A residential developer that gives buyers a three-year rent guarantee, paying the committed amount if the flat is vacant or the difference if leased, asked about withholding, deductibility, VAT and documentation of these payments.
The Administration's view:
- If documented with evidential documents, the payments are marketing and sales expenses deductible from corporate income under ITL 40/1.
- Since the payments are not based on a lease, no withholding is made under ITL 94; for the buyer they are movable capital income compensating for rental income, declared if the ITL 86/1-d threshold is exceeded.
- If the recipient is obliged to issue invoices under TPL 232, they issue an invoice to the company; otherwise the company issues an expense voucher.
- As the payments are not consideration for any delivery or service, they are outside the scope of VAT.
The ruling is relevant to developers selling homes with rent guarantees and to buyers of such homes.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of rent paid to flat owners under a rent-guaranteed agreement
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
….
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that you are engaged in constructing residential buildings, that to increase sales you make rent-guaranteed sales agreements under which you give buyers of real estate a rent guarantee for 3 years, that you also find tenants for the purchased properties, that a lease is made between the tenant found and the property owner and the tenant pays the rent to the property owner, and that if the lease amount is below the rent commitment made by your company, the difference is paid to the property owner by your company, it is understood that information is requested on whether rent withholding is to be made on payments of the full committed amount if the property is vacant, or on payments for the difference between the rent and the committed amount if the property is leased, under the rent-guaranteed agreement, whether these payments can be expensed for corporate tax, whether they are subject to value added tax and how the payments are to be documented; our Presidency's opinion is set out below.
1- UNDER THE INCOME AND CORPORATE TAX LAWS:
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers in an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on commercial income apply in determining net corporate income.
Article 37 of Income Tax Law No. 193 states that earnings from all kinds of commercial and industrial activities are business income, and the first paragraph of Article 38 provides:
"Business income on the balance sheet basis is the positive difference between the values of the equity in the enterprise at the end and at the beginning of the accounting period. During this period, by the owner or owners:
Values added to the business are deducted from this difference;
Values withdrawn from the business are added to the difference.
In determining business income in this way, the valuation provisions of the Tax Procedure Law and Articles 40 and 41 of this law are complied with."
Article 40 of the same Law lists the expenses deductible in determining net income, and subparagraph (1) of the first paragraph of that article provides that general expenses incurred to obtain and maintain business income may be deducted in determining net business income.
For general expenses incurred to obtain and maintain business income to be deductible, they must be incurred to obtain and maintain income, no fixed asset must be acquired in return, and the expense must not be one to be added to the cost of the economic enterprise. In general, stationery, cleaning, heating, lighting, water and telephone expenses, workplace and vehicle expenses, representation and entertainment expenses proportionate to the business, normal maintenance and repair expenses of real estate and fixed assets valued like real estate, insurance expenses, financing expenses, marketing, sales and distribution expenses, advertising expenses, commissions paid to persons abroad, defective product returns and commission expenses are such expenses.
Under these provisions, the rent amount to be paid by your company to flat owners, under the rent-guaranteed sales agreement between your company and the customers to whom you sold flats to increase your sales, where the flats you sold and owned by your customers cannot be leased, or the payments made for the difference between the rent and the committed amount if the property is leased, can be accepted as marketing and sales expenses and deducted in determining corporate income under the first paragraph of Article 40 of the Income Tax Law, if documented by evidential documents.
Article 70 of that Law provides that income obtained from leasing the goods and rights listed in subparagraphs of the article by their owners, possessors, holders, servitude and usufruct right holders or tenants is income from immovable capital, and that if these goods and rights are included in a commercial or agricultural enterprise, their income is calculated under the relevant provisions in determining commercial or agricultural income.
The first paragraph of Article 75 of that Law provides that dividends, interest, rent and similar income obtained by the owner, outside his commercial, agricultural or professional activity, due to capital consisting of cash capital or values represented by money are income from movable capital.
Article 86 titled "Cases where aggregation is not made" of the same Law provides:
"No annual return is filed for the income listed below, and where a return is filed for other income, this income is not included in the return.
