An energy generation company sold a plot together with the power plant installed on it and asked whether it could benefit from the CTL 5/1-e and VATL 17/4-r exemptions on this sale.
The Administration's view:
- The exemption requires the immovable to be registered in the land register in the entity's name; per TAKBİS records the immovable is a plot and no type correction has been made for the plant.
- For corporate tax, provided other conditions are met, only the gain attributable to the plot can be exempted under CTL 5/1-e (pre-7456 provisions and Provisional Art. 16).
- For VAT, as the plant is not registered in the entity's name, the price corresponding to the plant must be separated and subjected to VAT.
- The price attributable to the plot is exempt under VATL 17/4-r (Provisional Art. 43), provided the plot has been in the assets for at least two full years.
The ruling is relevant to entities selling immovables whose buildings or structures are not registered in the land register.
Full text
Subject: VAT and corporate tax exemption on the sale of a power plant together with the land on which it stands
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
….
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that as a company you bought on … the land on which a power plant is installed within your energy generation activities and sold that land together with the power plant installed on it on …, you request our Directorate's opinion on whether you can benefit from the corporate tax and value added tax exemptions on that land sale.
I- UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW
Subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520, before its amendment by Law No. 7456, provided:
"75% of the earnings of entities from the sale of participation shares held in their assets for at least two full years, and of founders' shares, usufruct shares, pre-emptive rights held for the same period and participation shares of investment funds giving rise to exempt earnings under subparagraph (a) of this paragraph, and 50% of the earnings from the sale of immovables held in their assets for the same period.
This exemption is applied in the period of sale, and the exempt portion of the sale gain is kept in a special fund account on the liabilities side until the end of the fifth year following the year of sale. However, the sale price must be collected by the end of the second calendar year following the year of sale. Taxes not accrued on time due to the exemption corresponding to sale proceeds not collected within this period are deemed lost.
Taxes not accrued on time due to the exemption applied to the portion of the exempt gain transferred to another account in any way other than addition to capital, withdrawn from the business, or transferred to the head office by limited-liability entities within five years are deemed lost. This provision also applies if the business is liquidated within the same period (except transfers and divisions under this Law).
...
Earnings of entities engaged in trading or leasing securities or immovables from the sale of values held for this purpose are outside the scope of the exemption."
By Article 19 of Law No. 7456, published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, sales of immovables were removed from that exemption from 15/7/2023, and Provisional Article 16 added to the Corporate Tax Law by Article 22 of the same Law provides: "For immovables in the assets of entities before the entry into force of this article, the provisions of subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 before their amendment by the Law introducing this article apply. However, the 50% rate in subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of this Law is applied as 25% for immovable sale gains made after the entry into force of this article."
On the matter, Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 states:
- in the section titled "5.6.2. Application of the exemption in sales after the publication date of the Corporate Tax Law":
"...The first sentence of subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of Law No. 5520 was amended by subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 89 of Law No. 7061, and from 5/12/2017 (inclusive), when the amendment entered into force, the exemption will apply to 50% of the gain from sales of immovables; 75% of the gain from sales of immovables made before this date may be subject to the exemption....",
- in the section titled "5.6.2.2.1. Immovables":
"Immovables subject to the exemption are goods defined as 'immovable' in the Turkish Civil Code which by their essential nature cannot be moved from one place to another and are therefore fixed in place.
These are listed in Article 704 of the Turkish Civil Code as:
- Land,
- Independent and permanent rights registered on a separate page of the land register,
- Independent units registered in the condominium register.
For the gain from immovables to be disposed of to be subject to this exemption, the immovable must be registered in the land register in the name of the entity under Article 705 of the Turkish Civil Code. Therefore, this exemption will not apply to the gain from the sale of a building not registered in the land register in the name of the entity.
In practice, there may be delays for various reasons in registering the type correction in the name of the entity. In such cases, in determining whether the immovable has been in the business assets for two years, it may be possible to document by a building construction permit, a tax office determination or one of the records of official institutions that it has been owned and actually used in the business for more than two years.
