A cooperative liable to corporate tax asked about the tax treatment of monthly dues collected from members and in-kind and cash donations it receives, whether dues require an invoice and VAT, and whether it must issue e-producer receipts for goat milk to be bought for soap-making from farmers not keeping books.
The Administration's view:
- Corporate tax: dues collected from members and in-kind and cash donations are elements of corporate income of a CT-liable cooperative.
- VAT: dues that are an element of corporate income are subject to VAT; late-payment interest is included in the base under VATL 24/c. Cash donations without consideration are outside the scope of VAT; in-kind donations by VAT taxpayers are subject to VAT under general rules.
- Documentation: an invoice or retail sales document is issued for dues. A taxpayer donor issues an invoice at arm's length for an in-kind donation; for a non-taxpayer donor the cooperative issues an expense voucher.
- A producer receipt is issued for goat milk bought from farmers not keeping books; if the cooperative is subject to mandatory e-Invoice or within Law No. 5957, it must issue an e-producer receipt.
The ruling is relevant to cooperatives liable to corporate tax.
Full text
Subject: Taxation of dues and donation income of a cooperative
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that your Cooperative, established on … and with corporate tax liability since then, resolved at its ordinary general meeting on … to collect monthly dues from its members to cover expenses, that your Cooperative also decided to make soap in order to operate in various fields and wishes to buy goat milk from local producers (farmers not subject to bookkeeping) for this, our Presidency's opinion is requested on whether the dues collected will be taken into account as income in determining period income, whether an invoice is to be issued and VAT calculated for these dues, whether an e-producer receipt is to be issued for goat milk purchases from local producers, and how in-kind donations made to your Cooperative are to be shown in books and documents.
IN TERMS OF THE CORPORATE TAX LAW:
Subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 1 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 states that the income of cooperatives is subject to corporate tax, and subparagraph (k) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Law provides:
"Excluding consumer and transport cooperatives, cooperatives whose articles of association contain provisions that profit is not distributed on capital, no share of profit is given to the chair and members of the board of directors, reserves are not distributed to members and business is done only with members, and which actually comply with these provisions, and, in addition to these restrictions and conditions, building cooperatives that from establishment until the completion of construction do not include in their management and supervisory boards natural persons and representatives of legal entities undertaking those construction works partly or wholly, persons deemed related to them under Article 13 of the Law, or persons in an employer-employee relationship with those listed above, and whose building permit and land title are registered in the name of the cooperative's legal entity. (Transactions of cooperatives with persons other than their members and transactions with their members on matters not in the cooperative's articles of association are "non-member" transactions. Disposal by cooperatives of depreciable economic assets such as fixtures, machinery, equipment, vehicles and similar allocated to the performance of the activity that have completed their economic life, and building cooperatives obtaining a workplace or dwelling for each share by giving their own land in exchange for floors, are not deemed non-member transactions. Due to non-member transactions of cooperatives, a separate economic enterprise attached to the cooperative's legal entity is deemed to arise. Cooperatives earning income from their economic enterprises and from participations in the capital of another fully liable entity and later distributing this income to members does not affect the exemption. The procedures and principles for taxing income from non-member transactions are determined by the Ministry of Finance.)"
Section "4.13. Cooperatives" of Corporate Tax General Communiqué Serial No. 1 contains detailed explanations on the subject.
According to these provisions and explanations, dues collected from members by your Cooperative, which has corporate tax liability, and in-kind and cash donations made to your Cooperative must be considered an element of corporate income and taken into account in determining taxable corporate income.
IN TERMS OF THE VALUE ADDED TAX (VAT) LAW:
VAT Law No. 3065 provides:
- in Article 1/1, that deliveries and services made in Türkiye within commercial, industrial, agricultural and self-employment activities are subject to value added tax,
- in Article 20/1, that the tax base is the consideration constituting the counterpart of delivery and service transactions,
- in Article 20/2, that the term consideration means the total of money, goods and other benefits, services and values that can be represented in money, received in any manner from those receiving the goods or services or those acting on their behalf in return for these transactions or owed by them,
- in Article 24/c, that various income such as maturity differences, price differences, exchange differences, interest and premiums, and all kinds of benefits, services and values provided under names such as service and the like are included in the base.
