TREN
Contact us

Domain, Portal, Server and Advertising Services Bought from Foreign Firms in Micro-Exports: Corporate Tax Withholding, VAT and Tax Treaty Treatment

Corporate Income Tax · Foreign incomeDomain, Portal, Server and Advertising Services Bought from Foreign Firms in Micro-Exports: Corporate Tax Withholding, VAT and Tax Treaty TreatmentPrivate ruling · 30 July 2024
Rast note

A company making micro-exports through online marketplaces asked about the tax treatment of advertising, sales commission, potential customer information, portal use, server, domain, application and software services obtained from foreign firms.

The Administration's view:

  • Payments for domain names, portal use, potential customer information and server storage are royalties subject to corporate tax withholding; other services are business profits and not subject to withholding.
  • Online advertising services are subject to 15% withholding under Presidential Decision No. 476; however, no withholding applies to ads published exclusively abroad where processes are not conducted through a workplace or permanent representative in Turkey.
  • For VAT, services relating to exports and benefited from only abroad are outside the scope of VAT; if also benefited from in Turkey, VAT is paid via Return No. 2 as responsible party and deductible on Return No. 1.
  • Under the US and Ireland DTAs, withholding on royalties may not exceed 10% (5% for use of a server in the USA); software used unmodified, sales commission and non-confidential customer information are business profits. A certificate of residence is needed to benefit from treaty provisions.

The ruling is relevant to companies making micro-exports via marketplaces and buying digital services from abroad.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Taxation of services obtained from abroad
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Ruling request dated 23.06.2023.

From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that in connection with your activity of selling products only to customers abroad within micro-export through sites such as …, …, services such as advertising aimed at customers, sales commission, potential customer information, fees for using the portal where sales are made, server storage, domain names, applications and software are obtained from firms resident abroad, an opinion is requested on the treatment of these services under the tax laws; our Presidency's opinion is set out below.

UNDER THE CORPORATE TAX LAW

The second paragraph of Article 3 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that entities listed in Article 1 of the Law whose legal and business centres are both outside Turkey are taxed on a limited liability basis only on earnings obtained in Turkey, and the third paragraph lists the earnings and income constituting corporate income under limited liability.

The first paragraph of Article 30 of the same Law provides that corporate tax is withheld at 15% on the earnings and income of entities subject to limited liability listed in the subparagraphs of that paragraph by those paying in cash or on account or accruing them, including advances, and the withholding rates were determined by Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 published in the Official Gazette dated 3/2/2009. However, that article contains no provision on withholding on payments within business profits.

The eighth paragraph of that article authorises the President to determine the withholding rates in this article separately by income items or fields of activity, to reduce them to zero and to increase them up to twice the specified rate; under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 issued on this authority, the withholding rates were set at 5% for earnings from petroleum exploration activities, 20% for other self-employment earnings and 20% for royalty payments.

On the other hand, by Presidential Decision No. 476 dated 18/12/2018 published in Official Gazette No. 30630 dated 19/12/2018, online advertising services provided to those listed in the first paragraph of Article 94 of the Income Tax Law and the first paragraph of Article 15 of the Corporate Tax Law were brought within the scope of withholding, and it was provided that tax must be withheld on payments made to providers of these services or to intermediaries of online advertising services, regardless of whether the recipients are taxpayers. In this context, Article 3 of that Decision reads:

"ARTICLE 3- The following subparagraph has been added to the first paragraph of Article 1 of the Decision annexed to Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 dated 12/1/2009 on withholding rates on earnings and income of entities subject to limited liability subject to withholding under Article 30 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520.
"15- Of payments within the seventh paragraph of Article 11 of the Tax Procedure Law;
a) 15% on payments made, in relation to online advertising services, to providers of these services or intermediaries of online advertising services."

On the other hand, the section titled "30.4.11.1.1. Withholding on payments for online advertising services" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, which contains explanations on that Decision, states:

"Under the amendment made to Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14593 by Presidential Decision No. 476, tax must be withheld at 15% on payments made, in relation to online advertising services, to limited-liability entities providing this service or intermediating online advertising services.
Accordingly, those responsible for withholding listed in section (15.1.) of the Communiqué are obliged to withhold at 15% on payments they will make to a limited-liability entity in return for online advertising services it provides. ..."

Therefore, tax must be withheld at 15% under Article 30 of the Corporate Tax Law on payments made to limited-liability entities providing online advertising services or intermediating online advertising services.

Within these provisions and explanations:

1- Payments you made for domain names, portal (website) use where sales are made, potential customer information and server storage services purchased from abroad are in the nature of royalty payments, and corporate tax must be withheld on these payments.

2- Since the other services you obtain from foreign firms are considered within commercial activity, corporate tax must not be withheld under Article 30 of the Corporate Tax Law on payments made against invoices to foreign firms for these activities.