For example, if an immovable actually used for more than two years based on an allocation certificate issued by organised industrial zones or for various reasons, but not yet registered in the entity's name in the land register, is sold based on the allocation certificate or by transfer of possession, the exemption will not apply since there is no sale of an immovable; however, if an immovable whose two full years of use is documented as explained above is sold after being registered in the land register in the entity's name, the gains from the sale will be considered within this exemption.",
- and in the section "5.6.2.3.1.3. Determination of the 2-year period for buildings under construction":
"Where entities sell buildings whose construction is not yet completed and which cannot actually be used, provided they have been recorded in the entity's assets for two full years, only the portion corresponding to the sale gain of the building's land will be exempt from corporate tax.
However, if a building constructed on land and recorded in assets is sold after being registered in the land register in the entity's name, the date on which construction was completed and the building began to be used as a building will be taken as the start date of the two-year holding period of the building sold."
Circular No. 2010/4-1697 dated 16.03.2010 of the General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre defines type change (type correction) as the procedure made on the map sheet and in the land register to convert the type of an immovable from unbuilt to built or built to unbuilt, or from vineyard, garden, field etc. to plot, or from land to vineyard, garden etc.
On the other hand, from the ruling request form referred to above and based on the TAKBİS query, it is understood that the immovable has the character of a plot in the land register records.
According to the above provisions and explanations, in the sale of the plot you bought in … together with the power plant installed on it, it is possible to exempt only the gain attributable to the plot of the power plant registered as a plot in the land register …, provided other conditions are also met, under subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law.
II- UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW
Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 17/4-r (before its amendment by Article 7 of Law No. 7456), that transfers and deliveries by sale of participation shares and immovables held in entities' assets for at least two full years are exempt from VAT, and that deliveries of immovables and participation shares held for this purpose by entities trading in exempt assets are outside the exemption.
On the other hand, Article 7 of Law No. 7456 abolished the exemption in Article 17/4-r of Law No. 3065 for transfers and deliveries by sale of immovables held in entities' assets for at least two full years, and Provisional Article 43 added to Law No. 3065 by Article 8 of Law No. 7456 provides that the provisions before the amendment of Article 17/4-r apply for immovables in entities' assets before 15/7/2023.
The sub-section titled "4.16.1.1. Application of the Exemption in the Sale of Immovables in Entities' Assets Before 15/7/2023" of the section titled "II/F-4.16.1. Application of the Exemption in Sales of Immovables" of the VAT General Application Communiqué states:
"Provisional Article 43 added to Law No. 3065 by Law No. 7456, published in Official Gazette No. 32249 dated 15/7/2023 and entering into force, provides:
"For immovables in entities' assets before the entry into force of this article, the provisions before the amendment made by the Law introducing this article in subparagraph (r) of paragraph (4) of Article 17 of this Law apply."
In this context, the VAT exemption will continue to apply to transfers and deliveries made by sale from 15/7/2023 by entities of immovables in their assets before 15/7/2023.
For the exemption to apply on the sale of immovables (plot, land, building) and participation shares, they must have been recorded in the entities' assets for at least 2 full years (730 days).
In calculating the minimum two-full-year holding period, periods during which these immovables were in the assets of asset leasing companies, financial leasing companies, participation banks and development and investment banks within the exemptions in Articles (17/4-u) and (17/4-y) of Law No. 3065 are also taken into account.
The exemption does not apply to the delivery of immovables held for this purpose by entities trading in exempt assets (habitually buying and selling or leasing immovables).
The exemption applies to transfers and deliveries made by sale. Transfers and deliveries in the form of donation or grant are outside the exemption.
..."
Accordingly, although it is understood from your ruling request form that the plot sold was acquired on …. with the power plant installed and sold on …., since the query in the Land Registry and Cadastre Information System found that no type correction was made for the power plant and therefore it was not registered in your company's name, it is not possible to apply the exemption in Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065 to the sale of the power plant; in the sale of the immovable registered as a plot in the land register, the price corresponding to the plant on the plot must be separated and subjected to VAT.
On the other hand, the sale price attributable to the plot may be exempted from VAT under Article (17/4-r) of Law No. 3065, provided the plot has been recorded in your company's assets for at least two full years.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.