TREN
Contact us

Planned Maintenance, Fault Repair and Periodic Maintenance of Electricity Distribution Networks Are Not Multi-Year Construction and Repair Work; No Withholding on Progress Payments

Personal Income TaxPlanned Maintenance, Fault Repair and Periodic Maintenance of Electricity Distribution Networks Are Not Multi-Year Construction and Repair Work; No Withholding on Progress PaymentsPrivate ruling · 2 August 2024
Rast note

An entity procuring personnel- and vehicle-based maintenance and repair services for electricity distribution networks asked whether the service is multi-year construction and repair work under ITL 42 and whether CTL 15/1-a withholding applies to progress payments to the contractor.

The Administration's view:

  • ITL 42 requires the work to be construction or repair, to span more than one calendar year and to be performed under a commitment; repair means large-scale repair and renewal of dilapidated parts of an immovable other than its frame.
  • Maintenance to remove short-term fault sources on networks, detection work such as visual inspection, fixing non-urgent defects and observation work at transformer stations are not construction and repair work.
  • Therefore, even if the work spans more than one calendar year, no corporate tax is withheld on payments to the contractor joint venture.

The ruling is relevant to entities procuring or providing maintenance and repair services for energy infrastructure.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether level 1 and 2 planned maintenance and repair, fault repair, preventive and periodic maintenance of electricity distribution networks can be treated as multi-year work
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

….

From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, stating that a service of … will be procured, that the … … and …. … Agreement drawn up for it were submitted with the ruling request form, that the work under the standard agreements relates to the use of personnel and vehicles and that, considering the unit prices in the agreements, the work to be done is not within the construction and/or major repair of energy transmission lines, it is understood that our Presidency's opinion is requested on:

- whether the service procured under the attached standard agreements can be considered multi-year construction and repair work under Article 42 of the Income Tax Law,
- whether withholding under subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 15 of the Corporate Tax Law should be made on the progress invoices to be issued by the contractor.

Article 42 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides: "In construction (stripping works are also deemed construction) and repair works spanning more than one calendar year, profit or loss is definitively determined in the year the work is completed, and all of it is deemed income of that year and shown in that year's return."

For a work to be considered under Article 42 of the Income Tax Law, the following conditions must be met together:

- the subject of activity is construction (including stripping) and repair work,
- the construction and repair work spans more than one calendar year,
- the construction and repair work is performed under a commitment.

The first paragraph of Article 15 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that those obliged to withhold tax shall withhold on payments made in cash or on account to entities, including advances; subparagraph (a) of that paragraph provides that withholding is made on progress payments made to entities engaged in construction and repair works spanning more than one calendar year according to the principles of Income Tax Law No. 193 in relation to these works. The withholding rate has been set at 5% from 01.03.2021 under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14594.

On the other hand, the "Definitions" section of Article 4 of Public Procurement Law No. 4735 defines "Works: All kinds of construction works such as buildings, highways, railways, motorways, airports, quays, ports, shipyards, bridges, tunnels, metro, viaducts, sports facilities, infrastructure, pipelines, communication and energy transmission lines, dams, power plants, refinery facilities, irrigation facilities, land reclamation, flood protection and stripping, and the installation, manufacturing, excavation, transport, completion, major repair, restoration, landscaping, drilling, demolition, strengthening and assembly works related to these works, and similar works."

"Service" in the same article is defined as "Maintenance and repair, transport, communication, insurance, research and development, accounting, market research and surveys, consultancy, architecture and engineering, survey and project, mapping and cadastre, zoning application, zoning plans at all scales, promotion, printing and publishing, cleaning, food preparation and distribution, meetings, organisation, exhibition, protection and security, vocational training, photography, film, intellectual and fine arts, computer system services and software services, leasing of movable and immovable property and rights, and similar other services."

In general, construction covers all activities relating to the structural part of an immovable produced by using materials and labour, while repair refers to large-scale repair and renewal activities relating to rebuilding dilapidated parts of an immovable other than its frame.

In the annexes to your petition:

- Article 5 titled Job description of the …. .. Agreement signed with …. defines the work as "the performance of fault repair, preventive maintenance, periodic maintenance and planned maintenance of the … and … electricity distribution networks within …AŞ's area of responsibility and under …AŞ's responsibility, with the supply of personnel and vehicles belonging to the CONTRACTOR, in accordance with this agreement and its annexes, applicable legislation, technical and professional rules, and the organisation and work plan to be determined by …AŞ.",
- Article 5 titled Job description of the …. Electricity Distribution Networks Level 1 and 2 Maintenance and Repair Service Procurement Agreement defines the work as "the performance of Level 1 and 2 Planned Maintenance and Repair works on the … and … electricity distribution networks in …AŞ's area of responsibility, per kilometre on lines and per unit at DM/KÖK/fPs, with personnel and vehicles belonging to the CONTRACTOR and materials supplied by …AŞ, in accordance with this agreement and its annexes, applicable legislation, technical and professional rules, and the organisation and work plan to be determined by …AŞ."

According to these provisions and explanations, since maintenance of the … electricity distribution networks to remove conditions that may cause faults in the short term, detection work such as visual inspection that can be done without cutting power, maintenance work to remove defects that are not urgent in terms of safety of life and property, and detection work at transformer stations with technological devices to observe and prevent possible faults and similar works cannot be considered construction and repair work, no corporate tax will be withheld on payments made to the contractor joint venture for this work, even if it spans more than one calendar year.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.