TREN
Contact us

VAT on Leasing Municipal Real Estate to a Municipal Company via Usufruct Depends on Whether a Public Economic Enterprise Arises

VAT · ExemptionsVAT on Leasing Municipal Real Estate to a Municipal Company via Usufruct Depends on Whether a Public Economic Enterprise ArisesPrivate ruling · 23 October 2024
Rast note

A company wholly owned by a municipality stated that it leased the municipality's real estate through a tender by establishing a 10-year usufruct right, and asked whether the rent is subject to VAT.

The Administration's view:

  • Leasing of bare ownership does not create an economic enterprise unless it is carried out for commercial purposes or within a commercial organisation, or continuously at a certain volume and significance; leases that include the transfer of an operating right do create an economic enterprise.
  • If a public economic enterprise arises within the municipality due to the usufruct lease, the lease is subject to VAT under Article 1 of the VAT Law; otherwise it is exempt from VAT under Article 17/4-d.

The ruling is relevant to real estate leasing and usufruct transactions between municipalities and municipal companies.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: VAT on leasing municipal real estate by establishing a usufruct right
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

It is understood from the ruling request form referred to above that, stating that real estate belonging to … Municipality was leased through a tender to your Company, the entire capital of which belongs to … Municipality, by establishing a 10-year usufruct right, it is asked whether the rent is subject to value added tax (VAT); our Presidency's opinion on the matter is given below.

Article 2 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists public economic enterprises among corporate taxpayers; the third paragraph of that article provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging or attached to the State, special provincial administrations, municipalities, other public administrations and institutions, whose activities are continuous and which are not capital companies or cooperatives, are public economic enterprises; and the sixth paragraph provides that their not pursuing profit, their activities being among duties given by law, their not having legal personality, and their not having independent accounting and capital or workplaces allocated to them do not affect their taxpayer status, and that the price of goods or services being only enough to cover cost, not making a profit or allocating profit to their founding purposes does not change their economic character.

Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, containing explanations on the application of that Law, states:

- in section (2.3.1.), that the explanations in section (2.4.) of the Communiqué must be taken into account in determining whether a public economic enterprise constitutes a commercial, industrial or agricultural enterprise,

- in section (2.4.), that the distinctive features of economic enterprises are attachment, continuity and the activity being commercial, industrial or agricultural in nature, in other words that the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as buying and selling goods, manufacturing or performing services for consideration within the market economy based on an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity, that instead of listing such cases one by one the Law covers all economic activities carried out by an association or foundation within the market economy, and that the price of goods or services sold being only enough to cover cost, not making a profit, or allocating profit to founding purposes does not change their status as economic enterprises,

- in section (15.3.2.3.), that no tax is withheld from rent payments made to corporate taxpayers listed in Article 1 of the Corporate Tax Law (except cooperatives) for leasing their immovables, and these institutions declare their rental income in the corporate tax return for the relevant accounting period; and that where immovables of associations and foundations are leased so as to form an economic enterprise, no tax is withheld from the rental income since the resulting economic enterprise is a corporate taxpayer,

- in section (15.3.2.4.), that no tax is withheld from rent payments made to the State, special administrations, municipalities and villages for leasing their immovables.

Whether an economic enterprise arises in leasing transactions will be evaluated separately for leasing of bare ownership and for leasing of real estate that has the nature of an economic enterprise and includes the transfer of the operating right.

As long as leases in the form of bare ownership leasing are not carried out for commercial purposes or within a commercial organisation, or are not continuously of a certain volume and significance, it is not possible to speak of an economic enterprise due to that lease. However, since leasing the operating right held over real estate made ready for operation and allocated to the performance of an economic activity includes the transfer of the operating right, such leases must be accepted as commercial leases and as creating an economic enterprise.

From examination of the usufruct agreement drawn up between … Municipality and your Company annexed to the ruling request form, it is understood that the subject of the agreement is the establishment of a usufruct right over immovables owned by … Municipality located at parcel … block … … Neighbourhood … district … province.

Accordingly, although the Municipality is not a corporate taxpayer by virtue of its legal personality, if the transfer of its immovables by establishing a usufruct right is carried out for commercial purposes or within a commercial organisation, or is continuously of a certain volume and significance, or includes the transfer of the operating right, corporate tax liability must be established for the public economic enterprise that arises within the Municipality. Otherwise, no public economic enterprise will arise due to that lease.

On the other hand, VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,

- in Article 1/3-f, that leasing of goods and rights specified in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT,

- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of establishments belonging or subject to, or founded or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and their unions, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations, and of revolving fund entities or other establishments belonging or subject to them, are subject to VAT,

- in Article 17/4-d, that leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises is exempt from VAT.

Article 1 of the same Law provides that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are determined according to the Income Tax Law and, where the Income Tax Law is unclear, according to the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation, and that these activities being carried out as required by laws or official authorities, the legal status and personality of those carrying them out, whether they are Turkish nationals, and whether their residence or workplace or legal or business centre is in Turkey do not change the nature of the transactions and do not prevent taxation.

The VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:

- in section (I/B-2.) titled "Taxation of Public Institutions and Organisations, Associations and Foundations and Professional Organisations",

"Deliveries and services of administrations within the general budget, special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and their unions, universities, associations and foundations and all kinds of professional organisations listed in Article (1/3-g) of Law No. 3065, that are not within commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities and are in line with their founding purposes, are not subject to tax.
Leasing of goods and rights within Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under Article (1/3-f) of the Law. However, leasing of real estate of the above organisations not included in their economic enterprises is exempt from tax under Article (17/4-d) of the Law.
On the other hand, establishments belonging or subject to, or founded and operated by, the above organisations and revolving fund entities are considered economic enterprises. Their commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are subject to tax. In this framework, bus, gas, water, electricity, slaughterhouse, cold storage etc. enterprises attached to municipalities and revolving fund entities are subject to tax for their activities not within the scope of exemption.",

- in section (II/F-4.4.) titled "Leasing of Real Estate Not Included in Economic Enterprises",

"Leasing of goods and rights specified in Article (1/3-f) of Law No. 3065 and Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to tax. In contrast, leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises is exempted from tax by Article (17/4-d) of the Law.
Only immovables fall within the scope of this exemption; leasing of other goods and rights listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under the general provisions.
...
Leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises (land, buildings and integral parts and accessories leased together with them, fishing grounds and fish weirs, and rights registered in the land registry as immovables) is not subject to VAT; only leasing of real estate included in an economic enterprise is subject to VAT.
Leasing of goods and rights other than the above real estate listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law (exploration, operating, concession rights and licences and other rights) is subject to VAT regardless of whether they are included in an economic enterprise..."

Section (1.4.) titled "Leasing Transactions" of VAT Circular No. 60, containing explanations on the matter, states:

"... all kinds of leasing transactions of economic enterprises are subject to VAT under Article 1/1 of the VAT Law.
Although leasing of goods and rights listed in Article 70 of the Income Tax Law is subject to VAT under Article 1/3-f of the VAT Law, leasing of real estate not included in economic enterprises is exempt from VAT.
In this framework, leasing of an operating right in the form of leaving an enterprise or establishment to the use of another for a certain price and period will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-f of the Law, even if it is defined as income from immovable property for income tax purposes..."

Accordingly, if a public economic enterprise arises within the Municipality due to the leasing of immovables owned by … Municipality to your Company by establishing a usufruct right, that lease will be subject to VAT under Article 1 of Law No. 3065, and if no public economic enterprise arises within the Municipality, it is natural that the lease will be exempt from VAT under Article 17/4-d of the Law.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.