TREN
Contact us

Sale of Registered Software Is Exempt Under ITL 18, Implementation and Training Services Are Self-Employment Income; Both Are Subject to VAT

Personal Income Tax · Self-employment incomeSale of Registered Software Is Exempt Under ITL 18, Implementation and Training Services Are Self-Employment Income; Both Are Subject to VATPrivate ruling · 9 October 2024
Rast note

A self-employed certified public accountant who developed two software products with a computer engineer, registered them with the Ministry of Culture and Tourism and sold them to a holding company, asked about the income tax and VAT treatment of income from the software sales and from implementation, training and support services for which he charges separately.

The Administration's view:

  • Income from selling software that is based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge and registered under Law No. 5846 is exempt under Article 18 of the Income Tax Law; if total earnings exceed the fourth bracket amount of the Article 103 tariff, all earnings are declared.
  • Income from implementation, training and support services is not within the exemption and is taxed as self-employment income.
  • Software sales and after-sale services are subject to VAT at the general rate; if the VAT liability consists only of Article 18 transactions all made to those listed in Article 94, the VAT is declared by the buyer as responsible party, otherwise by the person himself as taxpayer.

The ruling is relevant to self-employed persons who develop and sell software and provide related services.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Income tax and VAT treatment of software sales and software implementation and training services
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that there is uncertainty about the taxation of the income you will earn where software products registered in your name by the Ministry of Culture are sold to institutions or individuals and implementation, training and support services are also provided for these software products; the request states that you work as a self-employed certified public accountant, that together with a computer engineer you developed two software products named "m…" and "d…", that the software named "m…" was registered in your name and the software named "d…" in the separate names of you and the computer engineer, that you first sold these computer software products to a holding company for TRY 134,000.00, and that you also charge separately for implementation, training and support services for these products. Our Directorate's opinion is explained below.

IN TERMS OF THE INCOME TAX LAW:

Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

- in Article 18 titled "In self-employment income":

"Revenue obtained by authors, translators, sculptors, calligraphers, painters, composers, computer programmers and inventors and their legal heirs from publishing their works such as poems, stories, novels, articles, scientific research and studies, computer software, reportage, caricature, photographs, films, video tapes, radio and television scripts and plays in newspapers, magazines, computer and internet media, radio, television and video, or from selling their works in the form of books, CDs, diskettes, paintings, sculptures and sheet music and their patents, or from assigning, transferring or leasing their existing rights over them, is exempt from Income Tax.
Prices and fees received in return for exploiting works by publication, representation, performance and exhibition are included in the exemption.
Obtaining the above earnings occasionally does not prevent the application of the exemption.
The self-employment income exemption does not extend to tax to be paid by withholding under Article 94 of this Law.
Those whose total earnings within the scope of this article exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 cannot benefit from this exemption. Those in this situation are not obliged to withhold under the first paragraph of Article 94.",

- in Article 65 titled "Definition of self-employment income":

"Income arising from all kinds of self-employment activities is self-employment income.
Self-employment activity is the performance of work based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital, and not of a commercial nature, in one's own name and account under personal responsibility without being subject to an employer.
...",

- in Article 66 titled "Self-employed persons": "Those who perform self-employment activity as a habitual profession are self-employed persons. ...",

- in Article 94 titled "Tax withholding":

"Public administrations and establishments, state economic establishments, other institutions, commercial companies, joint ventures, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed persons obliged to declare their actual income, and farmers determining their agricultural income on the balance sheet or agricultural business account basis, are obliged to withhold, against the income taxes of the beneficiaries, when they make the payments listed in the following subparagraphs (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account.
...
2. From payments made to those performing self-employment work for such work (excluding payments made to notaries for their self-employment activities);
a) from payments for self-employment work within the scope of Article 18, (17% under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14592)
b) from others, (20% under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14592)
...
tax is withheld."

Whether an activity is a self-employment activity depends on whether it bears the elements of being based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital, being carried out in one's own name and account under personal responsibility without being attached to an employer, and being continuous.

On the other hand, subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 1/B titled "Definitions" of Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works states that a computer program means a set of computer instructions arranged so as to enable a computer system to perform a particular operation or task, and the preparatory work enabling the creation and development of this set of instructions.