1. Under full liability;
...
d) Income from movable and immovable capital obtained in a calendar year, not subject to withholding or exemption, the total of which does not exceed 600 million liras (TL 2,600 for 2020 per Income Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 310).
..."
Article 94 of that Law provides that those listed in the first paragraph of the article are obliged, when making the payments listed in the subparagraphs of that article (including advances) in cash or on account, to withhold against the income tax of the beneficiaries.
On the other hand, from the examination of the "…." attached to the ruling request form, it is understood that under the protocol all leasing authority over the property belongs to their company or a leasing company designated by it, that if the property cannot be leased their company undertakes to make monthly rent payments for 3 years, that the rent guarantee is …. including withholding, and that the property owner accepts not to use the property subject to the protocol during the guarantee period.
According to these provisions and explanations, there is no need to withhold income tax under Article 94 of the Income Tax Law on payments not based on a property leasing transaction but essentially envisaged by your company within its real estate sales and marketing strategy; these payments, committed by the rent-guaranteed sales agreement, not essentially based on a leasing transaction but in the nature of compensation for rental income, must be taxed as income from movable capital under Article 75 of the Income Tax Law for the recipients, and if the declaration thresholds for the relevant calendar years for "income from movable capital not subject to withholding or exemption" in sub-subparagraph (d) of subparagraph (1) of the first paragraph of Article 86 of that Law are exceeded, these payments must be declared by the recipients as income from movable capital with the annual income tax return.
2- UNDER THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Under the provision in the first paragraph of Article 227 of Tax Procedure Law No. 213, "Unless otherwise provided in this Law, it is mandatory to document the records kept under this Law relating to relations and transactions with third parties", our tax system has adopted the issuance of a document by taxpayers for deliveries of goods, services and other transactions, and these transactions must essentially be documented with any of the documents in Article 229 et seq. of that Law.
The same Law provides:
- in Article 229, that an invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work, showing the amount owed by the customer for the goods sold or work done,
- in Article 231/5, that the invoice is issued within a maximum of seven days from the delivery of goods or performance of the service, and invoices not issued within this period are deemed never issued,
- in Article 232, that first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simplified method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged to issue invoices for goods sold or work done to first and second class merchants, self-employed persons, merchants whose income is determined under the simplified method, farmers obliged to keep books and tax-exempt artisans, and these are obliged to request and receive invoices; and that for others, it is mandatory for the seller or performer to issue an invoice if the price of goods bought from or work done by first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simplified method and farmers obliged to keep books exceeds 50,000,000 liras (TL 1,400 for 2020) or, even if less, if they request it,
- in Article 234, that the expense voucher to be drawn up by first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simplified method and self-employed persons and farmers obliged to keep books for work done by or goods bought from tax-exempt artisans and signed by the performer or seller is deemed an invoice issued by the tax-exempt artisan.
In addition, since an invoice is a document relating to accrual, its issuance depends not on payment of the price but on delivery of goods or performance of the service, and in services in the form of leasing the taxable event occurs with the performance of the service.
Accordingly, within the rent guarantee given to owners of flats sold by your company, where all or part of the guaranteed rent is paid by your company to the flat owner because the flat remains vacant or is leased by the owner for less than the guaranteed rent, an invoice must be issued in your company's name by the recipient if the recipient is among those obliged to issue invoices under Article 232 of Law No. 213; otherwise your company must issue an expense voucher.
3- UNDER THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Turkey within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to VAT,
- in Article 20, that in deliveries and services the base is the consideration for these transactions, and that consideration means the total of money, goods and benefits, services and values obtained in other ways that can be represented in money, received in any way or owed by those receiving the goods or services or acting on their behalf in return for these transactions.
Accordingly, payments of the amount committed by your Company to be paid to the other party if the property is vacant, and payments for the difference between the rent and the committed amount if the property is leased, within the rent-guaranteed sales agreement, are outside the scope of VAT since they do not constitute consideration for any delivery or service.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.