TREN
Contact us

A Provincial Special Administration's Social Facility Enterprise Without Legal Personality Is an Official Office: It Withholds Stamp Duty on Payments and Applies VAT Withholding as a Designated Buyer

VAT · WithholdingA Provincial Special Administration's Social Facility Enterprise Without Legal Personality Is an Official Office: It Withholds Stamp Duty on Payments and Applies VAT Withholding as a Designated BuyerPrivate ruling · 12 August 2024
Rast note

A social facility enterprise set up as an in-budget enterprise within a provincial special administration asked whether it must withhold stamp duty on payments for goods, services, construction and leases, whether its sales are exempt from stamp duty, and whether it must apply VAT withholding on works subject to withholding and file VAT Return No. 2.

The Administration's view:

  • If the enterprise has no legal personality separate from the provincial special administration or lacks an economic character, it is an official office under Art. 8 of the Stamp Duty Law.
  • Tax on documents signed with contractors without permanent stamp duty registration is collected from the contractor and paid by the enterprise; for those signed with permanently registered taxpayers, it is declared and paid by either party. Payment documents for purchases of goods and services are subject to proportional stamp duty under paragraph IV/1-a; the duty is withheld at payment and declared on the withholding return. No stamp duty is sought on documents with official offices.
  • The enterprise, a VAT taxpayer within the designated buyers, applies VAT withholding on purchases of goods and services subject to withholding and declares and pays the withheld amount on VAT Return No. 2.

The ruling is relevant to in-budget enterprises of provincial special administrations and municipalities and their contractors.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether stamp duty and VAT withholding apply to progress payments for goods and services bought by a provincial special administration's economic enterprise
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that an opinion is requested on whether your social facility enterprise established within the Provincial Special Administration must withhold stamp duty on documents issued for payments it makes in purchases of goods and services and construction works, whether stamp duty is to be withheld from agreements and progress payments when it carries out leasing transactions, whether it is exempt from stamp duty on sales of goods and services, and whether, when purchases of goods and services and construction works are commissioned, it must apply VAT withholding on progress payments for works subject to VAT withholding and declare it on VAT Return No. 2.

In Terms of the Stamp Duty Law

Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides in Article 1 that documents listed in table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; in Article 3 that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents and that stamp duty on documents relating to transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons; in Article 8 that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, provincial special administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages, and that economic enterprises attached to these offices with separate legal personality are not deemed official offices; in Article 9 that documents listed in table (2) annexed to this Law are exempt from stamp duty; in Article 19 that the tax on receipts and similar documents subject to proportional tax used in payments of general and special budget offices, provincial special administrations and municipalities, banks, state economic enterprises and their affiliates and establishments and similar organisations is collected by the relevant offices and establishments by withholding from entitlements when making these payments or, in advance payments, when giving the advance; in subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 22 that the tax on documents issued within a month by taxpayers, institutions and organisations determined by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is declared on a return to the tax office by the evening of the twentieth (twenty-sixth from 1/4/2019 under Tax Procedure Law Circular No. 115) day of the following month and paid by the evening of the twenty-sixth day; in Article 23 that stamp duty withheld within a month by offices and establishments other than general budget offices that must withhold from entitlements is declared on a return to the tax office of the place of payment by the evening of the twentieth (twenty-sixth for returns filed from 1/4/2019 under Tax Procedure Law Circular No. 115) day of the following month and paid by the evening of the twenty-sixth day; in the fourth paragraph of Article 24 that for documents drawn up by official offices or notaries and given to persons or left at the office on which stamp duty was not collected or collected short, the tax belongs to the taxpayers and the penalty to those who drew them up; and in the fifth paragraph that the tax and penalty are collected from those who drew up the documents, with a right of recourse against the taxpayers for the tax.

Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I. Documents relating to contracts" of table (1) annexed to that Law provides that agreements, undertakings and assignments containing a specific amount, and paragraph 1/a of the section titled "IV. Receipts and other documents" provides that receipts and release deeds containing a specific amount given by persons to official offices for payments (including advances) relating to purchases of goods and services by official offices, and documents ensuring the transfer of these payments to accounts opened or to be opened in the names of persons on behalf of official offices or their payment to their order and transfer, are subject to proportional stamp duty.

Paragraph A/1 of the section titled "I. Documents relating to official business" of table (2) annexed to the Law provides that all kinds of documents covering transactions between official offices, and answers and their annexes written by persons in response to questions from these offices, are exempt from stamp duty.

