A real estate trading company could not deliver a property it sold because the cadastral court cancelled the registration, and as a result of the buyer's lawsuit it paid the property's market value and statutory interest through enforcement. It asked whether these payments are deductible.
The Administration's view:
- Under ITL 40/3, damages and compensation paid under a contract, judgment or law are deductible if business-related; compensation arising from personal fault or offences is not.
- If the sale price was taken into account as income in the period it was collected, the portion of compensation paid through enforcement corresponding to the amount previously recorded as income can be deducted in the period of payment.
- The statutory interest running from the date of the lawsuit under the court decision cannot be deducted.
The ruling is relevant to companies paying compensation for failing to perform a sale contract.
Full text
Subject: Whether an unjust enrichment amount paid through enforcement on behalf of a company can be deducted on the corporate tax return
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that you are a corporate taxpayer engaged in buying and selling real estate, that you sold the property registered in the company's name to … on …, but that possession could not be delivered because the Cadastral Court cancelled the registration relating to that sale, that therefore … filed an unjust enrichment lawsuit against your company, and that the compensation ordered to be paid by decision of the … Civil Court of First Instance, Case No: …, and the statutory interest running from the date of the lawsuit were paid through enforcement, you request information on whether these payments are to be taken into account as expenses in determining corporate income; our Presidency's opinion is explained below.
Article 6 titled "Net corporate income" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
The first paragraph of Article 40 of Income Tax Law No. 193 lists deductible expenses, and subparagraph (3) of the same paragraph provides that damages, losses and compensation paid under a contract, judgment or order of law may be recorded as expenses provided that they are business-related.
Article 8 of the Corporate Tax Law lists the expenses that taxpayers may additionally deduct from revenue in determining corporate income calculated like commercial income. Subparagraph (g) of the first paragraph of Article 11 titled "Non-Deductible Items" of the same Law provides that, excluding compensation set as a penalty clause in contracts, material and moral damage compensation expenses arising from offences of the entity itself, its partners, managers and employees are not accepted as deductions in determining corporate income.
The section titled "11.8. Compensation expenses arising from offences of the entity itself, its partners, managers and employees" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states: "Excluding compensation set as a penalty clause in contracts, material and moral compensation expenses arising from offences of the entity itself, its partners, managers and employees cannot be taken into account as deductions."
Accordingly, for damages and compensation paid to be recorded as expenses, they must be business-related and made under a contract, judgment or order of law. Business-related means that the spending is closely connected with obtaining and maintaining commercial income, that is, a causal link must be established between the damages, losses and compensation and obtaining or maintaining commercial income. It is not possible to take into account as expenses damages, losses and compensation that are not business-related or, even if business-related, are paid due to the personal fault of the entity itself, its partners, managers and employees.
From the decision of the … Civil Court of First Instance, Case No: …, Decision No: …, annexed to your ruling request form, it is understood that the case is a compensation case based on the sale of real estate; that the plaintiff bought a share of … m² of the property in block … parcel …; that the sale price of the share was paid; that the property in dispute was not transferred in the land registry and not delivered to the plaintiff; that there was a valid sale between the parties; that in valid sales the plaintiff has the statutory right to claim the market value of the property sold as of the date performance became impossible; that although the plaintiff performed its obligation the defendant did not; and that, with the land registry record of the property in the company's name cancelled and registered in the name of a third party not party to the case, and with … , the date on which the Cadastral Court decision became final, accepted as the date on which performance of the contract became impossible, it was decided that TL …, the market value of the property on this date determined by experts, be collected from you together with statutory interest running from the date of the lawsuit.
According to these provisions and explanations, if the sale price of your land-type property registered in your Company's name was taken into account as income in determining your corporate income for the period in which it was collected, it is possible to take into account as an expense in determining your corporate income in the period of payment the portion of the compensation paid through enforcement based on that court decision corresponding to the amount you previously recorded as income, while it is not possible to take into account as an expense in determining your corporate income the statutory interest running from the date of the lawsuit under that court decision.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.