An accounting firm appointed by the bankruptcy office to file electronically the corporate tax and VAT returns of a bankrupt company, for a monthly fee, asked whether tax is withheld on the fee and how stamp duty is calculated.
The Administration's view:
- The appointed company issues an invoice monthly, within 7 days after each month end, in the name of the company served, and adds the amount to its corporate income.
- No corporate tax is withheld on the fee paid by the bankruptcy office.
- As the payment is a service purchase by the bankruptcy office, papers issued for the payments are subject to stamp duty on the VAT-exclusive amount under SDL Table (1) IV/1-a.
The ruling is relevant to accounting and similar service firms appointed by bankruptcy administrations.
Full text
Subject: Withholding on fees received by an accounting firm appointed by the bankruptcy administration to file returns for a bankrupt company
Unofficial translation by Rast Partners. The Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.
In the ruling request form referred to above, stating that:
- your company was appointed by the … Office to file electronically the corporate tax and VAT returns of …, whose bankruptcy was ordered by the … Commercial Court of First Instance and which is processed in bankruptcy file … of the … Office,
- under the contract for this appointment, the firm's returns are filed under this contract with the password of the company manager and authorised signatory,
- a monthly fee of … will be paid by the … Office for the return filing service,
our Presidency's opinion is asked on whether income tax is to be withheld on this fee and how stamp duty is to be calculated.
I. In Terms of the Tax Procedure Law and Corporate Tax Law
Article 6 of Corporate Tax Law No. 5520 provides that corporate tax is calculated on the net corporate income obtained by taxpayers within an accounting period and that the provisions of the Income Tax Law on business income apply in determining net corporate income.
Tax Procedure Law No. 213 provides:
- in Article 177:
"The following merchants are in the first class:
...
4. All kinds of commercial companies (ordinary partnerships are subject to whichever of the above subparagraphs their type of business falls within);
..."
- in the first paragraph of Article 227:
"Unless otherwise provided in this law, it is mandatory to document records kept under this law relating to relations and transactions with third parties."
- in Article 229:
"An invoice is a commercial document given to the customer by the merchant selling the goods or doing the work to show the amount the customer owes in return for goods sold or work done."
- in subparagraph (5) of the first paragraph of Article 231:
"5. The invoice is issued within at most seven days from the date of delivery of the goods or performance of the service. The Ministry of Treasury and Finance is authorised to shorten this period or require the invoice to be issued at the time of delivery or performance, taking into account separately or together the type, quantity, price and amount of the goods or service, the manner of sale, field of activity, sector or type of tax liability. Invoices not issued within these periods are deemed never issued."
- in Article 232:
"First and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books are obliged to give invoices for goods they sell or work they do to:
1. First and second class merchants;
2. Self-employed professionals;
3. Merchants whose income is determined under the simple method;
4. Farmers obliged to keep books;
5. Tradesmen exempt from tax
and these are obliged to request and receive invoices.
For others, where the price of goods purchased from or work commissioned to first and second class merchants, those whose income is determined under the simple method and farmers obliged to keep books exceeds 50,000,000 lira (TL 2,000 for 2022), or even if less than 50,000,000 lira (TL 2,000 for 2022) if they request it, the seller of the goods or doer of the work must give an invoice."
According to these provisions:
- your company, appointed by the … Office to file the returns of …, must issue an invoice monthly, within 7 days from the end of the relevant month, in the name of that company to which the service is provided, on the monthly service fee, and add this amount to corporate income.
- It goes without saying that no corporate tax withholding will be applied on this fee paid by the … Office.
II. In Terms of the Stamp Duty Law
Law No. 488 provides:
- in Article 1, that the papers listed in Table (1) annexed to this Law are subject to stamp duty, and that the term papers in this Law means documents drawn up by writing and signing or placing a mark replacing a signature that can be submitted to prove or show any matter, and documents created in magnetic media and as electronic data using an electronic signature,
- in Article 3, that the taxpayers of stamp duty are those who sign the papers, that stamp duty on papers relating to transactions between official offices and persons is paid by the persons, and that official office in this Law means general and special budget administrations, special provincial administrations, municipalities and villages,
- in Article 4, that to determine the tax to which a paper is subject, the nature of the paper is examined and the tax in the table is found accordingly, and that in determining the nature of papers, for those whose form is specified in laws their names in the laws are considered and for others the provision and meaning contained in the writing on them,
- in Article 19, that taxes on receipts and papers of this nature subject to proportional tax used in payments of general and special budget offices, special provincial administrations and municipalities, banks, public economic enterprises and their affiliates and establishments and similar enterprises, affiliates and establishments are collected by deduction from the entitlement by the relevant offices and establishments when these payments are made or, for payments by advance, when the advance is given.
Paragraph 1/a of Section "IV. Receipts and other papers" of Table (1) annexed to the Law provides that receipts and release deeds containing a specific amount given by persons to official offices due to payments (including advances) for purchases of goods and services by official offices, and papers ensuring the transfer of these payments on behalf and account of official offices to accounts opened or to be opened in the name of persons or their payment to their order and transfer, are subject to proportional stamp duty.
Stamp Duty Law General Communiqué Serial No. 30 states that, regardless of whether there is any provision on value added tax in the content of papers subject to proportional stamp duty, stamp duty must be calculated only on the price of the work excluding value added tax, and stamp duty on papers drawn up including value added tax must be calculated on the amount remaining after deducting the value added tax.
Accordingly, bankruptcy offices may purchase goods and services from persons to perform their duties arising from laws, and for the reasons mentioned above, payments made to your company appointed to file electronically the corporate tax and VAT returns of … must be considered within the purchase of services.
Therefore, papers drawn up for payments made to your creditor company in return for the service received by the … office due to that appointment (excluding VAT) must be subject to stamp duty under paragraph IV/1-a of Table (1) annexed to Law No. 488.
For your information.
Private rulings bind only the taxpayer who requested them; similar cases should be assessed separately. The English text is an unofficial translation prepared by Rast Partners; the Turkish original published by the Revenue Administration prevails.