A company owning land in a renewal area under Law No. 5366 asked whether, when it sells to third parties its share of the independent units completed under a revenue-sharing sale promise and construction agreement with a contractor joint venture, these sales are exempt from land registry fees under Article 3/6 of Law No. 5366.
The Administration's view:
- Applications in renewal areas are exempt from all taxes, duties, fees and charges; however, Law No. 5366 contains no provision exempting from land registry fees the sale to third parties of buildings built by parcel owners.
- Therefore, sales to third parties of the independent units completed under the agreement cannot be exempted from fees under Law No. 5366.
The ruling is relevant to companies owning land in renewal areas under Law No. 5366 and selling units after the project.
Full text
Subject: Land registry fee on sales to third parties, under a real estate sale promise agreement, of immovables within the scope of Law No. 5366
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
Reference: Ruling request form dated 26.08.2024 and numbered 3880566.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above, stating that … independent units were completed under the "Real Estate Sale Promise in Official Form with Revenue Sharing in Return for Land Sale and Construction Agreement" dated … with journal number … drawn up at … Notary between your company and … Joint Venture, on the immovable registered at parcel … block … map sheet … … neighbourhood … district, owned by your company and located in a renewal area under Law No. 5366, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether the sale to third parties of the independent units that your company, as landowner, will take over from the contractor firm will be exempted from land registry fees under the sixth paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 5366.
Article 57 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that land registry and cadastre transactions listed in Tariff (4) attached to this Law are subject to land registry and cadastre fees; paragraph I/20-a of Tariff (4) attached to the Law provides that a proportional fee is collected separately from the transferor and the transferee on the transfer and acquisition of immovables for consideration, under a lifetime maintenance contract or according to barter provisions.
The first paragraph of Article 123 of the same Law provides that no fee is collected from persons exempted from fees by special laws or for transactions exempted.
Article 1 of Law No. 5366 on the Protection by Renewal and Use by Revitalisation of Deteriorated Historical and Cultural Immovable Assets provides that the purpose of the Law is, by metropolitan municipalities, district and first-tier municipalities within metropolitan boundaries, provincial and district municipalities and municipalities with a population over 50,000, and by special provincial administrations outside the jurisdiction of these municipalities, to rebuild and restore, in line with the development of the region, deteriorated areas that are about to lose their character and that have been registered and declared as protected sites by conservation boards for cultural and natural assets, and their protection areas, to create housing, commercial, cultural, tourism and social facility areas in these regions, to take measures against natural disaster risks, and to protect historical and cultural immovable assets by renewal and use them by revitalisation; Article 2 provides that renewal areas are determined by a decision of the absolute majority of the full membership of the provincial general council in special provincial administrations and of the municipal council in municipalities, that decisions taken by the provincial general council in special provincial administrations and by the municipal council in municipalities outside metropolitan areas are submitted to the President, that in metropolitan areas such decisions taken by district and first-tier municipal councils are submitted to the President if approved by the metropolitan municipal council, and that the President decides within three months whether the project will be implemented; the first paragraph of Article 3 provides that renewal projects and applications prepared or commissioned by the special provincial administration and municipality in areas designated as renewal areas are carried out by the relevant special provincial administrations and municipalities or implemented by having them done by public institutions and organisations or natural persons and private law legal entities; the third paragraph provides that, in applications on building parcels within the renewal area, buildings to be renewed while preserving their own parcel and structure may be built by the parcel owner provided they adhere to the project accepted by the municipality without disrupting the integrity of the project and are used for the purpose determined by the special provincial administration and municipality, that in such cases it is essential that the application is started and completed simultaneously with the project, and that otherwise the provisions of this Law will be applied by the special provincial administration and municipality; and the sixth paragraph provides that applications in renewal areas are exempt from all kinds of taxes, duties, fees and charges.
Accordingly, although renewal projects and applications prepared or commissioned by the special provincial administration and municipality in renewal areas must be carried out by the relevant special provincial administrations and municipalities or implemented by having them done by public institutions and organisations or natural persons and private law legal entities, it is possible, in applications on building parcels within the renewal area, for buildings to be renewed while preserving their own parcel and structure to be built by the parcel owner provided they adhere to the project accepted by the municipality without disrupting the integrity of the project and are used for the purpose determined by the special provincial administration and municipality; Law No. 5366 contains no provision that transactions relating to the sale to third parties of buildings built in this way by parcel owners will be exempted from land registry fees.
Accordingly, it is not possible to exempt from fees under Law No. 5366 the sale to third parties of the … independent units completed under the "Real Estate Sale Promise in Official Form with Revenue Sharing in Return for Land Sale and Construction Agreement" dated … with journal number … drawn up at … Notary between your Company and … Joint Venture, on the immovable registered at parcel … block … map sheet … … neighbourhood … district, understood to be located in an area designated as a renewal area under Law No. 5366.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.