3- Naturally, if you obtain online advertising services, tax will be withheld at 15% under Presidential Decision No. 476 on payments made for these advertising services from 1/1/2019.

4- For the business profits of limited-liability entities to be subject to corporate tax in Turkey, they must have a workplace or permanent representative in Turkey in accordance with Tax Procedure Law No. 213 and the earnings must be obtained from work done at these places or through these representatives. Therefore, for entities whose legal and business centres are not in Turkey:

- since their business profits obtained abroad are not subject to corporate tax in Turkey, and
- since online advertising services they provide for publication abroad cannot be considered work done at a workplace in Turkey or through a permanent representative, provided the processes relating to the service, including the contract, are not conducted at a workplace in Turkey or through a permanent representative,

no tax should be withheld under Decision No. 476 where payments are made to those entities for online advertising services published exclusively abroad.

5- Where payments are made to limited-liability entities for online advertising services published domestically and aimed at domestic customers, tax must be withheld at 15% under Article 30 of the Corporate Tax Law.

UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 4, that a service is any transaction other than deliveries, deemed deliveries and imports of goods, and that these transactions may take forms such as doing, processing, creating, manufacturing, repairing, cleaning, keeping, preparing, evaluating, leasing something or undertaking not to do something,
- in Article 6, that a transaction made in Turkey means the goods being in Turkey at the time of delivery, the service being performed in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey.

Section (1.1.1.) titled "Transactions Abroad" of VAT Circular No. 60 states:

"Under Articles 1 and 6 of the VAT Law, deliveries of goods taking place abroad and services performed abroad and benefited from abroad are outside the scope of VAT. There is no question of calculating VAT on the price of a transaction not made in Turkey or associating such a transaction with any exemption provision in the Law.
Accordingly, for a taxpayer in Turkey:
...
- the intermediary service provided for deliveries that a foreign firm will make directly to another foreign firm (without the goods coming to Turkey),
...
- the sales commission service provided abroad for marketing a foreign firm's goods to another foreign firm
are outside the scope of VAT since they are not performed in Turkey or benefited from in Turkey."

According to these provisions and explanations, since services such as advertising aimed at customers, sales commission, potential customer information, portal use fees where sales are made, server storage, domain names, applications and software obtained from foreign-resident firms in relation to export transactions and benefited from abroad are outside the scope of VAT, there is no need to withhold VAT as a responsible party on payments you make to the foreign-resident firm for these services.

However, if services such as advertising aimed at customers, sales commission, potential customer information, portal use fees where sales are made, server storage, domain names, applications and software obtained from foreign-resident firms in relation to your export transactions are also benefited from in Turkey, these services are subject to VAT, and if the foreign-resident firms have no domicile, workplace, legal centre or business centre in Turkey, the VAT on this transaction must be declared and paid by you as a responsible party with VAT Return No. 2. The tax so declared and paid can be deducted with VAT Return No. 1.

UNDER DOUBLE TAXATION AGREEMENTS

The Turkey - United States of America Double Taxation Agreement has applied since 1 January 1998 and the Turkey - Ireland Double Taxation Agreement since 1 January 2011, and the relevant paragraphs of Article 7 titled "Business Profits" and Article 12 titled "Royalties" of the Agreements are annexed.

Accordingly, payments for domain names, portal use, server storage services and confidential information on potential customers obtained from firms resident in these countries must be treated as royalties, and under paragraph 2 of Article 12 of the Agreements, tax must be withheld in Turkey at a rate not exceeding 10% of the gross amount of the payment, and 5% for the fee for using the server located in the USA.

If applications and software obtained from these firms are used in your business or sold to final consumers without any modification or reproduction, the earnings of these firms, and the earnings from sales commission paid to them and from non-confidential information on potential customers, must be treated as business profits and taxed only in these countries unless the firms resident in these countries carry on business through a permanent establishment in Turkey. However, if firms resident in these countries carry on business through a permanent establishment in Turkey within Article 5 of the Agreements, Turkey will have the right to tax under domestic legislation, limited to the amount attributable to that permanent establishment.

Where the Agreements give Turkey the right to tax, under paragraph 1 of Article 23 of the Agreements on elimination of double taxation, taxing the same income twice will be avoided by crediting the tax paid in Turkey against the tax payable in the USA and Ireland.

Where the Agreement provisions change domestic legislation, to benefit from them the companies resident in the USA and Ireland must prove with a document obtained from the competent authorities of these countries that they are fully liable taxpayers in these countries and taxed there on their worldwide income, and the original of this document and a copy of its Turkish translation certified by a notary or by Turkish Consulates in that country must be submitted to the withholding agents or the relevant tax office. Naturally, if the certificate of residence cannot be submitted, domestic legislation will apply instead of the relevant agreement provisions.

For your information.

(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.