 32 of Income Tax Law No. 193 of 31/12/1960 before 1/1/2022, and after 1/1/2022 the tax corresponding to the minimum wage exemption regulated in item (18) of the first paragraph of Article 23 of Law No. 193, is cancelled by deducting it from the tax accrued on the withholding return to be filed..."
Accrual means the tax reaching the stage of being payable, and the cancellation from accrual, which we refer to as the withholding incentive, is the State waiving, partly or fully in favour of the employer (the withholding agent), the collection of tax that has reached the stage of being payable.
Accordingly, while wages of R&D, design and support staff working under Law No. 4691 relating to these duties were exempt from income tax before 03/02/2021, from that date, from the income tax calculated on those wages:
- until 1/1/2022, the income tax remaining after deducting the minimum living allowance,
- after 1/1/2022, the income tax remaining after deducting the tax corresponding to the minimum wage exemption regulated in item (18) of the first paragraph of Article 23 of Law No. 193
will be cancelled by deducting it from the tax accrued on the withholding and premium service return to be filed.
In this context, the tax remaining after deducting the tax corresponding to the minimum wage exemption from the income tax calculated on the wage amounts you have paid gross since 1/1/2023 to R&D, design and support staff under Provisional Article 2 of Law No. 4691 must be cancelled on the withholding and premium service return, and the incentive so provided will have been benefited from by your Company.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.