Section "1.3. Dues" of VAT Circular No. 60 states that dues received from members or participants are outside the scope of VAT provided they do not constitute consideration for any delivery or service, but that dues payments made in return for commercial deliveries and services of a cooperative with corporate tax liability and deemed an element of corporate income will be subject to VAT, for example dues payments made by members of cooperatives with corporate tax liability such as consumer and transport cooperatives and deemed an element of corporate income are subject to VAT, while dues collected by a cooperative without corporate tax liability to cover common expenses (meeting members' needs such as security, gardening, maintenance of pool and social facilities, electricity and water) will not be subject to VAT as they are not commercial in nature.
Accordingly, dues received from members by your Cooperative, which has corporate tax liability, that are an element of corporate income are subject to VAT, and interest amounts calculated because members did not pay their dues on time will be included in the VAT base under Article 24/c of Law No. 3065.
On the other hand, cash donations made to your Cooperative are outside the scope of VAT provided they do not constitute consideration for any delivery or service. In-kind donations made to your Cooperative by VAT taxpayers will be subject to VAT under general provisions.
IN TERMS OF THE TAX PROCEDURE LAW:
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in the first paragraph of Article 227:
"Unless otherwise provided in this Law, it is mandatory to document records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties."
- in Article 229:
"An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work to show the amount the customer owes in return for goods sold or work done."
- in subparagraph (5) of the first paragraph of Article 231:
"The invoice is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. Invoices not issued within this period are deemed never issued."
- in Article 232:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged to give invoices for goods they sell or work they do to, and to request and receive invoices from:
1. First and second class merchants;
2. Self-employed professionals;
3. Merchants whose income is determined under the simple method;
4. Farmers obliged to keep books;
5. Tradesmen exempt from tax.
For others, where the price of goods purchased from or work commissioned to first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books exceeds 50,000,000 lira (TL 2,000 from 1.1.2022, TL 4,400 from 1.1.2023, TL 6,900 from 1.1.2024), or even if less than that if they request it, the seller of the goods or doer of the work must give an invoice."
- in Article 235:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged, when paying for goods purchased from farmers not taxed on the actual basis, to issue a receipt in two copies, sign one and give it to the selling farmer, and have the other signed by them and take it. Where the goods are purchased on behalf of the merchant or farmer by an agent or intermediary, the receipt is issued and signed by them.
In purchases from farmers made on advance, the receipt is given upon delivery of the goods.
The copy of the producer receipt remaining with the merchant or buying farmer replaces the invoice.
..."
In addition, Articles 258 et seq. of that Law contain provisions on valuation of economic assets.
Also, Article 124 of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 lists cooperatives among commercial companies; and Article 89 of Cooperatives Law No. 1163 provides that the provisions of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 apply to the accounting methods and mandatory books of cooperatives, cooperative unions, cooperative central unions and the National Cooperatives Union of Türkiye, that the procedures and principles for applying this article will be determined by a communiqué issued by the Ministry of Trade, and that the related provisions of the Tax Procedure Law are reserved.
Accordingly;
1- Where cooperatives have no commercial activity apart from dues collected to cover common expenses, there is no obligation to issue invoices for dues that are not an element of business income. However, where they have commercial deliveries and services, an invoice, or a retail sales document where there is no obligation to issue an invoice, must also be issued for those dues under general provisions.
Therefore, your Cooperative, which has corporate tax and VAT liabilities, must issue an invoice, or a retail sales document where there is no obligation to issue an invoice, for dues received from your members under general provisions.
2- If cash donations and aid made to your Cooperative, whether from members or non-members, do not constitute consideration for a delivery or service, no invoice needs to be issued for these transactions. However, if donations or aid are received as consideration for deliveries and services made by your Cooperative, there is an obligation to issue an invoice on these donations and aid under general provisions.
