A contractor awarded the demolition, in exchange for scrap, of a school building and removal of debris, tendered by a provincial special administration, asked whether documents relating to the tender decision and contract are exempt from stamp duty under Law No. 222.
The Administration's view:
- Contracts drawn up in official offices' tenders and tender decisions are subject to proportional stamp duty.
- Art. 83 of Law No. 222 exempts primary education revenues and the expenses listed in Art. 78 (excluding personnel costs) from all duties and taxes; Art. 78 lists items such as school construction, repair, equipment and general expenses.
- Since demolishing a school building for scrap and removing debris is not among the expenses in Art. 78, documents relating to the tender decision and contract cannot benefit from this exemption.
The ruling is relevant to contractors undertaking demolition and scrap works in public tenders.
Full text
Subject: Stamp duty in the application of Law No. 222
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From examination of your ruling request form referred to above and its annexes, it is understood that, stating that you were awarded the "Demolition of the … School Building in Exchange for Scrap and Removal of Debris Work" tendered by the … Provincial Special Administration Directorate of Support Services, an opinion is requested on whether documents issued for the tender decision and contract relating to that work are exempt from stamp duty under Law No. 222.
Stamp Duty Law No. 488 provides in Article 1 that documents listed in table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty; in Article 3 that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the documents and that stamp duty on documents relating to transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons; and in Article 8 that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, provincial special administrations, investment monitoring and coordination presidencies, municipalities and villages.
Paragraph A/9 of the section titled "I- Documents relating to contracts" of table (1) annexed to that Law provides that contracts drawn up with the administration conducting the tender in tenders by official offices for purchases of goods and services, and Article 2 of the section titled "II- Decisions and minutes" provides that all kinds of tender decisions of official offices and institutions with public legal personality, whether or not subject to Tender Laws, are subject to proportional stamp duty.
On the other hand, Article 7 of Primary Education and Education Law No. 222, as amended by Law No. 6287 Amending the Primary Education and Education Law and Certain Laws, provides that primary education is a National Education and Training Institution consisting of a four-year compulsory primary school and a four-year compulsory lower secondary school established to achieve the purpose stated in Article 1; and Article 83 provides that all revenues of primary education and the expenses specified in Article 78 (excluding personnel expenses) are exempt from all kinds of duties and taxes.
The expenses listed in Article 78 of that Law cover expenses to be incurred by primary education institutions, and the article lists as primary education expenses:
- in paragraph a), the construction, alteration and major repair of village, town and city primary education institutions and teachers' housing, all kinds of initial installations and school furniture, teaching equipment, and expropriation of plots and land,
- in paragraph b), all kinds of expenses such as minor repairs, general expenses of schools, the cost of school books and teaching supplies to be given free to poor students, making up students' shortages of food and clothing, treatment of serious illnesses, and expenses of boarding primary schools and supplementary courses and classes.
In this framework, considering that the "Demolition of the … School Building in Exchange for Scrap and Removal of Debris Work" tendered by the … Provincial Special Administration is not among the expenses listed in Article 78 of Law No. 222, it is not possible to exempt from stamp duty under Law No. 222 the documents issued for the tender decision and contract of that work.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.