TREN
Contact us

Sale of an Academic Invention by a Technology Transfer Office: No 5/B or VAT Exemption for the Company; Payments to Faculty Subject to Self-Employment Withholding

Corporate Income Tax · Technoparks and R&DSale of an Academic Invention by a Technology Transfer Office: No 5/B or VAT Exemption for the Company; Payments to Faculty Subject to Self-Employment WithholdingPrivate ruling · 14 August 2024
Rast note

A company acting as a university's technology transfer office will sell an invention developed by academics at the university under the university's commercialisation directive and, after deducting expenses, allocate certain percentages to the inventor, the university and itself. It asked whether VAT applies to the sale, whether withholding applies when distributing income, and whether its income is subject to the corporate tax exemption.

The Administration's view:

  • The CTL 5/B exemption is granted to the owner of the patent or utility model certificate or holder of an exclusive licence over it. Income obtained by the company from commercialising and selling the invention cannot benefit from this exemption.
  • There is no exemption for payments to faculty members for their inventions; payments for inventions made through work independent of the university are self-employment payments and subject to withholding under ITL 94/2.
  • Since the sale is not within CTL 5/B, the VATL 17/4-z exemption does not apply; the sale is subject to VAT under the general provisions.

The ruling is relevant to university technology transfer offices, technopark companies and inventor academics.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Tax treatment of intellectual and industrial property and inventions in a technology development zone
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is stated:

- that it has been decided that the invention titled "…", developed under the university's roof by academics of …, is to be commercialised through …, which is within your Company, in accordance with the directive on intellectual and industrial property rights and commercialisation of inventions issued by that University,

- that the sales of these intellectual, industrial properties and inventions will be made by your Company and, after deducting the expenses incurred, …% will be recorded as income to the owner of the idea or invention, …% to the University and …% to your Company,

and in this distribution our Presidency's opinion has been requested on:

- whether VAT applies to the amount to be invoiced to …, and if so at what rate,

- whether withholding is to be made when distributing income, and if so at what rate,

- whether the corporate income obtained by your Company relating to these transactions is subject to the corporate tax exemption.

Evaluation in Terms of the Corporate Tax Law

Article 5/B titled "Exemption for industrial property rights" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:

"(1) 50% of:
a) earnings and income obtained from leasing,
b) earnings obtained from transfer or sale,
c) earnings obtained where they are mass-produced and marketed in Turkey,
ç) the portion attributable to the patented or utility-model-certified invention of earnings obtained from the sale of products produced as a result of use in a production process carried out in Turkey,
of inventions resulting from research, development and innovation activities and software activities carried out in Turkey is exempt from corporate tax. This exemption also applies to income obtained as a result of infringement of rights relating to the invention and to insurance or other compensation received due to the invention.
(2) For the exemption to apply:
a) the invention subject to the exemption must be among inventions protected by the grant of a patent or utility model certificate under Decree Law No. 551 dated 24/6/1995 on the Protection of Patent Rights or Industrial Property Law No. 6769 dated 22/12/2016, and a patent must be obtained under the examined system or a utility model certificate as a result of a search report,
b) persons who may benefit from the exemption must have the qualifications specified in Article 2 of Decree Law No. 551 or Article 3 of Law No. 6769 and, provided that they have the authority to develop the patented or utility-model-certified invention, must be the owner of the patent or utility model certificate or hold an exclusive special licence over the patent or utility model certificate.
..."

On the other hand, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 contains detailed explanations on the matter, stating:

- in the section titled "5.14.1. Scope of earnings and income obtained from industrial property rights":

"...
In this exemption:
- Patent means a patent granted by the Turkish Patent Institute (TPE) under the examined system,
- Utility model certificate means a utility model certificate granted by TPE as a result of a favourable search report,
- Leasing means leasing the invention subject to the patent or utility model certificate for a certain period to individuals or entities in Turkey or abroad under an exclusive or non-exclusive licence agreement,
- Transfer or sale means selling the invention subject to the patent or utility model certificate for consideration to individuals or entities in Turkey or abroad,
- Marketing by mass production means producing in Turkey the original product exclusively subject to the patent or utility model certificate and offering it for sale to individuals or entities in Turkey or abroad,
- Use in the production process means using the invention subject to the patent or utility model certificate in the production process of products produced in Turkey or in the manufacture of these products.
The basic condition for this exemption is that the research, development and innovation activities and software activities relating to the inventions from which the earnings and income are obtained were carried out in Turkey.
Income obtained as a result of infringement of rights relating to the invention and insurance or other compensation received due to the invention are also within the exemption."

- in the section titled "5.14.2. Those who will benefit from the exemption":

"Corporate taxpayers and income taxpayers may benefit from this exemption.
..."

According to these provisions and explanations, it is possible to benefit from the exemption for industrial property rights if the conditions explained above are met, and persons who may benefit from the exemption must have the qualifications specified in Article 2 of Decree Law No. 551 or Article 3 of Law No. 6769 and, provided that they have the authority to develop the patented or utility-model-certified invention, must be the owner of the patent or utility model certificate or hold an exclusive special licence over it.