3- For in-kind donations and aid made to your Cooperative by members or non-members, if the donor is a taxpayer, an invoice must be issued by them in your Cooperative's name under general provisions at arm's length value, including information leaving no room for doubt about the nature of the transaction, and your Cooperative must record the economic asset subject to the in-kind donation/aid based on that document.
If the donor is not a taxpayer, your Cooperative must issue an expense voucher under general provisions at arm's length value, including information leaving no room for doubt about the true nature of the transaction, and record the economic asset subject to the in-kind donation/aid based on this document.
4- For your purchases of goat milk from farmers not taxed on the actual basis (not obliged to keep books), your Cooperative must issue a producer receipt in their name when paying the price.
5- Explanations on applying the uniform accounting system are given in Accounting System Implementation General Communiqué No. 1 published in Official Gazette No. 21447 repeated dated 26/12/1992 and other communiqués published later on this subject, and it goes without saying that your transactions must be recorded in line with those communiqués.
The second paragraph of Repeated Article 242 of the same Law provides that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to determine the procedures and principles for creating, recording, transmitting, keeping and submitting electronic books, records and documents and for keeping and issuing books and documents electronically. That paragraph also provides that provisions on books, records and documents in the Tax Procedure Law and other tax laws also apply to electronic books, records and documents, and that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to set procedures and principles for electronic books, documents and records different from those for other books, documents and records.
The first paragraph of Repeated Article 257 of the Law provides that the Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to set accounting procedures and principles by taxpayer and professional groups, to determine the nature, form and mandatory content of books and documents kept under this Law and of additional books and documents it deems appropriate to be kept or issued, to amend them, to print and distribute them for a fee or have third parties print and distribute them, to have their records kept, and to impose or remove obligations to certify, keep and submit these books and documents.
In this regard, Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué No. 509 published in Official Gazette No. 30923 dated 19/10/2019 states:
- in section "IV.5.2. Joining the e-Producer Receipt Application":
"The e-Producer Receipt application is not mandatory for taxpayers other than those specified in section "IV.5.4." of this Communiqué, and taxpayers wishing to join the application must:
a) be included in the e-Invoice application,
b) have completed the necessary preparations to issue and transmit e-Producer Receipts in accordance with the procedures and principles explained in this Communiqué,
c) make the necessary application to join the e-Producer Receipt application in accordance with the methods of use and application principles specified in section "V.1." of this Communiqué."
- in section "IV.5.4. Obligation to Switch to the e-Producer Receipt Application":
"Among taxpayers obliged to switch to the e-Invoice application, those who are also obliged by their activities to issue producer receipts, taxpayers engaged in fruit and vegetable trade as commission agents or merchants under Law No. 5957 dated 11/3/2010 on Regulating the Trade of Fruits and Vegetables and Other Goods with Sufficient Supply and Demand Depth, and taxpayers on whom the Presidency has imposed an obligation to switch to the e-Producer Receipt application must issue producer receipts they issue from the date specified in section "IV.5.5." of this Communiqué as "e-Producer Receipts".
The Presidency is authorised to impose an obligation to switch to the e-Producer Receipt application on taxpayers or taxpayer groups determined as risky or of low tax compliance as a result of analysis or audit work, regardless of activity, sector and turnover, by giving written notification and at least 3 months for transition preparations. Taxpayers given written notification must join the e-Producer Receipt application within the periods specified in the written notification. Taxpayers given written notification must, by joining the e-Producer Receipt application within the periods specified in the letter, issue producer receipts for purchases from their suppliers in this scope as e-Producer Receipts. Provisions in the Law apply to taxpayers not complying with this obligation."
Accordingly, if your Cooperative is obliged to switch to the e-Invoice application or is a taxpayer engaged in fruit and vegetable trade as a commission agent or merchant under Law No. 5957 dated 11/3/2010 on Regulating the Trade of Fruits and Vegetables and Other Goods with Sufficient Supply and Demand Depth, there is an obligation to issue e-producer receipts for goat milk purchases from local producers (farmers not subject to bookkeeping).
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.