A driving school company that inflation-adjusted its training vehicles at end-2023 and sold them in 2024 below adjusted value asked whether the resulting loss is deductible.
The Administration's view:
- Under TPL Repeated Art. 298/A, inflation adjustment differences on disposed assets are deemed cost.
- Under Art. 53 of TPL General Communiqué No. 555, only for non-depreciable items sold below adjusted value is the loss corresponding to the adjustment difference disregarded; there is no such limitation for depreciable items.
- Therefore the adjusted amount is taken as cost on the sale of the vehicles, and the entire sale loss computed under TPL 328 can be deducted from corporate income.
The ruling is relevant to companies selling depreciable assets after inflation adjustment.
Full text
Subject: Treatment of inflation adjustment differences on the sale of depreciated driving school training vehicles
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
From the examination of your ruling request form referred to above, it is understood that, stating that your Company operates as a private driving school, and that driving school training vehicles in the "254-Vehicles" account of your balance sheet, among depreciable economic assets used in your activity on which 2023 inflation adjustment was made, were sold in 2024 for less than the value resulting from inflation adjustment, our Directorate's opinion is requested on whether the resulting sale loss will be deducted from the commercial profit base or treated as a non-deductible expense.
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in Article 328:
"Where depreciable economic assets are sold, the difference between the price received and their value recorded in the inventory book is transferred to the profit and loss account. Taxpayers keeping books on the operating account basis and those keeping self-employment income books record this difference in their books as revenue or expense.
The value of those for which depreciation has been set aside is the amount remaining after deducting the depreciation set aside.
...",
- in paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298:
"Non-monetary items in financial statements are subject to inflation adjustment under the following provisions.
1. Income and corporate taxpayers determining their income on the balance sheet basis subject their financial statements to inflation adjustment if the increase in the price index exceeds 100% in the last three accounting periods including the current period and 10% in the current accounting period. The inflation adjustment application ends if both conditions are not met together.
Taxpayers within the scope must prepare financial statements and make inflation adjustment as of the end of provisional tax periods. In determining the above rates in provisional tax periods, the previous thirty-six months including the last month of the quarterly periods are taken into account instead of the last three accounting periods, and the last twelve months instead of the current accounting period. If adjustment is made in any of the provisional tax periods within an accounting period, adjustment is also made in the following provisional tax periods and at the end of the current accounting period.
...
2. In the application of this article
a) Non-monetary items means items other than monetary items,
b) Monetary items means items whose nominal values remain the same despite changes in the value of the Turkish Lira but whose purchasing power changes inversely with price movements (foreign currencies are also treated as monetary items),
...
5. ...
Where values subject to inflation adjustment are disposed of, the inflation adjustment differences relating to them are deemed cost.",
- in Provisional Article 33:
"...
Financial statements dated 31/12/2023 are subject to inflation adjustment regardless of whether the inflation adjustment conditions have arisen. The profit/loss difference arising from the inflation adjustment is shown in the prior years' profit/loss account. Prior-year profit so determined is not taxed, and prior-year loss is not accepted as a loss.
...
The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for the application of this article."
In addition, the procedures and principles of financial statements to be subject to inflation adjustment and adjustment transactions to be made for the end of the 2023 accounting period and, depending on the conditions arising/existing, for following accounting periods (including provisional tax periods) were determined by Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 555, and additional regulations/explanations on the matter were made in Tax Procedure Law Circular No. 165. By Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 560, it was deemed appropriate that taxpayers within the scope (except taxpayers within subparagraph (9) of paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298 of the same Law) not make inflation adjustment in the first provisional tax period of calendar year 2024, in which the inflation adjustment conditions arose.
In this context, Article 53 titled "Subsequent disposal of non-monetary items in the inflation-adjusted balance sheet" of Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 555 states:
"(1) Under subparagraph (1) of paragraph (A) of Repeated Article 298 of Law No. 213, where non-monetary items subject to inflation adjustment are disposed of, the inflation adjustment differences relating to them will be taken into account as cost.
However, where non-depreciable items among non-monetary items in the adjusted balance sheet for the end of the 2023 accounting period are sold for less than their adjusted values, the loss corresponding to the difference between the post-adjustment value and the pre-adjustment value will not be taken into account in determining the income or corporate tax base.
..."
Under this explanation, where non-depreciable items are sold for less than their adjusted values, it is not possible to take into account in determining the income or corporate tax base the loss corresponding to the difference between the post-adjustment value and the pre-adjustment value, while it is possible to take into account in determining corporate income the loss arising where depreciable items are sold for less than their adjusted values.
Accordingly, in the sale of your depreciable vehicles subject to inflation adjustment by your Company, it is possible to take the post-inflation-adjustment amount into account as cost and to take into account in determining your corporate income the entire sale loss calculated as specified in Article 328 of Law No. 213.
For your information.
(*) This ruling has been issued under Article 413 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213.
(**) This ruling is invalid if incorrect information has been provided on this matter while it is under tax examination, judicial review or settlement.
(***) If you act in accordance with this ruling issued at your request and tax has to be assessed as a result, no tax penalty will be imposed on you and no late payment interest will be calculated on the tax assessed.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.