TREN
Contact us

Rail Welding Work Under an Undertaking Spanning More Than One Year Is a Multi-Year Construction Work; CT Withholding and 4/10 VAT Withholding Apply to Progress Billings

VAT · WithholdingRail Welding Work Under an Undertaking Spanning More Than One Year Is a Multi-Year Construction Work; CT Withholding and 4/10 VAT Withholding Apply to Progress BillingsPrivate ruling · 28 May 2024
Rast note

A company maintaining and repairing railway lines asked whether rail welding work under a contract with the state railways extending into the next year is a multi-year construction work, and whether CT withholding on payments and VAT withholding on progress invoices apply.

The Administration's view:

  • ITL 42 requires together that the work be construction and repair work, extend over more than one calendar year and be carried out under an undertaking.
  • Rail welding work spanning more than one calendar year and done under an undertaking is construction and repair work under ITL 42; corporate tax is withheld from progress payments under CTL 15/1-a from the start of the work.
  • As the state railways is a designated buyer under the VAT General Implementation Communiqué, the work is treated as construction work and 4/10 VAT withholding applies on the invoice.

The ruling is relevant to contractors performing railway and similar infrastructure maintenance and repair for public bodies.

ShareLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Full text

Subject: Whether rail welding work is a multi-year construction work
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.

Examination of your ruling request form and its annexes shows that, stating that your Company carries out maintenance and repair of railway lines, that a contract was signed on … with the General Directorate of Turkish State Railways for the work of making a total of … rail welds, consisting of … … welds and … … rail welds, in the …, … and … Regional Directorates, that the contract period is … months, and that the completion date of the work extends into subsequent years, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the work is to be considered a multi-year construction work and whether corporate tax withholding is to be applied to payments and VAT withholding to progress billing invoices.

I- IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW;

Article 42 of Income Tax Law No. 193 provides:

"In construction and repair works extending over more than one calendar year, profit or loss is determined definitively in the year the work is completed, and the whole is deemed income of that year and shown in that year's return."

For a work to be considered within Article 42 of the Income Tax Law, the conditions that the subject of activity is construction and repair work, that the construction and repair work extends over more than one calendar year, and that the construction and repair work is carried out under an undertaking must be sought together.

On the other hand, the first paragraph of Article 15 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that those obliged to withhold tax shall withhold tax on payments made in cash or on account, including advances, to entities, and subparagraph (a) of the same paragraph provides that tax is withheld from progress payments made to entities engaged in construction and repair works extending over more than one calendar year under the principles in the Income Tax Law relating to these works. Under Council of Ministers Decision No. 2009/14594 issued under the authority of that article, that withholding rate was set at 3%, and under the authority in this article the withholding rate was set at 5% by Presidential Decision No. 3491 dated 3/2/2021.

On the other hand, Article 4 of Public Procurement Law No. 4734 provides:

"- Service: means maintenance and repair, transport, communication, insurance, research and development, accounting, market research and surveys, consultancy, promotion, printing and publishing, cleaning, food preparation and distribution, meetings, organisation, exhibition, protection and security, vocational training, photography, film, intellectual and fine arts, services for computer systems and software services, leasing of movable and immovable property and rights, and similar other services,
- Construction: means all kinds of construction works such as buildings, roads, railways, motorways, airports, quays, ports, shipyards, bridges, tunnels, metros, viaducts, sports facilities, infrastructure, pipelines, communication and power transmission lines, dams, power plants, refineries, irrigation facilities, land reclamation, flood protection and stripping, and installation, manufacturing, preparation, transport, completion, major repair, restoration, landscaping, drilling, demolition, strengthening and assembly works relating to these works and similar construction works."

It is understood that the TCDD Standard Service Procurement Contract for the work of making a total of … rail welds, consisting of … … welds and … … rail welds, in the …, … and … Regional Directorates, attached to the ruling request form, was signed by the parties on …; that Article 5 of that contract provides that the technical specifications and other details of the work are set out in the documents annexed to the contract forming the tender documents; Article 10 that the contract period is … months following site delivery; Article 11 that the place of work is the region of the …, … and … Regional Directorates; Article 11.2 that site delivery will be made within at most 10 calendar days following signature of the contract and work will be ready to start within at most 10 working days following site delivery; and that the Unit Price Bid Schedule shows the work includes welding rails and stress relieving of rails.

According to the above provisions and explanations, the work of making a total of … rail welds, consisting of … … welds and … … rail welds, in the …, … and … Regional Directorates over … months under the contract signed on … between your Company and the General Directorate of Turkish State Railways must be considered within construction and repair work under Article 42 of the Income Tax Law, since it extends over more than one calendar year and is carried out under an undertaking.

Accordingly, corporate tax must be withheld under subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 15 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 from progress payments to be made from the date that construction and repair work begins.

II- IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX LAW;

VAT Law No. 3065 provides:

- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activity made in Türkiye are subject to VAT,
- in Article 9/1, that our Ministry is authorised to hold parties to taxable transactions responsible for payment of the tax receivable in order to secure it,
- in Article 10/a, that in cases of delivery of goods and performance of services, the taxable event occurs upon delivery of the goods or performance of the service.

The VAT General Implementation Communiqué states:

- in section "I/C-2.1.3.2.1. Construction Works and Engineering, Architecture and Survey-Project Services Performed Together with These Works":

"2.1.3.2.1.1. Buyers Applying Withholding and Withholding Rate
- In construction works performed for those listed in subsection (I/C-2.1.3.1/b),
- construction works performed for those listed in subsection (I/C-2.1.3.1/a) with a VAT-inclusive price of TL 5 million or more,
and engineering-architecture and survey-project services performed together with these construction works, VAT withholding at the rate of (4/10) is applied by the buyers.
Where the work price later exceeds TL 5 million due to expansion of the project, updating of the contract price and similar reasons, withholding is applied from the date this situation arises.
2.1.3.2.1.2. Scope
The following services fall within this section:
- All kinds of construction works relating to buildings, roads, railways, motorways, airports, quays, ports, shipyards, bridges, tunnels, metros, viaducts, sports facilities, infrastructure, pipelines, communication and power transmission lines, dams, power plants, refineries, irrigation facilities, land reclamation, stripping, flood protection and the like.
- Installation, manufacturing, preparation, transport, heating and cooling systems, sound systems, video systems, lighting systems, completion, all kinds of maintenance and repair including painting, decoration, restoration, landscaping, stripping, drilling, demolition, strengthening, assembly, disassembly and similar works relating to the above structures and construction works. These works are also subject to withholding in this scope where they relate to the above structures but are carried out after or independently of the construction work.
...
In construction works transferred by contractors wholly or partly to subcontractors or further subcontractors, withholding is made by each contractor transferring the work on the VAT on the service performed for it."

- in section "I/Ç-1. Occurrence of the Taxable Event":

"...
In progress billing transactions, for the progress payment obtained for the service provided, the taxable event occurs on the date the acceptance report documenting the accrual of the progress payment is issued, in other words, on the date the progress report is approved."

Accordingly, the "work of making a total of … rail welds, consisting of … … welds and … … rail welds, in the …, … and … Regional Directorates" performed by your Company for the General Directorate of Turkish State Railways, which is among the designated buyers listed in subsection (I/C.2.1.3.1/b) of the Communiqué, must be considered within construction works and engineering-architecture and survey-project services performed together with these works, and VAT withholding at the rate of (4/10) must be applied in the invoice to be issued under section (I/C-2.1.3.2.1.1) of the Communiqué.

For your information.

Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.