The Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) Trade and Development Bank, stating that it is exempt from stamp duty under its Headquarters Agreement with Turkey, asked whether an audit agreement it signed with an independent audit firm is exempt from stamp duty.
The Administration's view:
- Agreements stating a specific amount are subject to proportional stamp duty; as a rule, one signatory being exempt does not reduce the tax on documents signed by more than one person.
- Art. 12 of the Headquarters Agreement approved by Law No. 5638 exempts the Bank's transactions and purchases of goods and services within its official activities from all taxes, including stamp duty; Art. 26 of the Establishment Agreement provides for the Bank to be audited by auditors.
- Therefore the audit agreement is exempt from stamp duty as part of the Bank's official activities.
The ruling is relevant to audit and service firms signing agreements with international organisations.
Full text
Subject: Whether an agreement is exempt from stamp duty under the Headquarters Agreement between the Government of Turkey and the ECO Trade and Development Bank
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form, petitions and their annexes referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you are exempt from stamp duty under the Headquarters Agreement signed between your Bank and the Government of the Republic of Turkey on …/…/…, an opinion is requested on whether the "… Audit Agreement" signed on …/…/2023 between your bank and … Independent Audit and … Financial Advisory Inc. is exempt from stamp duty.
Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides in Article 1 that documents listed in table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty and that the term documents in this Law means documents drawn up by being written and signed or by placing a mark replacing a signature that may be submitted to prove or show any matter, and documents created in magnetic media and as electronic data using an electronic signature; in Article 3 that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents; in Article 4 that to determine the tax to which a document is subject, the nature of that document is examined and its tax is found in the table accordingly, that in determining the nature of documents, for those whose form is set out in laws, their names in the laws are considered, and for others, the provision and meaning implied by the text on them, and that if the document whose nature is to be determined refers to another document, tax is levied according to the nature it acquires by reference to the provisions of the referenced document; and in the second paragraph of Article 24 that those who sign documents signed by more than one person are jointly and severally liable for the whole of the tax and penalty, that the presence among them of those exempt from tax does not require the stamp duty to be paid short, that the whole of the tax on documents issued by stamp-duty-exempt institutions relating to persons' transactions in table (1) and bearing only the signature of these institutions is paid by the persons, but that if the tax on these documents is not paid or is paid short, the institutions are jointly and severally liable with the persons for the whole of the tax and penalty.
Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I. Documents relating to contracts" of table (1) annexed to the Law provides that agreements, undertakings and assignments containing a specific amount are subject to proportional stamp duty.
On the other hand, the "Headquarters Agreement Between the Government of the Republic of Turkey and the Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) Trade and Development Bank", approved by Law No. 5638 dated 2/5/2007, provides in Article 1 titled "Definitions":
"i) "Official Activities of the Bank" includes all activities carried out under the Agreement Establishing the Bank, and all activities appropriate for performing the purposes and functions of the Bank within Articles 1, 2 and 7 of that Agreement, including its administrative activities;
j) "Persons Connected with the Bank" means the Governors, Temporary Governors, Alternate Governors, Temporary Alternate Governors, Board Members, Directors, Temporary Directors, Alternate Directors, Temporary Alternate Directors, President, Vice Presidents, Officers and Employees of the Bank, and experts performing missions on behalf of the Bank;
and in Article 12 titled "Customs and Tax Exemption":
"1. Within the Official Activities of the Bank, the movable and immovable property of the Bank, all kinds of income from assets such as interest, capital gains, foreign exchange gains and profits, as well as its activities and transactions and purchases of goods and services, shall be exempt from all present and future, direct or indirect taxes and duties, whether local or central, including but not limited to Value Added Tax (VAT), income tax, withholding and stamp duty. With reference to the preceding provision, the Bank shall also be exempt from any obligation to withhold, collect or pay any tax. However, the Bank shall not claim exemption from taxes which are in fact no more than charges for public utility services."
On the other hand, the "Agreement Establishing the Economic Cooperation Organization Trade and Development Bank", approved by Law No. 4401 dated 7/7/1999 and put into force by Council of Ministers Decision No. 99/13227 published in Official Gazette No. 23819 dated 17/9/1999, provides in Article 1 titled "Purposes":
"The Bank shall mobilise resources for the purpose of initiating, developing and providing financial facilities that will promote intra-regional trade and accelerate the economic development of ECO member countries."
in Article 2 titled "Functions and Powers":
"To fulfil its purpose, the Bank shall have the following functions and powers:
(a) to finance development projects and intra-regional trade in ECO countries;
(b) to cooperate with national and international financial institutions and use such institutions as financial channels for its own operations;
(c) to establish and operate Special Funds for special purposes in accordance with regulations approved by the Board of Governors;
(d) to undertake all other banking activities to mobilise resources and provide banking services that may be necessary or arise later to further its purposes."
in Article 7 titled "Equity Participation":
"The total amount of equity investments made by the Bank shall not exceed 25% of the paid-in capital of the Bank."
and in Article 26 titled "Auditors - Reports":
"1. Qualified auditors registered in an internationally recognised member country shall be appointed, on the recommendation of the Board of Directors and with the approval of the Board of Governors, for a renewable term of one year on terms and conditions approved by the Board of Directors, to audit the transactions relating to the Bank and to report periodically to the Board of Directors as decided by the Board of Directors.
2. The Bank shall send to its Members and the ECO Secretariat an annual Report containing the audited accounts of the Bank and shall publish such reports. The Bank shall also send to its members a summary report showing the results of the Bank's operations on a quarterly basis.
3- The Bank may also publish other reports as desirable relating to its purposes and functions. Such reports shall be sent to members and the ECO Secretariat."
Accordingly, it is possible to exempt from stamp duty the "Audit Agreement" signed between the Economic Cooperation Organization Trade and Development Bank and … Independent Audit and Certified Public Accountancy Inc. within the Bank's official activities under the "Headquarters Agreement" and the "Establishment Agreement".
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.