A company providing engineering and project services stated that, as a subcontractor, it will provide project and engineering services from Ankara to an Istanbul-based main contractor that undertook a foreign electricity facility tender, invoicing the main contractor, and asked whether the CTL 10/1-ğ deduction and the export of services VAT exemption apply.
The Administration's view:
- Since the service is provided to a Turkish-resident main contractor, the invoice is issued in its name and the service is benefited from in Turkey, the CTL 10/1-ğ deduction does not apply.
- For the same reasons, the service cannot be treated as export of services under Article 11/1-a of the VAT Law and is subject to VAT.
The ruling is relevant to firms providing engineering and design services as subcontractors to Turkish main contractors on foreign projects.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of income from design services provided domestically
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Company's field of activity is engineering, consultancy and project services, that within the work tendered by … Electricity Administration, the preparation of primary electrical, construction and steel construction projects and provision of engineering services for the construction, electrical facility and substations being built in … are carried out, that the undertaking of the facility to be built was assumed by the main contractor firm (… A.Ş.) and the export-related works are carried out by the main contractor, that your firm carries out the project and engineering works of that job as subcontractor of the main contractor to provide design services from its workplace in Ankara, and that within this work an invoice will be issued to the main contractor firm headquartered in Istanbul for project and engineering services for the said foreign work, an opinion is requested on whether the income to be obtained from that service provided to the exporting firm can be deducted from the corporate tax base and whether the invoice to be issued is exempt from VAT as export of services.
I- IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
Subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
"80% of the income obtained exclusively from these activities by service businesses operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance with the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre are abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Turkey, provided all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is obtained must be filed.
To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the customer abroad.
..."
The section titled "10.5. Services provided from Turkey to persons and institutions resident abroad" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 contains detailed explanations on the matter, and the section titled "10.5.2. Conditions for benefiting from the deduction" states:
"10.5.2.1. Main field of activity written in the articles of association of companies that can benefit from the deduction
The main fields of activity written in the articles of association of the relevant companies must include providing architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training determined by the Ministry of Finance with the opinion of the relevant ministries, education and health services. Only one of these services may be provided within the company, or more than one provided they are in the articles of association.
...
10.5.2.2. The service being performed from Turkey exclusively for a person and/or institution resident abroad
Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training services determined by the Ministry of Finance with the opinion of the relevant ministries must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre are abroad; education or health services must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey.
The above services must actually be provided; services such as assistance, consultancy and brokerage offered in these fields cannot be treated within this scope.
10.5.2.3. The invoice being issued in the name of the person and/or institution resident abroad
The invoice to be issued for the service performed must be issued in the name of the person and/or institution resident abroad whose characteristics are explained above.
...
10.5.2.4. Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing and data analysis services provided from Turkey being benefited from abroad
The service provided must be benefited from abroad. In other words, the service provided for the person and/or institution resident abroad must have no connection with the activities of these persons and/or institutions in Turkey."
Accordingly, since the project and engineering service performed by your Company is provided to the main contractor firm … A.Ş. headquartered in Istanbul, the invoice for the service is issued in the name of the main contractor firm, and the service is benefited from in Turkey, it is not possible for you to benefit from subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of the Corporate Tax Law.
II- IN TERMS OF VALUE ADDED TAX
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to value added tax,
- in Article 4/1, that a service is a transaction other than deliveries, transactions deemed deliveries and import of goods, and that these transactions may take forms such as making, processing, creating, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, preserving, preparing, evaluating or leasing something, or undertaking not to do something,
- in Article 6/b, that a transaction being made in Turkey means the service being performed in Turkey and benefited from in Turkey,
- in Article 11/1-a, that services performed for customers abroad are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that for a service to be considered a service performed for customers abroad, the service must be performed for a customer abroad and benefited from abroad.
Subsection "2.1. Scope of the Exemption" of the section titled "II-A/2. Export of Services" of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:
"For a service to be exempt from VAT under Article (11/1-a) of Law No. 3065, according to Article (12/2) of the same Law:
- the service must be performed for a customer abroad,
- the service must be benefited from abroad.
That the service was performed for a customer abroad is documented by an invoice or similar document issued in the name of the customer abroad.
Benefiting from the service abroad means that the service performed in Turkey for the customer abroad relates to the customer's business, transactions and activities abroad and has no connection with its activities in Turkey.
Since goods and services that foreign firms will send to Turkey are consumed in Turkey, consultancy, brokerage, supervision, customer finding, market research and similar services provided in Turkey to these firms for those goods and services are not treated within the export of services exemption and are subject to VAT. In this case, in determining the benefit criterion, the service performed must be directly related to the imported goods."
Accordingly, since your firm headquartered in Ankara provides design services for the construction, electrical facility and substations to be built in … to the main contractor firm headquartered in Istanbul, the invoice for the service is issued in the name of the main contractor firm, and the service is benefited from in Turkey, it is not possible to treat this service as export of services under Article 11/1-a of the VAT Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.