TREN
Contact us

A Liquidation Share Paid to a Shareholder by a Company in Liquidation Is a Dividend; Half Is Declared as Taxable Income

Personal Income Tax · Investment incomeA Liquidation Share Paid to a Shareholder by a Company in Liquidation Is a Dividend; Half Is Declared as Taxable IncomePrivate ruling · 9 October 2024
Rast note

An individual holding 10% of a joint stock company in liquidation, while his objection to the liquidation balance sheet and lawsuit were pending, asked whether a payment the company made to him as a "liquidation share" is a dividend and how it is to be declared.

The Administration's view:

  • Distribution to shareholders on liquidation of equity items other than paid-in capital (including net liquidation profit) is a dividend distribution and is subject to withholding according to the recipient's legal status.
  • The amount paid is a dividend earned in the relevant period; half of the gross amount is taxable income and, since it exceeds the second bracket amount of the Article 103 tariff (TRY 150,000 for 2023), it is declared on the annual return.
  • All of the 10% tax withheld by the company can be credited against the tax calculated on the annual return.

The ruling is relevant to individual shareholders receiving payments from companies in liquidation.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Taxation of a liquidation share paid by a company in liquidation
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Reference: a) Your ruling request form dated 09.02.2024. b) Your ruling request form dated 13.02.2024

In your ruling request forms referred to above, stating that you have objections to the liquidation opening balance sheet dated 1/7/2022 of … Anonim Şirketi in Liquidation, in which you have held a 10% share since 15/04/2001, that the lawsuit you filed on this matter has not yet concluded, and that in this process the said Company made a payment of TRY 10,183,000.91 in your name under the name "Liquidation Share" on 22/11/2023, an opinion is requested on whether the amount paid to you will be treated as a dividend and, if so, how it will be declared; our Directorate's opinion on the matter is given below.

Article 75 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

"Dividends, interest, rent and similar revenues obtained by the owner, outside his commercial, agricultural or professional activity, due to capital consisting of cash capital or values represented by money are income from movable capital.
Regardless of their source, the following revenues are deemed income from movable capital:
1- Dividends of all kinds of shares (including dividends given to founder shares and other usufruct shares, all kinds of payments made to shareholders as interest for the preparation period or under other names, dividends paid on participation certificates of investment funds established under the Capital Markets Law, and interest, dividends or similar income paid on mortgage-backed securities issued representing housing finance funds and asset-backed securities issued representing asset finance funds);"

and in Income Tax Law application, the taxable event for income from movable capital is the occurrence of legal and economic disposition. In the occurrence of the taxable event, the legal disposition stage, meaning the income becoming claimable by its owner, is followed by the economic disposition stage, meaning the income becoming payable to its owner upon request.

In addition, that Law provides:

- in subparagraph (3) of the first paragraph of Article 22: "Half of the dividends written in subparagraphs (1), (2) and (3) of the second paragraph of Article 75 obtained from fully liable institutions is exempt from income tax. Withholding is made on the exempted amount under Article 94, and all of the tax withheld is credited against the tax calculated on the annual return where the dividend is declared on the annual return.",

- in the first paragraph of Article 86 titled "Cases Where No Aggregation Is Made":

"No annual return is filed for the following income, and where a return is filed for other income, this income is not included in the return.
1. Under full liability;
a) Agricultural income not taxed on the actual basis, income from movable capital written in subparagraphs (15) and (16) of Article 75 of this Law, and the portion of earnings and revenues within the exemption limits,
...
c) Provided the total taxable income [excluding those in subparagraphs (a) and (b)] does not exceed the amount in the second income bracket of the tariff in Article 103, wages obtained from more than one employer, income from movable capital and income from immovable capital that have been subject to withholding in Turkey,"

Sub-subparagraph (b) of subparagraph (6) of the first paragraph of Article 94 of that Law states that withholding will be made by those listed in the first paragraph from the dividends written in subparagraphs (1), (2) and (3) of the second paragraph of Article 75 distributed by fully liable institutions to fully liable natural persons, those not liable to income and corporate tax and those exempt from these taxes, limited liability natural persons, limited liability institutions (excluding those obtaining dividends through a workplace or permanent representative in Turkey) and limited liability persons exempt from income and corporate tax (10% effective from 22/12/2021 under Presidential Decision No. 4936).

On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 17 titled "Liquidation" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that, in the taxation of institutions that have entered liquidation for whatever reason, the liquidation period applies instead of the accounting period, that liquidation begins on the date the general assembly resolution on the institution entering liquidation is registered and ends on the date the liquidation decision is registered, and that the period from the start date to the end of the same calendar year, each calendar year after this period, and for the period in which liquidation ends, the period from the beginning of the relevant calendar year to the end date of liquidation, are each deemed an independent liquidation period.

The fourth paragraph of that article provides that the tax base of institutions in liquidation is the liquidation profit, that liquidation profit is the positive difference between the wealth value at the end of the liquidation period and the wealth value at the beginning of the liquidation period, that in calculating liquidation profit all kinds of payments made to shareholders or owners during liquidation as advances or otherwise are added to the wealth value at the end of liquidation, and payments made by shareholders or owners in addition to existing capital and earnings and revenues obtained during liquidation and exempted from tax are added to the wealth value at the beginning of the liquidation period; and the fifth paragraph provides that the wealth value at the beginning and end of the liquidation period is the institution's equity shown in its balance sheet at the beginning and end of the liquidation period.

The purpose of liquidation, one of the reasons for termination of companies established under the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC), is to convert the company's assets into money, pay its debts and, if any money remains, distribute it to the company's shareholders. As a result of liquidation, the money to be distributed to shareholders after returning the capital shares they contributed to the company is the "liquidation share". Although the liquidation share is not defined in the TCC, under Articles 543 and 643 of the TCC, the assets remaining after the debts of the company in liquidation are paid and share prices are returned must be distributed among shareholders in proportion to the capital they paid and their privileges, unless otherwise agreed in the articles of association.

Accordingly, where, as a result of liquidation, equity accounts other than capital paid by shareholders (including net liquidation profit) are distributed to shareholders, the amount distributed must be treated as a dividend distribution and subjected to withholding on dividend distribution according to the legal status of the recipient.

From examination of our Presidency's Management Information System records, it is understood that, regarding the liquidation share payment made to you in the 2023/11 period by … A.Ş. in Liquidation with tax identification number ……, of which you are a shareholder, income tax of TRY 1,114,777.88, calculated by 10% withholding on a gross amount of TRY 11,147,777.88, was declared to … Tax Office to which the Company is attached, under the heading "Dividends Listed in Subparagraphs (1), (2) and (3) of Article 75 Distributed by Fully Liable Institutions to Fully Liable Natural Persons, Those Not Liable to Income and Corporate Tax, and Those Exempt From Income Tax (ITL-94/6-b-i)".

Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, the amount paid in your name by the Company of which you are a shareholder under the name of liquidation share must be treated as a dividend earned in the relevant period; considering half of the gross amount of that dividend as taxable income, since it exceeds the amount in the second income bracket of the tariff in Article 103 of the Income Tax Law (TRY 150,000 for 2023), it must be declared on the annual income tax return, and it is possible to credit all of the tax withheld under Article 94 of that Law against the tax calculated on the annual return.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.