For stamp duty purposes, bodies attached to the official offices defined in the law that have both separate legal personality and an economic character are not accepted as official offices, whereas bodies lacking either of these two features are treated as official offices.

From the decision of the … Provincial Special Administration Provincial General Council dated …/…/… numbered … annexed to your ruling request form, it is understood that it was decided under Article 53 of Provincial Special Administration Law No. 5302 to establish an in-budget enterprise (economic enterprise) named "…" within the Provincial Special Administration Directorate of Culture and Social Affairs and to transfer capital to it, and that the necessary permission was given by the Ministry of Interior on …/…/….

Within the above explanations, if your enterprise has no legal personality separate from the Provincial Special Administration Directorate of Culture and Social Affairs or does not have an economic character, it must be treated as an "official office" under Article 8 of the Stamp Duty Law.

In this context:

a) the stamp duties on documents signed between your enterprise and taxpayers without permanent stamp duty registration must be collected from the contractor firms, which are in the position of persons under Stamp Duty Law No. 488, and paid by your enterprise; and the stamp duty on agreements drawn up between your enterprise and taxpayers with permanent stamp duty registration must be declared by either party under subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 22 of Law No. 488 on a stamp duty return (tax type code 0040) to the tax office to which it is attached for permanent stamp duty registration by the evening of the twenty-sixth day of the month following the date the documents were drawn up and paid within the same period,

b) documents issued for payments (progress payments, advances, etc.) made by your enterprise relating to its purchases of goods and services must be subject to proportional stamp duty under paragraph IV/1-a of table (1) annexed to Law No. 488, and the tax must be collected by withholding at the time of payment and declared on the withholding return under Article 23 of Law No. 488 by the evening of the twenty-sixth day of the month following the date the documents were drawn up and paid within the same period.

On the other hand, no stamp duty will be sought on documents drawn up between your enterprise and institutions and organisations deemed official offices under Article 8 of Law No. 488, under paragraph I/A-1 of table (2) annexed to the Law.

In Terms of the Value Added Tax Law

Value Added Tax Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,

- in Article 9/1, that where the taxpayer has no domicile, place of business, legal seat or business centre in Turkey and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold those who are parties to taxable transactions liable for payment of the tax in order to secure the tax receivable.

The VAT General Application Communiqué sets out in section (I/C-2.1.2.) the nature of full withholding and transactions subject to full withholding; in section (I/C-2.1.3.1.) the nature of partial withholding and buyers to apply withholding; in section (I/C-2.1.3.2.) services subject to partial withholding; and in section (I/C-2.1.3.3.) deliveries subject to partial withholding.

Section (I/C-2.1.3.1.) of that Communiqué states:

"Those who may be held responsible for VAT withholding within partial withholding are listed below in two groups, and those who must apply withholding for each transaction within withholding are specified in the relevant sections of the Communiqué by reference to one or both of these groups or to certain responsible persons within these groups.
a) VAT taxpayers (those paying VAT only as withholding agents are not within this scope)
b) Designated buyers (whether or not VAT taxpayers):
- administrations, institutions and organisations in the schedules annexed to Law No. 5018, provincial special administrations and unions they form, unions formed by municipalities and village service unions,
- public institutions and organisations established by law or Presidential Decree other than those listed above,
- organisations with revolving funds,
- professional organisations in the nature of public institutions,
- pension and aid funds established by law or with legal personality,
- banks,
- insurance, reinsurance and pension companies,
- trade unions and their confederations,
- foundation universities,
- mobile electronic communication operators,
- water and sewerage administrations of metropolitan municipalities,
- state economic enterprises (State Economic Organisations, State Economic Enterprises),
- organisations within privatisation,
- organisations transferred to the Turkey Wealth Fund and sub-funds,
- organised industrial zones and all exchanges including securities and futures exchanges,
- institutions, organisations and enterprises more than half of whose shares belong directly (alone or together) to the administrations, institutions and organisations listed above,
- companies whose shares are traded on Borsa İstanbul (BİST) A.Ş.,
- development and investment agencies.
School-parent associations and family medicine institutions attached to the Ministry of Health are not treated within section (I/C-2.1.3.1/b) of the Communiqué.
VAT withholding is not applied to deliveries and services made by designated buyers to each other (except those made by professional sports clubs, including those that have become companies)."

Accordingly, VAT withholding must be applied under the explanations in section (I/C-2.1.) of the VAT General Application Communiqué on purchases of goods and services made by your economic enterprise, which is a VAT taxpayer and at the same time within the designated buyers, and the withheld amounts must be declared and paid on VAT Return No. 2.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.