TREN
Contact us

No Corporate Tax Withholding on E-PIN Codes Bought from a Foreign Firm; VAT Depends on Whether the Code Represents a Specific Product or Service

Corporate Income Tax · Foreign incomeNo Corporate Tax Withholding on E-PIN Codes Bought from a Foreign Firm; VAT Depends on Whether the Code Represents a Specific Product or ServicePrivate ruling · 6 August 2024
Rast note

A company that buys E-PIN codes from a foreign-resident firm under a dealership agreement and resells them asked whether corporate tax and VAT must be withheld on the purchase, and how VAT and corporate tax apply to domestic and foreign sales.

The Administration's view:

  • The foreign firm's earnings from selling codes are business profits; as CTL 30 does not subject business profits to withholding, no corporate tax is withheld on the payments.
  • Under Article 7 of the relevant double taxation agreement, these earnings are taxable only in the firm's state of residence unless obtained through a permanent establishment in Turkey.
  • If the codes are payment-type codes not representing a specific product or service, their import and domestic sale are outside the scope of VAT.
  • If the codes represent a specific product or service, VAT on import is paid by the buyer as responsible party via VAT Return No. 2; domestic sales bear VAT declared via Return No. 1; sales to foreign-resident firms are exempt under VATL 11/1-a.

The ruling is relevant to companies sourcing digital codes or e-pins from abroad for resale.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether tax should be withheld on payments for e-pin codes purchased from a firm resident in …
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that "E-PIN" codes (…) are purchased from a firm resident in … and resold and that there are dealership agreements with the selling firm, our Presidency's opinion is requested on:

- whether tax should be withheld under the Value Added Tax and Corporate Tax Laws on the purchase of E-PIN codes,
- whether VAT should be calculated when E-PIN codes are sold to another company established in Turkey or abroad or to the final consumer, and whether the earnings from such sales are subject to corporate tax.

UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW

The second paragraph of Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 states that entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal and business centres are both outside Turkey are taxed on a limited liability basis only on earnings obtained in Turkey. The third paragraph of the same article lists the earnings and income constituting corporate income under limited liability, and the fourth paragraph provides that the relevant provisions of Income Tax Law No. 193 apply regarding earning in Turkey of the earnings, income and revenue items in the article and having a permanent representative in Turkey.

The first paragraph of Article 7 of the Income Tax Law states the conditions under which earnings and income are deemed obtained in Turkey for persons subject to limited liability; subparagraph 1 states that commercial earnings are deemed obtained in Turkey if the earner has a workplace or permanent representative in Turkey and the earnings are obtained at those places or through those representatives, and subparagraph 4 states that self-employment earnings are deemed obtained in Turkey if the self-employment activities are performed or evaluated in Turkey. The third paragraph of that article provides that evaluation means payment in Turkey or, if payment is made abroad, its transfer to the accounts of the payer in Turkey or of the person on whose behalf payment is made, or its allocation from profit.

The first paragraph of Article 30 of the Corporate Tax Law provides that corporate tax is withheld by those paying in cash or on account or accruing, including advances, the earnings and income of entities subject to limited liability listed in subparagraphs of the article; commercial earnings are not among the earnings and income subject to withholding.

According to these provisions and explanations, corporate tax should not be withheld on payments made for activation codes (…) purchased from the firm resident in ….

2- UNDER DOUBLE TAXATION AGREEMENTS

Paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the Agreement between the Republic of Turkey and … for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income, applied since 01.01.1989, provides: "1. The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein. If the enterprise carries on business through a permanent establishment in the other Contracting State, the profits may be taxed in the other State but only so much of them as is attributable to that permanent establishment."

"Permanent establishment" is defined in Article 5 of the Agreement, which states clearly in which cases a permanent establishment arises in the other state.

Accordingly, the earnings of the firm resident in … from selling E-PIN codes must be treated as business profits under Article 7 of the Agreement, and the income of the company resident in … must be taxed only in … unless obtained through a permanent establishment in Turkey. If such income is obtained through a permanent establishment in Turkey, Turkey will have the right to tax it under domestic legislation, limited to the amount attributable to that permanent establishment.

On the other hand, earnings from selling E-PIN codes domestically must be evaluated under domestic legislation, and for sales of such codes abroad, under the provisions of a double taxation agreement if one exists between Turkey and the country of sale, or otherwise under domestic legislation.

3- UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW

Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities, and in Article 1/2, that all imports of goods and services are subject to VAT,
- in Article 4/1, that a service is any transaction other than deliveries, deemed deliveries and imports of goods,
- in Article 6/b, that a transaction made in Turkey means the service being performed in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey,
- in Article 8/1-a, that those making deliveries of goods and services are the taxpayers,
- in Article 9/1, that where the taxpayer has no domicile, workplace, legal centre or business centre in Turkey and in other cases deemed necessary, the Ministry of Treasury and Finance may hold parties to taxable transactions responsible for paying the tax in order to secure the tax receivable,
- in Article 11/1-a, that services rendered to customers abroad are exempt from VAT,
- in Article 12/2, that customer abroad means buyers whose domicile, workplace, legal and business centre is abroad and branches abroad of a domestic firm operating independently in their own name; and that for a service to be deemed rendered to customers abroad, it must be rendered for a customer abroad or benefited from abroad.

The section titled "VAT Application on the Sale of Cards, Passwords, Codes and Similar" (I/B-16.) of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:

"16.1. General Explanation
Cards, passwords and codes (activation codes, e-pin codes, game codes, digital product codes, wallet codes, gift cards/vouchers and similar) can be used to obtain products and services such as computer programs, games, applications, music, broadcasts and entertainment marketed online (streaming platforms, game sites, app stores, etc.), and can also be used for secure shopping in virtual or physical stores; these cards, passwords and codes can be sold online or physically.
Such cards, passwords and codes may constitute the consideration for a specific product or service, or may represent a virtual purchasing power to buy products or services from those issuing them.
16.2. VAT Application on Cards, Passwords and Codes Whose Consideration Is a Specific Product or Service
Some cards, passwords and codes represent a specific product or service, and even if not yet activated, no other product or service can be obtained with them. The import from abroad or sale in Turkey of these cards, passwords and codes sold online or physically in stores is subject to VAT.
Where these cards, passwords and codes are:
- obtained by Turkish residents from firms resident abroad, the VAT on this transaction must be declared and paid by the Turkish residents as responsible parties with VAT Return No. 2,
- obtained by individuals resident in Turkey who are not VAT taxpayers from electronic service providers resident abroad, the VAT on this transaction must be declared and paid by the foreign-resident firm with VAT Return No. 3,
- sold in Turkey, the VAT calculated must be declared by the selling firms with VAT Return No. 1.
...
16.3. VAT Application on Cards, Passwords and Codes Whose Consideration Is Not a Specific Product or Service
Some cards, passwords and codes represent a virtual purchasing power for later deliveries or services from the providers of products or services. When used, no specific product or service is obtained; a right to purchase online or physically arises.
16.3.1. VAT Application on the Sale of Cards, Passwords and Codes Whose Consideration Is Not a Specific Product or Service
The sale of cards, passwords and codes sold online or physically under names such as wallet code, which do not represent the consideration for a specific product or service, which create a purchase right with the issuing firm when used and which are in the nature of a means of payment, is outside the scope of VAT. In this context, obtaining these cards, passwords and codes from abroad or selling them within Turkey will not be subject to VAT.
..."

Section (I/C-2.1.2.1.) of that Communiqué contains explanations on transactions by those whose domicile, workplace, legal centre and business centre are not in Turkey, and section (II/A-2.) on export of services.

Accordingly,

- If the e-pin codes to be obtained by your Company are codes in the nature of a means of payment that do not represent the consideration for a specific product or service, their import from abroad and/or sale within Turkey will not be subject to VAT.

- If the e-pin codes to be obtained by your Company are codes whose consideration is a specific product or service, their import from abroad is subject to VAT under Article 1/2 of Law No. 3065, and the VAT calculated must be declared and paid by your Company as a responsible party with VAT Return No. 2. Naturally, if the foreign-resident firm comes to have a workplace in Turkey due to e-pin code sales, the VAT calculated on the invoice issued must be declared by that firm with VAT Return No. 1. On the sale of these imported e-pin codes to another firm in Turkey or to the final consumer, VAT must be calculated under Article 1/1 of Law No. 3065 and declared by your Company with VAT Return No. 1, while the sale of these codes by your Company to foreign-resident firms may be exempted from VAT under Article 11/1-a of Law No. 3065.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.