A company whose management and supervision was placed under the SDIF as trustee asked whether the gain from the SDIF's sale of the company to a third party to pay debts is exempt under CTL 5/1-f.
The Administration's view:
- The CTL 5/1-f exemption applies to gains, corresponding to the part of proceeds used to settle the debts, from transferring assets such as real estate or participation shares to banks or the SDIF against debts, for entities under legal follow-up for bank debts or indebted to the SDIF.
- The exemption applies where the assets are transferred or sold to the creditor banks or the SDIF and the proceeds are used to settle those debts.
- Gain from a sale to a third party, used to finance debts to other banks, cannot benefit from the exemption.
The ruling is relevant to companies under trusteeship or selling assets due to bank debts.
Full text
Subject: Gain exemption on a company sale by the SDIF
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
a) …
b) …
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to in (a) and your petition referred to in (b), it is understood that, stating that:
- by decision of …, under Article 133 of Criminal Procedure Law No. 5271 and the relevant provisions of Decree-Law No. 674, the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (SDIF) was appointed trustee over the management and supervision of your Company,
- a non-sustainability report dated … was issued on your Company by … A.Ş., and the Company was sold by the SDIF on … to pay its debts to banks and other creditors,
- in the sale of the Company, the sale price was collected by the SDIF, its debts to banks and other creditors were also paid by the SDIF, and there was no flow of collections or payments through the Company,
our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the gain from the sale of the Company is exempt under Article 5/1-f of the Corporate Tax Law.
Article 5 titled "Exemptions" of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides:
"(1) The following gains are exempt from corporate tax:
....
f) The entirety of gains corresponding to the part used to settle these debts of the proceeds from the transfer to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, against these debts, of immovables, participation shares, founders' shares and usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities under legal follow-up due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors, and 50% of the gains from the sale of immovables (including immovables subject to financial leasing over which the lessor took all disposal rights by mutual agreement of the parties against financial leasing receivables under legal follow-up due to the lessee's default in financial leasing transactions under Law No. 6361) and 75% of the gains from the sale of others among such assets thus obtained by banks, financial leasing or financing companies
..."
The section titled "5.7.1. Exemption granted to entities under legal follow-up due to their debts to banks, financial leasing or financing companies or indebted to the SDIF and to their guarantors and mortgagors" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, containing detailed explanations on the matter, states:
"By subparagraph (f) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law, the entirety of gains corresponding to the part used to settle these debts of the proceeds from the transfer to banks or this Fund, against these debts, of immovables, participation shares, founders' shares and usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights owned by entities under legal follow-up due to their debts to banks or indebted to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund, and by their guarantors and mortgagors, has been exempted from corporate tax.
Entities to benefit from this exemption must have been placed under legal follow-up under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 due to their debts to banks or be indebted to the SDIF.
The exemption may be benefited from by entities under legal follow-up due to bank debts or indebted to the SDIF and by their guarantors who are corporate taxpayers or corporate taxpayers giving mortgages on behalf of these entities.
The assets subject to the exemption are immovables, participation shares, founders' shares and usufruct shares and pre-emptive rights.
On the other hand, the gain that can benefit from the exemption will be limited to the amount corresponding to the part used to settle these debts of the proceeds from the sale or other transfer of these assets to banks or the SDIF against the debts.
..."
On the other hand, Article 20 titled "Powers of the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund relating to sale and liquidation" of Law No. 6758 on the Adoption with Amendments of the Decree-Law on Certain Regulations Under the State of Emergency provides:
"(1) The powers given to the Fund by Banking Law No. 5411 dated 19/10/2005 regarding banks/companies whose partnership rights other than dividends and management and supervision have been taken over by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund and their assets apply by analogy in the trusteeship duty given to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund by this Law and in sale or liquidation transactions, regardless of whether these companies or their owners are indebted to the Fund and whether there is a Fund attachment on their assets. Article 37 of Law No. 6755 dated 8/11/2016 on the Adoption with Amendments of the Decree-Law on Measures to Be Taken Under the State of Emergency and Regulations on Certain Institutions and Organisations applies to those appointed, assigned, or assigned by appointees with representation authority to manage and represent during investigation, prosecution or bankruptcy and liquidation the banks/companies and partnership shares whose management and supervision or trusteeship authority has been transferred to the Fund or to which the Fund has been appointed trustee, and to those appointed, assigned, or assigned by appointees with representation authority for the management of asset values under the tenth paragraph of Article 128 of Law No. 5271, and to the business and transactions performed within this scope. The liquidation commission assigned by the Fund Board to carry out liquidation transactions of companies has capacity to be a party in judicial proceedings or lawsuits. From the amount to be obtained from the sale under this article of companies or partnership shares to which the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund has been appointed trustee, the amount remaining after deducting the Fund's sale, litigation or attorney costs is held in an interest-bearing account until the proceedings are concluded with a final judgment. The amounts to be obtained from the sale under this article of company assets or asset values are distributed according to the ranking list prepared under Article 134 of Law No. 5411. The balance after distribution according to the ranking list is transferred to company accounts for the transactions in the fourth paragraph of Article 19 of this Law. In the sale of partnership shares, sale costs and litigation or attorney costs are not deducted from the share of shareholders who have no membership of, affiliation with or connection to structures, formations or groups determined to pose a threat to national security or terrorist organisations.
(2) If it is decided to sell company assets as a commercial and economic whole, the Fund Board is authorised to pay past debts from the tender price or have the tender buyer pay them, provided these debts are based on a genuine goods or services relationship with persons having no membership of, affiliation with or connection to the FETÖ/PDY terrorist organisation and meet the conditions in Article 134 of Law No. 5411.
(3) The provisions of this article also apply where assets of closed institutions, organisations, private radio and televisions, newspapers, magazines, publishing houses and distribution channels or the companies to which they belong taken over by the Treasury are transferred by the Ministry of Finance to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund for sale and liquidation. Amounts obtained from the sale of transferred assets are transferred to the Ministry of Finance."
According to these provisions and explanations, the exemption provisions in subparagraph (f) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Corporate Tax Law will be benefited from where the sale gain is obtained from the transfer or sale of owned immovables to the creditor banks or the SDIF and used to settle these debts, and it is not possible for you to benefit from those exemption provisions for your sale gain from a sale to a third party to be used to finance debts to other banks.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.