TREN
Contact us

Income From a Foreign Pipeline Project Company With Legal Personality Is Participation Income, Not Branch Income

Corporate Income Tax · Foreign incomeIncome From a Foreign Pipeline Project Company With Legal Personality Is Participation Income, Not Branch IncomePrivate ruling · 8 October 2024
Rast note

An institution fully liable in Turkey and holding a share in a foreign natural gas pipeline project company with legal personality asked whether its share of the project's income, taxed in the transit countries, can benefit from the CTL 5/1-g foreign branch income exemption, and if not, whether the tax paid abroad can be credited under CTL 33.

The Administration's view:

  • Since the project company has legal personality, the project income belongs to that company; the shareholder's share is participation income.
  • This income can benefit from the foreign participation income exemption if the conditions in CTL 5/1-b are met together; however, foreign taxes on exempt income cannot be credited in Turkey.
  • As the income is not earned through a workplace or permanent representative abroad, the CTL 5/1-g exemption does not apply.

The ruling is relevant to Turkish institutions holding shares in foreign project companies with legal personality.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether income from a natural gas pipeline project partnership is foreign branch income and whether taxes paid abroad can be credited in Turkey
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that full tax liability in Turkey was established from 10.04.2009 for … company established in … Islands in …, that the company is a …% shareholder of …., the project company with legal personality established to carry out the … Natural Gas Pipeline (…) Project, which is the pipeline section of the … Project;

- that the income of … is determined according to the amount of natural gas passing through the pipeline under international project agreements, and that the income is taxed at 27% in Azerbaijan and 25% in Georgia, which are among the transit countries,

- that the corporate tax returns for income from the project were filed by …. in the relevant countries in the name of the … branches and the taxes paid, and that documents showing that the taxes paid are in the name of the project partners were issued in the relevant taxing countries,

- that although …., which carries out the activities of the project agreements in Azerbaijan and Georgia, appears to have separate legal personality, it is in the nature of a joint venture operating only on behalf of its partners,

- that the earnings of … in Georgia were transferred to Turkey before the date the corporate tax return must be filed, and that its corporate tax and similar obligations paid in that country exceed 15%,

- that the earnings of … obtained in Georgia through …. are not participation income but foreign activity income obtained through a workplace abroad,

our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether that income falls within the exemption in subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, and, if not, whether the tax declared and paid abroad by … can be credited against corporate tax in Turkey under Article 33 of that Law.

Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 lists the institutions subject to corporate tax, and Article 3 of the same Law provides that those of these institutions whose legal or business centre is in Turkey are taxed as full taxpayers on all of their earnings obtained both inside and outside Turkey.

Subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of this Law regulates the foreign participation income exemption with the conditions:

"1) The company holding the participation share owns at least 10% of the paid-in capital of the foreign participation,
2) The participation share is held continuously for at least one year as of the date the income is obtained (for participation shares obtained by exercising pre-emptive rights or due to capital increases from the internal resources of the foreign participation, the acquisition date of the old participation shares held is taken as the basis),
3) The foreign participation income bears a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least 15% under the tax laws of the country where the participated institution operates, including taxes paid on the earnings that are the source of the dividend distribution,
4) The participation income is transferred to Turkey by the date the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is obtained must be filed."

Subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of the same article exempts from corporate tax corporate earnings obtained by institutions through their workplaces or permanent representatives abroad that meet the following conditions:

1) These earnings bear a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least 15% under the tax laws of the country where they arise,

2) The earnings have been transferred to Turkey by the date the annual corporate tax return for the accounting period in which they are obtained must be filed,

3) For institutions whose main activity is provision of financing including financial leasing, provision of insurance services or securities investment, these earnings bear a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least the corporate tax rate applied in Turkey under the tax laws of the country where they arise.

The first paragraph of Article 33 of that Law provides that corporate tax and similar taxes paid locally on earnings obtained in foreign countries and transferred to the general result accounts in Turkey can be deducted from the corporate tax assessed in Turkey on these earnings.

On the other hand, the section titled "5.2. Foreign participation income exemption" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states that under subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law, participation income obtained by institutions from abroad is exempted from corporate tax under certain conditions, and that to benefit from this exemption the conditions in that subparagraph must be met together.

In addition, the section titled "5.8. Foreign branch income" of that Communiqué states:

"By subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law, corporate earnings obtained by institutions through their workplaces or permanent representatives abroad are exempted from corporate tax under certain conditions.
Corporate earnings obtained through workplaces or permanent representatives abroad must:
bear a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least 15% under the tax laws of the country where they arise,
have been transferred to Turkey by the date the annual corporate tax return for the accounting period in which they are obtained must be filed,
where the main activity of the participated company is provision of financing including financial leasing, provision of insurance services or securities investment, bear a total tax burden similar to income and corporate tax of at least the corporate tax rate applied in Turkey (20%) under the tax laws of the country where they arise.
Under this subparagraph, the total tax burden will be determined according to the explanations in section (5.2.1.5) of the Communiqué."

On the other hand, the section titled "33.3. Limit of foreign taxes that can be credited" of the same Communiqué provides that where earnings obtained abroad are exempted from corporate tax, it is not possible to credit taxes paid abroad on these earnings against corporate tax calculated domestically.

According to these provisions and explanations, since …. company, established as a partnership for the … Natural Gas Pipeline (…) project, has legal personality, the project income also belongs to this company. For this reason, the earnings obtained by … must be accepted as a dividend, that is participation income, transferred to the company in proportion to its share in …..

In this respect, it is possible to benefit from the exemption for earnings obtained as participation income and transferred to the general result accounts in Turkey, provided the conditions in subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law are met simultaneously. However, it is not possible to credit taxes paid abroad relating to that exempt income against corporate tax calculated domestically.

In addition, since the income stated in the ruling request form is not income obtained through a workplace or permanent representative abroad, it is not possible to benefit from the exemption in subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.