A company providing engineering services including thermodynamic, thermal and fluid mechanics analysis asked whether it can deduct 80% of income from engineering services provided to a firm in Germany and invoiced without VAT under CTL 10/1-ğ. The cooperation agreement was signed with the foreign firm's Turkish branch, while invoices were issued to the head office abroad.
The Administration's view:
- 80% of income from engineering services actually provided from Turkey to non-residents and benefited from exclusively abroad can be deducted from the base, provided the other conditions are met.
- If the service is not benefited from abroad and relates to the foreign firm's activities in Turkey, the income cannot be treated under CTL 10/1-ğ.
The ruling is relevant to companies providing engineering and technical services to foreign customers.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of income from engineering services provided to foreign-resident institutions
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that, as included in your articles of association published in the Trade Registry Gazette, your Company provides all kinds of engineering and technological services including thermodynamic, thermal and fluid mechanics analysis in Turkey and abroad, that you provide engineering services to … GmbH Co. KG located in …, Germany, and that you issue VAT-exempt invoices for services to projects abroad, an opinion is requested on whether 80% of the income from this service provided abroad can be deducted in determining your corporate tax base under subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of the Corporate Tax Law.
The first paragraph of Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that those of the institutions listed in Article 1 whose legal or business centre is in Turkey are taxed on all of their earnings obtained both inside and outside Turkey, and Article 6 of the same Law provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers within an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
The first paragraph of Article 10 titled "Other deductions" of the same Law lists deductions that can be made from corporate income in determining the corporate tax base, provided they are shown separately on the corporate tax return, and subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph provides:
"80% of the income obtained exclusively from these activities by service businesses operating in architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training fields determined by the Ministry of Finance with the opinion of the relevant ministries, provided in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre are abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad, and by businesses operating in education and health subject to the permission and supervision of the relevant ministry and serving persons not resident in Turkey (expression amended by Article 59 of Law No. 7491; effective 28/12/2023 to apply to revenues and income obtained from 1/1/2023), provided all of it is transferred to Turkey by the date the corporate tax return for the accounting period in which it is obtained must be filed.
To benefit from this deduction, the invoice or similar document must be issued in the name of the customer abroad.
..."
Regarding the matter, the section titled "10.5. Services provided from Turkey to persons and institutions resident abroad" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 gives explanations, stating:
- in section "10.5.2.1. Main field of activity written in the articles of association of companies that can benefit from the deduction": "The main fields of activity written in the articles of association of the relevant companies must include providing architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis, vocational training, education and health services. Only one of these services may be provided within the company, or more than one provided they are in the articles of association. ...",
- in section "10.5.2.2. The service being performed from Turkey exclusively for a person and/or institution resident abroad":
"Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing, data analysis and vocational training services determined by the Ministry of Finance with the opinion of the relevant ministries must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre are abroad; education or health services must be provided to persons not resident in Turkey.
The above services must actually be provided; services such as assistance, consultancy and brokerage offered in these fields cannot be treated within this scope.",
- in section "10.5.2.3. The invoice being issued in the name of the person and/or institution resident abroad": "The invoice to be issued for the service performed must be issued in the name of the person and/or institution resident abroad. ...",
- in section "10.5.2.4. Architecture, engineering, design, software, medical reporting, bookkeeping, call centre, product testing, certification, data storage, data processing and data analysis services provided from Turkey being benefited from abroad": "The service provided must be benefited from abroad; the service provided for the person and/or institution resident abroad must have no connection with the activities of these persons and/or institutions in Turkey."
On the other hand, examination of our system records shows that your field of activity since 23/05/2023 is "721901-Other Research and Experimental Development Activities on Natural Sciences and Engineering (Including Agricultural Research)".
On the other hand, it is seen that the "Cooperation Agreement" dated 14/06/2023 annexed to the ruling request form states in section "1. Subject of the Agreement" that "… Türkiye operates in the Turkish energy market and follows energy projects"; in section "2. Scope of Services" that "... All interim and final results must be completed in a way that fully meets … Türkiye principles. … will have the right to include the Cooperation Partner's CV in proposals prepared for projects outside Turkey; that is, this CV will be shared with … GmbH & Co KG, …. For projects in Turkey, an assessment will be made according to the situation."; in section "5. Warranty" that "... The warranty period will begin upon commencement of the services provided under the agreement by … Türkiye and will end 12 months after acceptance of the services."; in section "8. Payment Terms" that the invoice will be issued in the name of … Türkiye; and in section "9. Work Results, Inventions" that "All results and documents arising during the performance of this agreement will be owned by … Türkiye and … Türkiye will have exclusive rights over them. Work results will be delivered to … Türkiye electronically (currently typically MS Office 365 and Adobe Acrobat) in … Türkiye's standard software formats valid at the time and, depending on the task, in printed copy. … Türkiye will be informed of inventions made by the Cooperation Partner and/or its personnel during the performance of services under the agreement. … Türkiye will benefit from them if it wishes and the Cooperation Partner will transfer all rights to … Türkiye. The costs of benefiting from these inventions will be borne by … Türkiye."; that section "1. Scope of Services" of the "Additional Agreement" dated 09/07/2024 states: "This additional agreement is to clarify the scope specified in the main agreement. The scope items below are valid from 15.06.2023. All kinds of engineering, analysis and calculation under the main headings below will be provided: Thermodynamics (thermal-mass energy balance, etc.), Thermal and heat transfer (heat transfer surface, heat exchangers, etc.), Combustion (boiler, waste heat boiler, etc.), Fluid mechanics analysis (turbomachinery fans, pumps, turbines, etc.), All kinds of engineering technology analysis, Preparation of flow diagrams, Preparation of layout and assembly plans, Preparation of specifications and data sheets, Concept and configuration studies, as well as site works and supervision services."; and that the agreement was signed by the foreign firm's branch in Turkey while the invoices were issued in the name of the foreign-headquartered firm.
According to the above provisions and explanations, provided the engineering service provided by your Company in Turkey to persons not resident in Turkey and those whose workplace, legal and business centre are abroad and benefited from exclusively abroad is actually provided and the other conditions listed above are also met, it is possible to deduct 80% of the income you obtained from that service in determining your corporate tax base.
However, it is natural that if the engineering service provided to foreign-resident persons or institutions is not benefited from abroad and relates to the activities of these persons and/or institutions in Turkey, the income to be obtained from this service cannot be treated under subparagraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 10 of the Corporate Tax Law.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.