A notary asked whether stamp duty and fees are collected on a bank's notice, in response to guarantors' requests to withdraw, accepting that the guarantees have ended and that the guarantors have no liability.
The Administration's view:
- This document, by its nature a notice, is not listed in Table (1) of the Stamp Duty Law and is therefore not subject to stamp duty.
- A fixed notary fee is collected under Tariff (2) II/2 of the Fees Law for each copy of the notice to be served on the addressees.
The ruling is relevant to banks issuing notices through notaries and to notaries.
Full text
Subject: Whether stamp duty and fees are collected on a notice accepting that guarantors have no liability in response to their requests to withdraw from guarantee
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of the ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether stamp duty and fees must be collected on a notice brought to your Notary Office for issue by …………. Commercial Centre Branch, accepting that the guarantors have no liability in response to the addressees' requests to withdraw from guarantee.
That notice states:
"As security for loans extended and to be extended by our Branch to our credit customer …….. ANONİM ŞİRKETİ, guarantees were signed by the guarantor ……. San ve Tic. Ltd. Şti. dated ……….. and ………… for TRY …………. and TRY ……….. annexed to General Loan Agreement no. ……….; by the guarantor …… dated ….…. for ……… annexed to General Loan Agreement no. ………..; and by the guarantor …… dated ……. for ……… annexed to General Loan Agreement no. …………. As of the date of this reply notice, we accept and declare that, within the above guarantees, the addressee guarantors have no guarantee debt to our Bank, that the guarantees have ended, and that after the date of this letter the addressee guarantors have no liability within those guarantees for loans to be extended to the above credit customer."
and the notary was requested to serve this notice on addressees with e-notification addresses, to serve it by PTT on addressees without e-notification addresses, to give one copy and to keep one copy in its office.
IN TERMS OF THE STAMP DUTY LAW
Article 1 of Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides that the documents listed in Table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; Article 4 provides that the nature of a document is examined to determine the tax to which it is subject and its value in the table is found accordingly, that in determining the nature of documents, for those whose form is specified in laws their names in the laws, and for others the provision and meaning contained in the text on them, are considered, and that if reference is made to another document on the document whose nature is to be determined, tax is collected according to the nature it acquires based on the provisions of the referenced document; Article 10 provides that stamp duty is collected as proportional or fixed, that in proportional tax the certain amount of money written in these documents according to their type and nature is the basis, and that the term certain amount of money means the money contained in the documents or resulting from the figures written in them.
In this framework, considering that the subject of stamp duty is formed by the documents in Table (1) annexed to the Law, that the type, parties and content of the document are important in determining the taxable event and the taxpayer of the document, and that each document subject to stamp duty must be assessed according to its nature and content, the document dated ………… addressed to …… Notary annexed to your ruling request form and understood to be a notice by nature must not be subjected to stamp duty since it is not among the documents in Table (1) annexed to Stamp Duty Law No. 488.
IN TERMS OF THE FEES LAW
The first paragraph of Article 38 of Fees Law No. 492 provides that notary transactions listed in Tariff (2) attached to this law are subject to notary fees; Article 41 provides that notary fees are collected on a proportional basis according to value or weight, and on a fixed basis according to the type and nature of the transaction, for transactions listed in Tariff (2).
Paragraph 2 of the section titled "II - Fixed fees" of Tariff (2) attached to the Law states that a fixed fee of TRY 240.50 (for 2024) is collected for each copy to be served on the addressee of all kinds of notifications (including notifications to be made by notaries to the addressee under Law No. 6830), notices, warnings and protests.
In this respect, a fixed fee must be collected under paragraph II/2 of Tariff (2) attached to Law No. 492 for each copy of the notice annexed to the ruling request form to be served on the addressees.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.