TREN
Contact us

A Public Benefit Association's Property Sale Without Commercial Organisation and Continuity Does Not Create an Economic Enterprise and Is Not Subject to CT or VAT

VATA Public Benefit Association's Property Sale Without Commercial Organisation and Continuity Does Not Create an Economic Enterprise and Is Not Subject to CT or VATPrivate ruling · 30 May 2024
Rast note

A public benefit association with an economic enterprise unrelated to real estate asked about the tax consequences of selling real estate registered in its name.

The Administration's view:

  • The association has no corporate tax liability by virtue of its legal personality.
  • If properties are sold within the market economy, within an organisation, for a commercial purpose and on a continuous basis, a second economic enterprise attached to the association arises; the gain is subject to corporate tax at that enterprise and the sale to VAT under VATL 1/3-g.
  • If the sale is aimed only at removing the property from the association's ownership without a commercial purpose, no separate economic enterprise arises, and the sale (other than by auction) is not subject to VAT.

The ruling is relevant to associations and foundations selling real estate.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Sale of real estate owned by a public benefit association
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

In your ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Association has public benefit association status and has an economic enterprise, our Presidency's opinion is requested on the treatment of the sale of the real estate registered in your association's name in terms of VAT liability.

IN TERMS OF CORPORATE TAX

Subparagraph (ç) of the first paragraph of Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 brings the income of economic enterprises belonging to associations or foundations within the scope of corporate tax; the fifth paragraph of Article 2 of the same Law provides that commercial, industrial and agricultural enterprises belonging to or attached to associations or foundations, whose activities are continuous and which fall outside the first and second paragraphs, are economic enterprises; and the sixth paragraph of that article provides that the fact that public economic institutions and economic enterprises of associations or foundations do not pursue profit, that their activities are among duties given by law, that they lack legal personality, and that they have no independent accounting or capital or place of business allocated to them does not affect their tax liability, and that the price of goods or services covering only cost, not making a profit, or allocating profit to founding purposes does not change their economic nature.

Section (2.3.1.) of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1, containing explanations on applying that Law, states that the explanations in section (2.4) of the Communiqué should be considered in determining whether a public economic institution constitutes a commercial, industrial or agricultural enterprise.

Section (2.4.) of that Communiqué explains that the distinctive features of enterprises in determining an economic enterprise are dependence, continuity and the activity being commercial, industrial or agricultural in nature; in other words, the elements of an economic enterprise are activities such as buying and selling goods, manufacturing or performing services for consideration within the market economy in connection with an organisation, which are also basic features of commercial activity; that instead of listing such cases one by one, the Law covers all economic activities carried on by an association or foundation within the market economy; and that the price of goods or services sold covering only cost, not making a profit, or allocating profit to founding purposes does not change their character as an economic enterprise.

On the other hand, examination of our GİBintranet records shows that the field of activity of your Association's economic enterprise is "Sale of …" and that there are no activities relating to buying, selling or leasing real estate.

Within the framework of the above provisions and explanations, although your Association has no corporate tax liability by virtue of its legal personality, if the real estate owned by your Association is sold within the market economy and within an organisation, pursuing a commercial purpose, in a continuous manner, a second economic enterprise attached to your Association will arise, and the gains from that real estate sale will be subject to corporate tax at this economic enterprise.

However, if that real estate sale is aimed only at removing the property from the association's ownership without pursuing any commercial purpose and is not an activity of continuous real estate buying and selling within any organisation, no separate economic enterprise will arise within your Association due to this sale.

IN TERMS OF VALUE ADDED TAX

Value Added Tax (VAT) Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Türkiye within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activity are subject to VAT,
- in Article 1/3-d, that sales made at auction venues are subject to VAT,
- in Article 1/3-g, that commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional deliveries and services of establishments belonging or attached to, or established or operated by, general and annexed budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and unions they form, universities, associations and foundations, and all kinds of professional organisations, and of revolving fund organisations or other establishments belonging or attached to them, are subject to VAT.

Section (I/B-2) titled "Taxation of Public Institutions and Organisations, Associations and Foundations and Professional Organisations" of the VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:

"2.1. In General
Deliveries and services of general budget administrations, special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages and unions they form, universities, associations and foundations, and all kinds of professional organisations listed in Article (1/3-g) of Law No. 3065 that do not fall within commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activity and are in line with their founding purposes are not subject to tax.
…
On the other hand, establishments belonging or attached to, or established and operated by, the organisations listed above and revolving fund organisations are considered economic enterprises. Their commercial, industrial, agricultural and professional activities are taxed. In this framework, municipal bus, gas, water, electricity, slaughterhouse, cold storage etc. enterprises and revolving fund organisations are subject to tax for their activities not within the exemption."

Accordingly, if the real estate owned by your Association is sold within the market economy and within an organisation, pursuing a commercial purpose, in a continuous manner, an economic enterprise attached to your Association will arise, and the real estate sale of this economic enterprise will be subject to VAT under Article 1/3-g of Law No. 3065.

On the other hand, if no economic enterprise arises within your Association due to the real estate sale, the real estate sale made (excluding sales by auction) will not be subject to VAT.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.