TREN
Contact us

Registering the Mortgage After Individual Title Transfer Does Not Prevent BITT and RUSF Exemption on Housing Loans to Building Cooperative Members

OtherRegistering the Mortgage After Individual Title Transfer Does Not Prevent BITT and RUSF Exemption on Housing Loans to Building Cooperative MembersPrivate ruling · 5 November 2024
Rast note

A bank stated that, when extending housing loans to members of a building cooperative, the mortgage could not be registered on the same day as the collective individual title transfer at the land registry and would be registered afterwards, and asked how this affects the Banking and Insurance Transactions Tax (BITT) exemption and Resource Utilisation Support Fund (RUSF) exemption.

The Administration's view:

  • For the BITT and RUSF exemptions on housing loans, as a rule the dwelling must be secured by a mortgage and the acquisition and loan must be simultaneous.
  • Since the obstacle to simultaneity arises from a software problem in the land registry system, provided the bank establishes the housing acquisition purpose with sufficient information and documents and undertakes responsibility for registering the mortgage after the individual title transfer, the loans are treated as housing finance; the BITT exemption applies and no RUSF is deducted.
  • For loans used from 28/12/2023, the consumer must not own a registered dwelling or dwelling share on the loan date to benefit from the BITT exemption.

The ruling is relevant to banks extending housing loans to building cooperative members.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: BITT and RUSF exemption where the housing loan and mortgage for cooperative-built homes are not simultaneous after individual registration
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of the ruling request form and your petition referred to above, stating that your bank extended a loan to … Housing Building Cooperative for housing construction, that construction was completed in 2022 and individual title transfers (registration in the names of cooperative members) began in the same year, that during the process of extending housing loans to those cooperative members your bank was informed by the land registry directorate that, because the individual title transfer for cooperative constructions is carried out collectively, it is not systemically possible to carry out the mortgage and individual title transfer on the same day, and that after the individual title transfer is completed the mortgage can be registered by your bank once members obtain appointments through the web land registry system, it is understood that an opinion is requested from our Directorate on whether the mortgage registration to be made after the housing loan is extended will affect the banking and insurance transactions tax (BITT) exemption and the resource utilisation support fund (RUSF) deduction.

The first paragraph of Article 28 of Expenditure Taxes Law No. 6802 provides that money received in cash or on account in their favour under any name by banks and insurance companies due to all their transactions of any kind, excluding transactions under Financial Leasing Law No. 3226 of 10/6/1985, is subject to BITT; and Article 30, which determines the taxpayer, provides that BITT is paid by banks, bankers and insurance companies.

Subparagraph (y) of the first paragraph of Article 29 of the same Law was amended by subparagraph (c) of Article 6 of Law No. 7491 on Amendments to Certain Laws and Decree-Laws as "All transactions of mortgage finance institutions and housing finance funds within housing finance as defined in the first paragraph of Article 57 of Law No. 6362, and money received in favour due to housing loans extended by housing finance institutions under the same Law to consumers who do not own a registered dwelling as at the date the loan is used, and due to the refinancing of these loans.", and that amendment entered into force on 28/12/2023. Under this amendment, the exemption for housing loans was limited by removing from the exemption money received in favour due to housing loans used directly by those who own a registered dwelling as at the date the loan is used.

On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 57 of Capital Markets Law No. 6362, in force from 30/12/2012, provides: "Housing finance is extending loans to consumers to acquire dwellings, leasing dwellings to consumers by financial leasing, extending loans to consumers secured by dwellings they own, and extending loans to refinance these loans. Transactions of housing finance institutions, housing finance funds and mortgage finance institutions based on or secured by these loans and receivables are also within this scope."

Also, the letter dated 22/10/2008 with number 16736 received as a result of correspondence with the Capital Markets Board on the subject states that by Decision No. 26/1059 of 26/9/2008 of the Board's Decision Body it was decided to notify our Ministry that "Where the loan is extended against cash without taking a mortgage on the dwelling subject to the loan, the loan will have the nature of a standard "consumer loan" rather than a "housing loan" and will therefore fall outside housing finance, since while "extending loans for the purpose of acquiring a dwelling" was included in housing finance under Article 38/A added to the Capital Markets Law, the credit institution was obliged to determine the consumer's purpose in using the loan, and considering that the most important element in determining the loan purpose is the mortgage, only mortgage-secured loans can be treated within housing finance ...".

On the other hand, Article 2 of Communiqué Serial No. 6 on RUSF relating to Decree No. 88/12944 of 12/5/1988 provides that RUSF will be deducted at 15% on consumer loans extended by banks and financing companies (loans extended to individuals provided they are not used for commercial purposes) and at 0% (zero) on other loans.

Item 2 of Article 3 of the same Communiqué exempts housing and building savings loans and housing construction loans extended to individuals for their own needs from the fund deduction.

Also, RUSF Deduction Circular Serial No. 2 contains explanations on the status of loans to be extended within housing finance with respect to the RUSF deduction.

Under these provisions, it is possible for housing loans extended by banks to individuals for the purchase of a dwelling to be exempted from BITT and for no RUSF to be deducted from these loans, provided the dwelling is secured by a mortgage, and the acquisition of the dwelling and the use of the loan must be carried out simultaneously. On the other hand, for housing loans used from 28/12/2023, only housing loans extended to consumers who do not own a registered dwelling as at the date the loan is used can benefit from the BITT exemption.

On the other hand, the letter dated 10/3/2023 with number 7879023 received as a result of correspondence on the subject with the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change (Land Registry and Cadastre General Directorate) states in summary that, although there is no provision in their legislation preventing the individual title transfer and mortgage of condominium and construction-servitude independent units of building cooperatives in the nature of dwellings and workplaces from being completed together under a single journal number, TAKBİS does not allow this systemically/in software and therefore the mortgage can be established by a separate transaction after the individual title transfer is completed, that on the other hand there is no legal provision preventing the establishment of a mortgage after the individual title transfer is completed, and that ultimately the completion of the individual title transfer, the mortgage, or the individual title transfer and mortgage in succession may vary according to the workload of the relevant directorate, and gives the opinion that the necessary systemic software arrangement can be made so that the individual title transfer and mortgage can be handled at the same time under a single official deed and single journal number.

In addition, the letter dated 15/12/2023 with number 46837 received as a result of correspondence on the subject with the Capital Markets Board states in summary that, although there is no doubt that a loan secured by a mortgage is within housing finance under Article 57 of Law No. 6362, considering that a mortgage is also envisaged in the transaction subject to the petition but, since it is not systemically possible to carry out the mortgage and individual title transfer on the same day, the bank can register the mortgage after the individual title transfer is completed, and that the situation preventing simultaneous individual title transfer and mortgage arises from a systemic software problem of the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change, it is possible to treat that transaction within the first paragraph of Article 57 of Law No. 6362 provided the housing finance institution establishes the housing acquisition purpose at the loan stage and undertakes responsibility for establishing the mortgage after the individual title transfer.

In this context, considering that in this case the situation preventing simultaneous individual title transfer and mortgage arises from a systemic software problem of the Land Registry and Cadastre General Directorate, it is possible to treat the loans to be extended to the members of that housing building cooperative within housing finance, to apply the BITT exemption to money received in favour due to these loans and not to deduct the fund from those loans, provided your bank establishes the housing acquisition purpose of the loans with sufficient information and documents and you also undertake responsibility for establishing the mortgage after the individual title transfer.

However, it is natural that for housing loans used from 28/12/2023, to benefit from the BITT exemption the consumer must not own a registered dwelling/dwelling share as at the date the loan is used.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.