Accordingly, it is not possible for your Company to benefit from the exemption for industrial property rights for the earnings obtained if the invention made by academics of … is commercialised, that is sold by your Company, through …, which is within your Company, in accordance with the "Directive on Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights and Commercialisation of Inventions" issued by that University.

Evaluation in Terms of the Income Tax Law

Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

in Article 61 titled "Definition of wages": "Wages are money and in-kind payments and benefits that can be represented in money given in return for services to those working subject to an employer and attached to a specific workplace.
The fact that wages are paid under the names allowance, compensation, cash compensation (financial liability compensation), appropriation, raise, advance, dues, attendance fee, premium, bonus, expense allowance or other names, or are determined as a certain percentage of earnings provided that it is not in the nature of a partnership relationship, does not change their nature.",
in Article 62 titled "Definition of employer": "Employers are individuals and legal entities who hire employees and employ them under their orders and instructions.",
in Article 65 titled "Definition of self-employment income": "Self-employment activity is the performance of work based on personal effort, scientific or professional knowledge or expertise rather than capital, and not of a commercial nature, in one's own name and account under personal responsibility without being subject to an employer.",
in Article 94 titled "Tax withholding": "Public administrations and institutions, economic public institutions, other entities, commercial companies, business partnerships, associations, foundations, economic enterprises of associations and foundations, cooperatives, investment fund managers, merchants and self-employed persons obliged to declare their real income, and farmers determining their agricultural earnings on a balance sheet or farm account basis, are obliged to withhold tax on account of the income taxes of the beneficiaries when making the payments listed in the following subparagraphs (including those paid as advances) in cash or on account.
On wages paid to employees and payments deemed wages listed in Article 61 (excluding those benefiting from exemption), according to Articles 103 and 104,
2. On payments made to those performing self-employment work for such work (excluding payments to notaries for their self-employment activities);
..."

On the other hand, additional Article 32 titled "Technology transfer office" of Higher Education Law No. 2547 provides:

"Higher education institutions may establish a technology transfer office in the status of a capital company by decision of the higher education institution's board of directors, subject to prior permission from the Council of Higher Education, to cooperate with the public and private sectors on R&D and innovation, to protect knowledge produced and inventions made within intellectual property and to transfer them into practice.
The founding capital of the office may be covered from scientific research project resources or revolving fund revenues.
Personnel are employed at the office in worker status subject to Law No. 4857, and foreign national personnel may be employed under International Labour Force Law No. 6735 dated 28/7/2016 and related legislation. Teaching staff whose services are needed in office activities may be employed permanently or part-time with the permission of higher education institutions. Income that part-time teaching staff obtain for these services need not be deposited in the university revolving fund enterprise. No additional payment is made to them by their own higher education institutions...."

On the other hand, Article 4 titled "Organisation of the Technology Transfer Office" of the Regulation on Technology Transfer Offices of Higher Education Institutions published in Official Gazette No. 30263 dated 07.12.2017 states:

"(1) A TTO is established on higher education institution campuses or within Technology Development Zones of which the higher education institution is a partner, in order to commercialise knowledge produced and inventions made by teaching staff at higher education institutions.
...
(4) TTO employees consist of workers, foreign national personnel or teaching staff assigned permanently or part-time whose services are needed in office activities.
(5) Teaching staff may carry out at the TTO, with the permission of the university board of directors, the work they will do under the domestic and foreign temporary assignment principles provided in Article 39 of Law No. 2547.
(6) Teaching staff whose services are needed in office activities may be employed permanently or part-time with the permission of higher education institutions. Income that part-time teaching staff obtain for their services is kept outside the scope of the university revolving fund."

According to these provisions and explanations, since there is no exemption provision in the legislation for payments made to faculty members for their inventions, it is not possible to exempt these payments from income tax.

Accordingly, payments to be made to faculty members for these inventions they made as a result of work carried out independently of the University must be accepted as self-employment payments under Article 65 of Law No. 193 and subjected to income tax withholding under subparagraph (2) of the first paragraph of Article 94 of the same Law.

Evaluation in Terms of the Value Added Tax Law

Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,

- in Article 17/4-z, that leasing, transfer or sale of intangible rights relating to a patented or utility-model-certified invention resulting from research and development, innovation and software activities within Article 5/B of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 dated 13/6/2006 is exempt from VAT.

Section (II/F-4.22.) titled "Leasing, Transfer or Sale of Intangible Rights Relating to a Patented or Utility-Model-Certified Invention" of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:

"Under Article (17/4-z) of Law No. 3065, leasing, transfer or sale of intangible rights relating to a patented or utility-model-certified invention resulting from research and development, innovation and software activities within Article (5/B) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 dated 13/6/2006 is exempt from VAT. For leasing, transfer or sale of intangible rights relating to such a patented or utility-model-certified invention to be exempt from VAT, they must have been obtained as a result of research and development, innovation and software activities within Article (5/B) of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520."

Accordingly, since the commercialisation, that is the sale by your Company, of the invention made by academics of … through …, which is within your Company, in accordance with the "Directive on Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights and Commercialisation of Inventions" issued by that University is not evaluated within Article 5/B of the Corporate Tax Law, it is not possible to exempt this sale from VAT under Article 17/4-z of Law No. 3065, and it must be subject to VAT under the general provisions.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.