Therefore, a computer programmer is a person involved in software development processes and responsible for the design and development of computer software, and the expressions "computer programmer" and "computer software" in Article 18 of the Income Tax Law relate to producing software; not every job done using a computer falls within this scope. In other words, what the article covers is not processing using produced programs, but program production/creation activities that have original features, such as producing/creating operating or application programs, and that are protected nationally or internationally by licensing/copyright.

It is understood that, according to the Registration Certificate dated … and numbered … of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism annexed to your ruling application, the computer program named "D…", and according to the Registration Certificate dated … and numbered …, the computer program named "M…", were registered as works under Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works.

According to these provisions and explanations, provided the software you developed under the names "m…" and "d…" is based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise and is registered by the Ministry of Culture and Tourism under Law No. 5846, the earnings from the sale of that software must be exempted under Article 18 of the Income Tax Law.

In this context, if the total earnings from the sale of that software exceed the amount in the fourth income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 of the Income Tax Law (TRY 880,000 for 2022, TRY 1,900,000 for 2023, TRY 3,000,000 for 2024), all of your earnings must be declared on the annual income tax return.

On the other hand, earnings from implementation, training and support services provided for computer programs are not within the exemption and will be taxed as self-employment income.

IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:

Article 1 of Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT, and that the continuity, scope and nature of commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are determined according to the provisions of the Income Tax Law and, where the Income Tax Law is unclear, according to the Turkish Commercial Code and other relevant legislation.

Section (I/C-2.1.2.2) titled "Deliveries and Services Made Within Self-Employment Activity" of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:

"Under Article (1/1) of Law No. 3065, deliveries and services made within self-employment activity are subject to tax. Those performing these activities habitually and continuously will be VAT taxpayers, while VAT registration will not be established for those performing occasional self-employment activity.
Those performing self-employment activities habitually and continuously must in principle establish VAT registration. However, VAT to be calculated by those making deliveries and services within Article 18 of Income Tax Law No. 193 exclusively to persons, institutions and organisations specified in Article 94 of the same Law must be declared by these persons or organisations as responsible parties.
For self-employed persons to benefit from this application, their VAT liability must consist only of transactions within Article 18 of the Income Tax Law and all of their transactions must be made to persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the same Law.
In addition, for transactions to be made under the responsibility application, persons making transactions within Article 18 of the Income Tax Law must notify the tax responsible party (those listed in Article 94 of the Income Tax Law) in advance that transactions will be made in this way.
Self-employed persons (those listed in Article 18 of the Income Tax Law) whose tax declaration and payment obligations for their transactions are fulfilled by responsible parties do not separately file VAT returns or keep books. Documentation of the transaction is carried out according to the general provisions of the Tax Procedure Law.
Under this application, persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the Income Tax Law calculate VAT on the transaction price including the income tax (IT) withholding amount for payments they make to persons within Article 18 of the same Law, and declare and pay it as responsible parties. The calculated VAT amount is not included in the IT withholding base.
Those making deliveries or services within Article 18 of the Income Tax Law to persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the same Law and also to those not listed in this article cannot benefit from the above application.
VAT calculated on transactions made to persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the Income Tax Law and others by those not preferring the responsibility application and by taxpayers who essentially cannot fall within this scope is declared and paid by themselves as taxpayers, subject to section (I/C-2.1.3) of the Communiqué. These taxpayers keep books, issue documents and file VAT returns under the general provisions. In this case, persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the Income Tax Law have no tax responsibility for these transactions, subject to section (I/C-2.1.3) of the Communiqué."

Accordingly, the sale of software programs developed by you and post-sale implementation, training and support services are subject to VAT under Article 1/1 of Law No. 3065, and since these services are not included in the lists annexed to Council of Ministers Decree No. 2007/13033, VAT must be calculated at the general rate.

On the other hand, if your VAT liability consists only of transactions within Article 18 of the Income Tax Law and all transactions are made to persons, institutions and organisations listed in Article 94 of the same Law, the VAT calculated on these services must be declared by these persons or organisations as responsible parties. If these services are not within this scope, it is natural that the VAT calculated on these services will be declared and paid by you as taxpayer.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.